Subscribe via RSS Feed

Pulling the Thread

[ 3 ] January 11, 2006 |

Jill at Feministe notes an interesting Townhall discussion of Alito’s invocation of Griswold at the hearings, which sees in Alito’s argument about the shifting rationales for the right to privacy a signal that Griswold does not mean Roe. Jill is right that this is important, and for people unfamiliar with the history it’s worth discussing what Alito is talking about.

As many of you know, Griswold–which struck down a Connecticut law banning the use of contraception–had a majority opinion by William O. Douglas, which located a right to privacy as an outgrowth of the structural logic of the Bill of Rights, which was overwhelmingly concerned with provides zones of individual protection against overweening state authority. The conservative justice John Marshall Harlan, while equally convinced that the statute was egregiously unconstitutional, located the individual’s protection in a substantive reading of the 14th Amendment’s due process clause. Roe v. Wade‘s notoriously brief legal analysis, while citing Griswold, held that the Texas statute was “violative of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment,” implying that it was applying Harlan’s, not Douglas’s, reasoning.

Robert Bork and many other conservatives have argued that Roe is wrong because Griswold was wrong. This presents the obvious problems that 1)Griswold was an easy case correctly decided, and 2)overturning it would be exceptionally unpopular, even more so than overturning Roe. Nobody who advocated it could get appointed to the Court, and rightly so. Which brings us to Plan B.

Before Griswold was a case called Poe v. Ullman, in which both Harlan and Douglas–in dissent–would write stronger opinions on behalf of the unconstitutionality of the contraception ban than they would later in Griswold. Harlan’s dissent was largely drafted by a young clerk named Charles Fried. As Reagan’s solicitor general, Fried argued in front of the Supreme Court that the Court could “pull the thread” of Roe without undoing the other privacy cases, based on the substantive due process logic. While Douglas’s emphasis on individual autonomy was more obviously related to the right at stake in Roe, Fried argued that Harlan’s S.D.P. right was located in the security of people in their homes, and as such did not apply to the abortion cases. Under Fried’s logic (which is quite plausible on its own terms), one can overrule Roe without overturning Griswold, or Eisenstadt (extending Griswold to unmarried heterosexual couples)or perhaps even Lawrence (extending the right to privacy to same-sex couples.)

And, of course, Alito and Fried worked together in the Reagan White House; Alito helped shape the Reagan administration’s anti-Roe strategy and was well aware of this argument. So it’s clear what’s going on here: Alito is signaling that his acceptance of Griswold doesn’t mean that he accepts Roe. People in the media who argue otherwise are being played for suckers, just as Alito and his supporters want.

Comments (3)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Anonymous says:

    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]prescribe ceftin for the treatment of[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Buy Ceftin Without A Prescription Or Membership[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Alternative Order Ceftin[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]By Buy Ceftin Online[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Order Ceftin With No Prescription[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Buying Ceftin Pharmacy Without Prescription[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Ceftin no prescription online generic and brand, big discounts![/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Where can i buy Ceftin online?[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]order Ceftin medication[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Buy Ceftin No Prescription Cod[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]250mg ceftin[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]is ceftin bad for teeth[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Purchase Ceftin Uk Delivery[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]Next Day Ceftin Delivery[/url]
    [url=http://members.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewUserPage&userid=buycefuroxime]gemfibrozil and ceftin[/url]

  2. Anonymous says:

    [SIZE=3][COLOR=Blue]BUY CIALIS,VIAGRA [/COLOR], [COLOR=Red]LEVITRA[/COLOR] [COLOR=Green]FROM CANADA[/COLOR], [COLOR=YellowGreen]MEXICO[/COLOR], [COLOR=Indigo]USA[/COLOR] [COLOR=Olive]WITHOUT PRESCRIPTION [/COLOR][/SIZE]
    [url=http://www.pharmas.onlinehostlocation.com][img]http://www.xmages.net/upload/1418e2a7.gif[/img][/url]

    buy no prior viagra cialis levitra
    buy levitra on-line
    buy cheap cialis generic levitra viagra
    buy cheap levitra online
    buy levitra in uk
    buy levitra wholesale
    buy levitra where
    buy levitra without prescription
    buy sublingual levitra on the internet
    buy levitra viagra
    buy online levitra cialis viagra
    buy levitra vardenafil php
    buy levitra online us
    buy levitra online viagra
    buy levitra online with fast delivery
    buy levitra onlines
    buy levitra san jose
    buy levitra scientists voice tsunami concern
    buy levitra viagra online
    buy levitra us
    levitra buy levitra online viagra
    buy vardenafil levitra
    buy viagra cialis levitra
    levitra search buy vardenafil levitra
    levitra shop buy
    levitra where to buy
    op userinfo username buy levitra cheap
    the buy levitra
    vardenafil query buy vardenafil levitra
    want to buy levitra
    where can i buy levitra
    levitra query buy vardenafil levitra
    levitra cheapest best buy lowest cost
    buy viagra levitra alternative lavitra
    buy viagra or levitra
    can i buy levitra at walgreens
    dreampharmaceuticals buy levitra online
    key buy levitra cheap
    levitra buy
    levitra buy generic
    levitra buy levitra
    where to buy levitra on line
    buy levitra online pharmacy online
    buy buy cheap cheap levitra levitra
    buy drug satellite tv levitra
    buy en language levitra
    buy generic levitra cheap
    buy generic levitra online
    buy genuine levitra online
    bravejournal buy levitra member
    buy levitra american pharmacy
    buy levitra at a discount
    buy dreampharmaceuticalscom levitra online
    buy dreampharmaceuticals levitra online
    buy dreampharmaceuticals from levitra online
    buy canada levitra
    buy cheap generic levitra
    buy cheap generic levitra pharmacy online
    buy cheap levitra xanax xenical
    buy discount levitra online
    buy domain levitra online 0catch com
    buy dosages levitra

  3. Anonymous says:

    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-fix-a-flat-motorcycle-tire/]how to fix a flat motorcycle tire[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-quickly/]how to get a flat stomach quickly[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-without-exercising/]how to get a flat stomach without exercising[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-cook-flat-brisket/]how to cook flat brisket[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-buy-flat-screen-tv/]how to buy flat screen tv[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-for-women/]how to get a flat stomach for women[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-get-a-flat-stomach-in-one-week/]how to get a flat stomach in one week[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-correct-baby-flat-head/]how to correct baby flat head[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-fix-chi-flat-iron/]how to fix chi flat iron[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-build-a-granny-flat/]how to build a granny flat[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-clean-a-flat-panel-computer-screen/]how to clean a flat panel computer screen[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-avoid-flat-head-in-babies/]how to avoid flat head in babies[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-get-a-flat-tummy-fast/]how to get a flat tummy fast[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-prevent-infant-flat-head/]how to prevent infant flat head[/url]
    [url=http://myflat.co.cc/My-flat/how-to-sell-my-flat/]how to sell my flat[/url]

Leave a Reply




If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar.

  • Switch to our mobile site