Home / General / This Day in Labor History: May 10, 1993

This Day in Labor History: May 10, 1993

Comments
/
/
/
146 Views

On May 10, 1993, the Kader toy factory in the Nakhom Pathom province of Thailand, just outside of Bangkok, caught on fire, killing 188 workers, severely injuring over 500, and breaking the all-time death toll for a factory workplace, previously held by the Triangle Shirtwaist Fire in New York in 1911. The largest workplace disaster in Thai history, the Kader fire should have demonstrated the to the world the very real costs of outsourcing unsafe working conditions to the world’s poor countries. Unfortunately, the event received relatively little media attention and created no momentum for improving safety standards in the world’s factories.

The Kader factory was largely owned by Charoen Pokphand Group, a huge Thai conglomerate with concerns primarily in agribusiness; as of 2003 it was the world’s 5th largest transnational food corporation. CP owned 80% of the factory, the Hong-Kong based Kader Company owned about 20%, including the name. The factory manufactured toys, mostly stuffed animals and plastic dolls, for the international market. It received large contracts from Arco, Hasboro, Tyco, Toys-R-Us, Fisher Price, and other leading toy companies. Approximately 3000 workers toiled in this factory, with about 1500 in Building No. 1. Most of the workers were young women, some underage using fake IDs to get by age restrictions on labor. Thai women frequently add to family income, so many families encouraged their daughters to travel to Bangkok for factory labor.

This factory opened in January 1989, but already had a history of unsafe conditions. The original plant burned in August 1989 and the company’s license was suspended that November. But the Thai Ministry of Industry allowed the new plant to open on July 4, 1990. In February 1993, another fire struck one of the factory buildings. It was still closed when the main fire started in May. Thai law only provided minimum wage for full-time workers. Thus Kader and other manufacturers rarely employed people as full-time laborers. 47% of Thai employers did not pay the minimum wage. Compulsory overtime frequently kept workers until midnight, or even 5 a.m. if a deadline approached. Workers had their pay docked if they did not meet production quotas. On the 4th floor of Kader, 800 workers toiled. On that floor were 8 toilets.

None of this mattered to the American and European corporations outsourcing toy production to the developing world. They sent orders to Kader, demanding exact specifications for their markets, and asked no questions about wages, hours, working conditions, or safety. That was the advantage of outsourcing. These became irrelevant questions for corporations–so long as the costs were kept low. If costs rose, Tyco and Hasboro would move operations to another factory, another country.

At about 4 pm, a small fire broke out in one corner of Building No. 1. No one is really sure how the fire started, although a cigarette seems most likely. The workers were told to continue working. The fire alarm did not work and the fire spread rapidly in a factory full of finished plastic products. Security guards and employees tried to put the fire out but found themselves quickly overwhelmed with a rapidly spreading conflagration that soon spread to Buildings No. 2 and 3. Much like the Triangle Fire of 1911 in the United States, employers had locked the downstairs fire exits in order to maintain more control over workers. Fleeing back upstairs, the workers flooded the upper fire exits, causing them to collapse under all the weight. Workers began jumping from the upper stories to escape the flames. Then the main building collapsed from the heat of the fire. If this sounds much like the procession of events at Triangle, outside of the structural collapse, commenters at the time noted the same thing as well, ranging from a lack of fire safety training to highly combustible industrial products unsafely stored to the high number of women killed.



The dead at Kader.

Said one survivor, “I didn’t know what to do. Finally I had no other choice but to join others and jump out the window. I saw many of my friends lying dead on the ground beside me. I injured my legs but I came out alive.” Said another, “In desperation, I went back and forth looking down below. The smoke was so thick and I picked the best place to jump in a pile of boxes. My sister jumped too. She died.” The symbol of the fire was a melted Bart Simpson doll. The fire took place at the height of The Simpsons craze and the factory is where most Simpsons material was produced.

Melted Bart, symbol of the Kader fire.

Like many horrible factory accidents, shoddy design combined with employer malfeasance and a lack of basic safety standards to create an easily preventable disaster. The building was constructed with uninsulated steel girders that would collapse in 15 minutes during a fire. Basic infrastructure investment, even if none of the other problems had been alleviated, would have likely saved dozens of lives.

Although initially resisting any compensation, CP agreed to pay $8000 to the families of each dead worker and agreed to help pay the education costs of orphaned children. The Thai government announced improved safety and health standards. Prime Minister Chuan Leekpai traveled to the factory site on the night of the tragedy and pledged greater fire safety for Thai workers. But no one from CP or the factory managers received even a day in jail. The management was fined $12,000 for building code violations. Safety and health standards in Thai factories have not improved in any meaningful fashion since 1993, nor have they in many of the other manufacturing nations of southeast Asia. One big reason for this of course is that all the incentive for governments and business owners is to do nothing because the less they do, the more the big American, European, and Japanese corporations are pleased with low costs.

A memorial to Kader victims.

As I have suggested in the aftermath of the Bangladesh fire, now the largest tragedy in the history of industrial factories, with over 900 dead, perhaps the only way to stop corporations from taking advantage of poor nations and corrupt politicians to replicate the terrible working conditions of the Triangle Fire, Kader fire, and Bangladesh building collapse is to tie corporate legal status with their subcontractors’ behavior, making them civilly and criminally responsible for the conditions in factories to which they subcontract work. Otherwise, Disney can make a big stink of pulling out of Bangladesh to make themselves look good without doing anything to help Bangladeshi workers stay alive or ensure that workers in Cambodia, Vietnam, or wherever aren’t subject to the same conditions when no one is looking.

The better details in here came from Fiona Haines, Globalization and Regulatory Character: Regulatory Reform after the Kader Toy Factory Fire

This is the 60th post in this series. Previous posts are archived here.

FacebookTwitterGoogle+Share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • scott

    Thank you so much for your series, it really puts into context that this isn’t about airy abstractions like labor or capital, it’s about the lives of ordinary people. I really appreciate all your efforts along these lines, and I wish that people like Yglesias and co. would eventually get the message as well.

    • Turkle

      Just writing to also say thank you for continuing this excellent series of posts.

  • I am very happy to see this series taking a more international approach.

  • DrDick

    Capitalism kills. At every opportunity and with impunity.

  • Murc

    Nitpick: you type “Hasboro” twice when I think you mean “Hasbro.”

    • LeftWingFox

      Hard to tell once kind of carcinogenic smoke from the other.

  • Bruce Vail

    I wonder if Matt Groening or Fox made any contributions to the orphans fund?

  • Bill Murray

    Don McGlashan did a song about this, which is the only way I heard about it.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aMirYb1EDUA

  • J R in WV

    I put this comment on a dead thread, and thought it was appropriate here as well, hope I’m not breaking a red-line rule of some sort!

    I’d like to nominate a local disaster for the worst ever category: The Hawk’s Nest Tunnel project, starring Union Carbide.

    One problem, though, is that there were so many deaths over the period of this construction project that little documentation exists that can prove the eventual death toll. The project was to build a dam on New River below Hawks’ Nest State Park, and drive a tunnel under Gauley Mountain to a hydroelectric plant, which would produce power for a steel mill that would produce special alloys.

    After driving the tunnel into the mountain, they found that the rock they were excavating was a highly desirable high-silica content sandstone, so valuable that they increased the diameter on the tunnel to make profit from the actual construction. They also refused to use the dust-suppressor water sprays on the machinery, because that slowed the work, lowering profits.

    The miners were a sickly lot, dying like flies of claimed lung problems like silicosis. Many were buried under the railroad track, so not even a headstone! Since this took place during the depression, Union Carbide’s subcontractors had no problem hiring replacements for the malingering dying miners they were burying in piles of waste. Also, too, using sub-contractors would keep Union Carbide from being vulnerable to suits or prosecution for killing hundreds of malingering hard-working tunnel rats.

    I suppose the growing death-toll in Bangladesh will run close to the total of Tunnel murders, And it was 1927-31, a long time ago, and we all know that horrible crimes are much less horrible after 80 years, even though the corporations responsible are still around – Union Carbide as such is nearly gone, Bought up by Dow.

    A Congressional committee found that there were 476 deaths, but the companies only copped to 109, out of a crew of 3,000 or so. Others who have researched the event believe the total was closer to a thousand. Many workers were southern black men, who went home when they got sick, and so died off-site, obviously not a death Union Carbide or the construction company, Rinehart & Dennis could be held responsible for!

    So, while there are lots of questions about the Hawk’s Nest tragedy we can’t answer, I think the fact that it was a long-term continuous project that killed people from nearly day one until the very end of drilling – killed so many we can’t even guess the total – all gives this local accident mass murder a high-enough ranking to at least be mentioned along-side more recent industrial disasters.

    • I’ll look into it.

    • Bexley

      Union Carbide starting as they meant to go on then.

  • Ragout

    Loomis write “Safety and health standards in Thai factories have not improved in any meaningful fashion since 1993.” but he doesn’t cite any particular evidence, and it is very hard to believe. According to the Thai Occupational Safety and Health Bureau, occupational safety has greatly improved in the past decade. For example, the rate of “severe” occupational accidents fell by 43% from 2002 to 2011. Safety was probably improving before 2002 as well, but the report doesn’t go back that far. I suppose it’s possible the Thais are lying, but what is the evidence to support Loomis’s claim?

    • I’m taking it from literature on the issue. I’m not entirely convinced by statistics from the Thai government, although obviously it’s possible. What I don’t understand is why it would be hard to believe. I mean, the people of Bangladesh for instance might suggest that their standards haven’t improved in the last 20 years.

      • Ragout

        One big accident doesn’t suggest anything either way about trends.

      • Ragout

        Also, it’s hard to believe that safety in Thailand hasn’t improved in the last 20 years, because as time marches on, almost all countries (and certainly Thailand) get wealthier and more educated, and so have more resources to devote to safety. Also technology and medical knowledge (e.g., about toxins) gets better, which also increases safety.

  • I am not sure if this has come to your attention or not. But, Dorje Gurung a Nepali chemistry teacher working at Qatar Academy was recently dismissed and later arrested on charges of “insulting Islam” on the basis of a denunciation of 12 year old students. He faces 7 years in prison if convicted. The lack of rights of ex-pat workers in Qatar appears to be definitely a labor issue. The case of Dorje Gurung while having a big presence on FB and news articles on the internet seems to have only hit two blogs so far including my own.

  • Pingback: This Day in Labor History: A Digest - Lawyers, Guns & Money : Lawyers, Guns & Money()

  • Pingback: On this Labor Day, let’s remember what unions have done for America | Fabius Maximus()

It is main inner container footer text