Subscribe via RSS Feed

Otto FTW

[ 57 ] December 20, 2012 |

This needs to become a meme:

j.ottopohl posted a comment in He’s a Lumberjack, and He’s OK: The Wobbly Scholarship of Erik Loomis, Ph.D. · 18 hours ago

I am not a leftist and I did my PhD in the UK and now work in Africa. But, even so I was wondering if this blog could read and review my dissertation. The title is Shallow Roots: The Exile Experiences of Russian-Germans, Crimean Tatars, and Meskhetian Turks in Comparative Perspective and I completed it at the School of Oriental and African Studies at the University of London in 2004. You can find an abstract to the dissertation at the url below.

Not sure we’re meeting the standards of peer review…


Comments (57)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. actor212 says:

    More like a “beer review”

  2. J.W. Hamner says:

    Nice. “I want Wayne LaPierre’s head on a stick!” should be the new euphemism for “Would you please read my dissertation?”

  3. spencer says:

    I’m not gonna click on TheOtherMcCain because I like my blood pressure where it is, but could Otto have been trying (not very successfully, but still) to make a point – that those idiots are not qualified to offer any substantive critique of academic research?

    Other than that, I got nothin’.

    • tt says:

      The point is that it’s exciting and even flattering for someone to read your dissertation. Preferably someone whose opinion you care about but you take what you can get. And honestly, I haven’t read Loomis’s dissertation so I can’t speak to accuracy but the summary looks fairly comprehensive. I admire the work ethic.

    • Vance Maverick says:

      I thought Otto was perfectly successful in making that point. His naturally…deadpan writing style was just right for this. Kudos (but like you, I won’t be getting out of the boat).

  4. Jeremy says:

    The lumberjack headline belongs on a much more positive post of Professor Loomis. I clicked onwards without realizing what cesspool I was venturing into.

    • Timb says:

      Why do white nationalist offend you so much?

      Oh, yeah, right. Too bad you didn’t get to the part of the site where McCain defends Emmett Till’s murderers….cause you know what grinds Glen Reynolds gears? Metaphors, but not defense of racist murder

    • Marcus O. Fazomi says:

      People often do not grasp the specificity original research requires. Dissertations are not greatly expanded high school papers.

  5. rea says:

    Otto can be a pain at times, but sometimes he’s a standup guy. That, I think, is the case here–he’s over there poking them with a metaphorical stick.

  6. Cody says:

    I’m laughing so hard. You all are going to get me in trouble at work.

    Seriously though – I look forward to seeing the blog’s review of Otto’s dissertation. It should be very informative!

  7. Spokane Moderate says:

    I’m pretty sure I’ve never directly interacted with him, but I’ve just gotta say:


  8. SEK says:

    I’m just going to float some balloons … can we call it “pohling”?

  9. Everett Volk says:

    I requested review of my master’s thesis. I think everyone should ask them for some peer review, as well.

  10. mark f says:

    The review of Erik’s dissertation is “By ‘Badger Pundit.'” Intentionally apt?

  11. Erik Loomis says:

    Have to give Otto the credit here. That is pretty bloody funny.

  12. Sherm says:

    Not enough gay sex in Otto’s dissertation to merit their review.

  13. Leeds man says:

    Nice one, Dr. Pohl.

  14. Cheap Wino says:

    Excellent! Judging by the crickets I think it went over most of the people’s heads.

  15. N__B says:

    I will gladly review any dissertation for a mere $0.50 per page. The fee is necessary only to keep me in good cheer beer.

  16. catclub says:

    Anybody else remember the Stephen Fry book, in which Professor Trefusis is asked to comment on some hideously violent ( possibly with sex, too)
    US movie?

    He has no problem with the movie, except for the violence it does to the English language.

    I am not sure why this topic reminded me of it.
    The next thing it reminds me of is Richard Feynmann being the only person to testify in favor of a topless bar.

  17. Rhino says:

    I am slowly becoming convinced that Otto is some kind of fairly deep piece of what I can only call performance art being developed here in our corner of the net. The strange combination of depth shown here with the irascibly shallow nature of his ongoingStalin schtick just kind of pry at me.

    Also, what he did here goes down as one of the high points of my Internet life, and I was around in the heyday of alt.peeves and alt.tasteless for some of history’s greatest trolling.

    You have my admiration Otto. If that is who (or even what) you are ;)

  18. marijane says:

    well played!

  19. melior says:

    Little known introductory verse which further supports your point:

    Oh, I’ve got two legs from my hips to the ground
    And when I move’m they walk a-round
    When I lift’em they climb the stairs
    And when I shave’m they ain’t got hairs.


  20. drstankus says:

    heh, actually, I’d love to read some academic papers.

    I’ve got a BA in Econ, so I’m probably worthless, but at least someone would read the thing. :)

  21. J. Otto Pohl says:

    Wow, thanks for the comments. I actually never expected anybody to notice the comment and just put it out there on a lark. Sometimes you get lucky. For the record most of my life is pretty transparent and easy to find on places like my blog and the International Committee for Crimea site which I linked to in the comment on McCain’s site. Although neither the comment on McCain’s site or this post have generated any traffic for my blog.

    • e julius drivingstorm says:

      Bump, Dr. J. Otto Pohl.

      Congratulations. You’ve been googled and bookmarked. Kudos for acknowledging over there your union’s role in landing you back pay.

    • Anonymous says:

      Actually, if you are working on the topic of the Crimean tatars and immigration, I think the case of Crimean tatar minority in Finland would provide a very interesting comparison point.

      The group in question was, when it formed in the late 19th century, the only islamic community in Finland, representing a completely alien phenomenon. However, it has not only avoided assimilation to the main-stream Finnish population, but also remained closed to all non-Tatar muslims. Currently, the Finnish Tatar community numbers around 1,000, and consists mainly of middle-class professionals and businessmen. (In practice, their position in the society mirrors the position of the Finnish Jewish community very closely.) There is some quite interesting scholarship on the topic.

  22. xaaronx says:

    Late to the party because I’ve been traveling a lot lately, but bravo Otto!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.