Home / General / Pro Football Hall of Fame

Pro Football Hall of Fame


Yesterday, 6 players were inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. I was particularly excited by the inclusion of the great Seattle Seahawk Cortez Kennedy, one of my favorite players in team history. Willie Roaf and Dermontti Dawson were both clear choices. I am less excited about Curtis Martin. Basically, he was a very good but not great running back for a long time whose primary other qualifications are that he didn’t get hurt and he played in New York. But whatever. Chris Doleman is a pretty strong candidate, but a) I would have voted for Charles Haley instead and b) some argue he wasn’t the best defensive lineman on his own team. I certainly can’t speak for Jack Butler, who played long before I was born. It is interesting that the Veterans’ Committee is determined to continue going for people who played in the 50s and 60s rather than the 70s. I wonder when this will shift. Sports Illustrated had a really good column a couple of months arguing that Ken Anderson should be the next Veterans’ Committee choice, providing compelling evidence that he was better than Dan Fouts. And if the Bengals win that first Super Bowl against the 49ers, Anderson is probably already in.

There’s a certain amount of outrage around the sports internets about the selections, which basically revolve around the players who get the ball all the time not getting in. If you left it up to fans, it would be all wide receivers, quarterbacks, running backs, sack leaders, and famous coaches. The selection committee does a very good job of ensuring a fairly equal distribution of positions. Offensive and defensive linemen are highly valued. Cortez Kennedy was forgotten about in the first few years of his eligibility because he played his whole career on terrible teams in a land far, far away from the east coast or California. But once people began making a case for him, he rose pretty fast. He came up just short the previous two years. So he might not be a glamor pick, but he’s an indisputable Hall of Famer. Clearly Cris Carter and Charles Haley should be selected, so there is some room for griping, but not at the expense of Kennedy, Roaf, and Dawson.

But analyzing yesterday’s selections is only an excuse for the real point of this post:

The Professional Football Hall of Fame building in Canton, Ohio is an embarrassment to the NFL.

Last year, on Selection Saturday, I visited the Hall of Fame. I thought it would be a big deal. Maybe nice glossy posters of the new inductees. Big names last year too–Deion, Faulk, etc. Nothing. You go in and it’s immediately clear the building has not been updated since about 1970. The person working the tiny front desk asks you what team you are a fan of (I was the only Seahawks fan that day). Then you go through a turnstile and walk into the museum.

It is in shocking shape. There are cool objects in there for sure. You walk in a big circle. And that’s about it. It has been so long since the NFL has updated this, that the text still talks about John Elway as an active player!!! Elway retired in 1998. I was outraged. The NFL clearly does not care about this building at all. Jerry Jones can build a billion dollar stadium, but the sport’s shrine to its past and present is in as good a shape as a county historical society museum. And when the NFL does get involved in parts of the displays, it is an obviously ham-fisted corporate attempt to spin whatever agenda the league office has at a given time. The most egregious was the whole room dedicated to the NFL playing games in Europe. What fan possibly cares about this? If anything, it’s annoying because your team loses a home game. No one is going to the Hall of Fame to see this.

The only good thing in the Hall of Fame is the actual Hall itself, by which I mean the room where players have their busts. In this case, the NFL actually does a better job than baseball, although the baseball HOF is about 1 million times the better museum than the NFL’s hall. There is a sense of reverence in there, along with great video presentations where you can press on the player you want to see (I watched all the former Oregon Ducks, of which there are an unusually high number of 6–8th among all schools).

Outside of that, it’s awful.

Some say that the NFL needs to move the museum out of Canton and somewhere more tourist friendly. I absolutely oppose this. Canton may not have much relevance to the NFL today, but it has as much as Cooperstown or Springfield has to their respective sports. Taking the Hall away would literally destroy the remainder of that once proud city. The Hall is all keeping Canton from becoming Flint or Youngstown. Even now, most visitors probably stay in nearby Cleveland.

Instead, the NFL needs to remake the museum to turn Canton into its version of Cooperstown. Admittedly, northeastern Ohio may not have the charms of upstate New York (though it does have the very large William McKinley tomb and the First Ladies National Historic Site, which, OK, isn’t much). But making the Hall a first-rate tourist destination would put a big boost into the Canton economy.

And it’s so obvious what the NFL should do.

1. Build a very large addition to the Hall that would allow it to properly represent the league’s rich history.

2. Create a whole wing on the Super Bowl that would have room for expansion. As it is, there are nice display cases for the first 4 Super Bowls. After that, virtually nothing. That’s just crazy. There are so many great teams and players to talk about through the Super Bowl. Everyone would spend an hour in that room alone.

3. Update the main part of the museum more than once every 15 years. At least keep the signage accurate to who is still playing. That is totally embarrassing.

4. How do many kids get into the NFL? Playing Madden. There needs to be a whole wing dedicated to the various video games of the NFL over the years. This could easily pay for itself–you could get people to pay to sign up for time slots to come to the Hall and play their favorite games. You think that if my brother and I went there, I wouldn’t pay $10 for an hour to kick his ass at Madden 97 or Super Tecmo Bowl? I absolutely would pay that. And I might watch other people play for awhile. It would be awesome. As I recall, the Hall does mention video games, but you can’t play them.

There are so many huge football fans in this country–the NFL could hold a contest for ideas to remake the Hall. Hype it up even more. Instead, the NFL is a league that makes the announcement of next year’s schedule the lead sports story for a day but can’t even honor its past properly.

The Pro Football Hall of Fame is a complete joke and the NFL should be ashamed of it.

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • I’m dismayed that this post does not include a “Cortez the Killer” embed.

  • c u n d gulag

    No Carter?

    No Parcells?

    No clue.

    • OK, but who doesn’t get in instead?

      • Bill Murray

        Curtis Martin

        • Really? 14K yards rushing, 3.4K receiving, 100TD? 3rd career all time rushing attempts, 4th in rushing yards, 3rd in total touches, 8th in yards from scrimmage? 10 straight 1K seasons to start his career?

          Not a dominant peak, sure, and not a great yards per carry, but consistency and production has to count. He only played 11 years, so wasn’t hanging on to pad his stats.

          • I know, I know, counting stats are outmoded. And I agree with the tenor of the piece and am very disappointed by Doleman over Haley.

          • OK, so I’ve been hunting around the net, in the spirit of self-criticism, to see if there is an NFL equivalent of Win Shares. On this list, Curtis Martin comes in at 79 (post-1970 players): http://www.pro-football-reference.com/blog/?p=525

            Does anyone have any others sites to suggest?

            • Bill Murray

              well I would probably use the weighted career AV which is here http://www.pro-football-reference.com/leaders/career_av_career.htm and Martin comes in at a tie for 143 post-1950, and about the 15th best running back in that time.

              Otherwise there doesn’t seem to be much about ranking player’s careers outside of traditional statistics

          • Bill Murray

            Martin was pretty well done in his last season, so I doubt not running up his career stats was his choice. I personally would rather have 13-15 of the top-20 in rushing yards before martin. Taking those running backs whose career overlapped his, I’d rank him somewhere between 7 and 10.

            So he was a good, consistent player but not really of Hall caliber

            • Yeah, after my initial burst of enthusiasm on this thread I’m inclined to agree.

  • Thlayli

    Kennedy is the fifth Miami alum to make the HOF, the third from the ’80s (Hendricks, Irvin, Kelly, Otto).

    Looking forwards: Lewis and Reed are locks, Portis and Shockey are borderline, Andre Johnson and Jimmy Graham are building their cases, Chuck Foreman is a possible Veterans pick.

    • There is no way in hell that Portis or Shockey even sniff the Hall of Fame.

    • The Shaggy DA

      Is Dwayne “the Rock” Johnson in the Hall yet?

    • Furious Jorge

      Jeremy Shockey? Clearly, you are ingesting a much more potent grade of drugs than even Miami players enjoy.

      • Scott Lemieux

        Seriously. Christ, who’s next, Pete Metzelaars?

  • The Shaggy DA

    Predictably, ESPN’s take was to ask, “Should Bettis have gone in before Martin?” The correct answer, of course, is neither. If anyone takes issue, I’d just ask you to name a year in which either one was even the second best RB in the league.

    • Absolutely. I would probably vote Bettis in before Martin, but I would vote neither of them in before Haley or Carter or Tim Brown or Will Shields.

      • Bill Murray

        or Ken Anderson or Bobby Boyd or Chuck Howley or probably a dozen other players

    • Martin was unanimously seen as the best in 2004 and as right at the top in 2001:

      All-Pro Teams
      Year Team Level Voters
      1995 1st Team All-Conf. Pro Football Weekly
      1995 1st Team All-Conf. UPI
      1996 2nd Team All-Conf. UPI
      1999 2nd Team All-NFL Associated Press
      2001 1st Team All-Conf. Pro Football Weekly
      2001 2nd Team All-NFL Associated Press
      2001 1st Team All-NFL Pro Football Writers
      2001 1st Team All-NFL Sporting News
      2004 1st Team All-Conf. Pro Football Weekly
      2004 1st Team All-NFL Associated Press
      2004 1st Team All-NFL Pro Football Writers
      2004 1st Team All-NFL Sporting News


      • The Shaggy DA

        Okay, I’ll give you that 2004 was a down year for running backs. All those all conference titles came when he was in a different conference from real HOF’ers like Barry Sanders, Emmett Smith (admittedly overrated, but better than Martin), and Marshall Faulk. He’s also no Eddie George or Corey Dillon. You may disagree, but being really pretty good over a long period does not make the Hall of Fame for me.

        • mpowell

          Well, it’s just a really difficult achievement for a RB. But I’d grant you that it delivers precious little value to the team. The Jets probably could have picked up waiver wire RBs over those 11 years and gotten just as good of performance in 5 of them.

      • The Shaggy DA

        As far as career peaks go, I think Priest Holmes was close, if not superior around that same time, but I don’t think anyone talks seriously about him being a HOF’er.
        Of course, he never played in New York.

  • Ginger Yellow

    The most egregious was the whole room dedicated to the NFL playing games in Europe. What fan possibly cares about this? If anything, it’s annoying because your team loses a home game.

    Or, in my case, as a London based Bears fan, you gain a home game. Still, not the sort of thing that should be in the Hall of Fame.

  • Incontinentia Buttocks

    I last went to Canton in the late 1980s and it was falling apart then, too.

    I distinctly remember that the very first display case was dedicated not to the origins of football, but to determining who the first person was who had been paid to play football. This starting point highlights one of the differences between Canton and its much nicer cousins. Springfield houses the “Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame.” Coopertown is the home of the “National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum.” While both focus on the pro game (and their formal Halls of Fame enshrine those who played, coached, and otherwise were involved with the pro game) the museums are about the entire history of their sports.

    Canton is the site of the “Pro Football Hall of Fame.” At least when I visited, the museum seemed little interested in the history of the sport of football beyond the NFL and the old AFL. It would be a much better museum if it broadened its historical vision.

    But they could start by simply making it less of a shithole.

    • The Shaggy DA

      That’s somewhat defensible when you consider that college football has a rich and much longer history than the pros, which has its own institution in South Bend.

  • Richard Hershberger

    Is the Pro Football Hall of Fame an NFL body? The baseball HoF is a distinct entity. While it has ties to Major League Baseball, it is its own thing. One can argue that the NFL should toss some cash in the direction of Canton, but it is probably mistaken to speak as if the museum were owned and operated by the NFL.

    I am more of a baseball guy, so perhaps my perception is skewed, but my sense is that football doesn’t have the sense of its own history like baseball does. Baseball has its own limitations: anything before 1900 tends to be seen through a sepia-tinged haze of quaintness. But with football this seems to be true of anything before the Superbowl era. Cooperstown has made an industry of marketing to baseball fans’ sense of history. I’m not persuaded there is an equivalent market for football.

  • JLK1

    I don’t know who runs the Canton museum, but the league itself is a non-profit tax exempt entity that pays Goodell something like $10 million per year.

It is main inner container footer text