University administrator and faculty pay in the new Gilded Age
This is a follow-on to Erik’s post yesterday about university administrators using the COVID-19 pandemic as an excuse for further neoliberal decimation of the humanities, even as they continue to jack up their own compensation to ever-more obscene levels.
Here are some numbers that I hope speak for themselves. ALL FIGURES ARE INFLATION-ADJUSTED INTO CONSTANT 2018 OR 2019 DOLLARS.
Salary of full-time faculty at American colleges and universities
Percentage of university faculty that were full time
What this means, of course, is that the average salary of the people who do the teaching in American higher education has declined substantially over the past half century, since over that time full-time faculty salaries have barely budged, while the percentage of faculty who are poorly paid part-time contingent workers has shot up dramatically.
This is true despite the nonsense we hear constantly about how university operating expenses are driven by Baumol’s cost disease, i.e., the idea that costs remain high in sectors where technology is less able to improve labor productivity, such as teaching.
In American higher education, per instructor salary costs have plunged over the past half century, even though the revenue per student American higher ed has pulled in over this time has literally doubled:
Revenue per student at American institutions of higher education
1970-71: $17,624 (2018 dollars)
Hey, where’s all that extra money going anyway?
Mean salary of American college and university presidents in 1983
$160,640 (2018 dollars).
Median compensation of private college and university presidents in 2018
Median compensation of public college and university presidents in 2019
Mean compensation of the ten highest-paid private college and university presidents in 2018
Mean compensation of the ten highest-paid public college and university presidents in 2019
And of course if your university president is getting paid seven figures, that means that dozens of sublunary administrative demiurges must be paid salaries that are several times higher, in real dollars, than the typical university president was getting paid when I was an undergraduate in the early 1980s.
Here’s a quaint passage from a 1982 New York Times story, when Texas A&M shocked the world of higher education by luring football coach Jackie Sherrill away from the University of Pittsburgh for the astounding sum of $280,000 per year in total compensation:
Jackie Sherrill, head football coach at the University of Pittsburgh since 1977, yesterday was named coach and athletic director at Texas A & M and signed a six-year contract whose worth was put by knowledgeable sources at the College Station, Tex., campus at $1.7 million.
The contract apparently makes the 38-year-old Sherrill the highest paid university employee in the nation. Though declining to comment on the total value of the pact, Sherrill confirmed in a farewell news conference at Pitt that it was for six years and said that his base salary would be $95,000 a year. But the addition of benefits – including a home, new cars, insurance policies and money-fund investments – brings the entire package, the sources in Texas said, to an average of more than $280,000.
According to the best estimates of several officials with a broad knowledge of higher-education matters, no other person has ever received so much in pay from an American university.
”No president or chancellor or professors at any university that I know of, including our chancellor, are paid anywhere near that much,” said Dr. Ed Bozik, assistant chancellor at Pitt.
It was a simpler, more innocent time.
$280,000 in 1982 is $747,000 today. Columbia University by itself, to choose an example at semi-random, is probably paying 30 people more than that right now. Oh let’s check:
From the 2018 990 tax filing of this tax-exempt charitable organization:
General Counsel: $773K
Senior Exec Vice President for Maximizing Synergistic Interdisciplinarity: (last four words may have been interpolated): $854K
Another Exec VP for Something Really Important: $801K
Exec VP for Health Sciences: $1.97 million.
[Thomas Dolby voice] Science!
The island of doubt is like the taste of medicine:
Clinical Professor: $4.05 million
Prof. of Surgery: $2.8 million
Prof. of Surgery: $4.8 million
Prof. of Surgery: $3.78 million
Prof. of Surgery: $3.18 million
Oh yeah, the university’s president and my old Con Law prof: $4.55 million.
And the piece de resistance: [Drum roll]
EXECUTIVE VICE PRESIDENT OF INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT: $6.17 million, which believe me doesn’t go nearly as far south of 110th Street as you might imagine.
I think that’s enough for now.
Faculty Salaries and Full v. Part-time Ratios
Presidential Salaries in 2018/19