Home / General / When Feeling Entitled to Sex Goes More Wrong than Usual

When Feeling Entitled to Sex Goes More Wrong than Usual

Comments
/
/
/
749 Views

If you’d like to get caught up on the horrific details of the California spree shooting, PZ Meyers has a transcript of the shooter’s… manifesto–I guess–here.

I’ve seen one of his videos. Yes, it’s chilling. But the creepiest thing about it is how young and fresh-faced the shooter is.

I’m now wondering if we’ll be allowed to discuss how incredibly pervasive and potentially destructive the specter of misogyny is.  Someone on twitter said it was time to label MRA-type groups as hate groups. Yes. It’s past time.

FacebookTwitterGoogle+Share
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • Linkedin
  • Pinterest
  • herr doktor bimler

    Nope, nope, nope. I’m staying here with the lancetfish.

    • Ahuitzotl

      I am as one with you, on that. Kia te kuware rere ki to ratou whakawa.

      • herr doktor bimler

        I know I should learn Te Reo, but my head is full and I might forget something else.

  • Hogan

    And you do deserve it, just for the crime of living a better life than me.

    I can’t even

    • Karen

      That’s the line that affected me the most.

    • NewishLawyer

      So says the guy who drove a BMW????

      Does this mean that everyone else at UCSB had a Ferrari or Lambourghini?

      • Vance Maverick

        Nice cars are not all there is to the good life, Mr. Lawyer.

        The rhetoric of deservingness (desert) is pretty powerful. There are a lot of bogus claims out there about desert, and some good ones that are not often enough affirmed. Here, I think it’s possible to concede that the guy deserved a better life, and that he was probably mentally ill, and still blame toxic PUA/MRA talk for his having gone so very far wrong.

        • rea

          Nice cars are not all there is to the good life, Mr. Lawyer.

          Well, yeah. But, as this kid found, being rich, reasonably smart, and reasonably good looking isn’t necessarily enough to get you a relationship–it also helps a lot to be not crazier than shit.

        • JL

          I don’t think we should assume that he was mentally ill. People do this every time there’s a mass shooting, but you don’t have to be mentally ill to be violent.

          It’s also unclear to me that he deserved a better life, since most of his talk seems to have been that his life sucked because nobody dated or had sex with him, and I have minimal sympathy over that – lots of people (including both me and my spouse) were around his age, or even older, the first time we had a romantic relationship. Being a late bloomer really isn’t such a difficult or shameful thing.

          • Barry Freed

            What comes out if you read his rantings is an overweening sense of entitlement combined with several metric ton loads of frightening misogyny. I doubt he was mentally ill in any DSM-IV diagnosable sense but I suspect he gave he gave off waves of teh crazy that told anyone paying the slightest attention to stay well clear.

      • anonymous

        Why you tryin’ to Frenchify the lambo’s spelling?

      • Tyro

        To be fair, it was a mere 328i.

      • Pablo Picasso

        I would like to give this comment a ride in my El Dorado, while the girls turn the colour of an avocado.

        • wjts

          +128 when it’s cold outside.

      • Alex O’connor

        How new? Too old and too new….you have defined the inscrutable legal wave function and collapsed.

      • Alex O’connor

        All I know is that without a gun no one would be shot to death.

        • Anonymous

          Yes, of course. It’s an anomaly that carry laws have increased the number of weapons in the hands of citizens and crime has decreased over that same 25 year period.

          This cannot stand!

          • Malaclypse

            So, is your failure to look at state-level data a deliberate lie, or are you merely too stupid to grasp the relevance?

            • delurking

              What’s wrong with stupid AND evil?

              • Malaclypse

                He’s not smart enough to be evil. Also, evil is not as sadly pathetic.

          • rea

            Wow! A correlation! Did you know, too, that there is a stong correlation over the last 14 years between per capita consumption of mozzerella chees and the number of civil engineering doctorates awarded?

            http://www.tylervigen.com/

            • Snarki, child of Loki

              I LOVE mozzarella cheese! Time to get cranking out those CE doctorates, people!

            • Anonymous

              Yes, also a correlation of more carbon output and rising global temperatures.

              • Malaclypse

                And an explanatory mechanism linking the two. You left that part out, because you are profoundly stupid.

                • Anonymous

                  Guns also have an explanatory mechanism. Studies at University of Chicago and others have also made the link that you seem unable to see.

                  I will not insult you as you have me for my views because I’m better than you.

                  Better

                • Malaclypse

                  Bless your heart, dear.

                • wjts

                  For Chicago, Alma Mater,
                  And the honor of her name,
                  Her sons shall raise, with loyal praise,
                  The glory of her fame.

                • N__B

                  “I’m above you! Better than! Businessman, see?”

                • ChrisTS

                  Guns also have an explanatory mechanism

                  What?

    • Larry

      Infantile rage fueled by envy?

  • Linnaeus

    I didn’t even make it all the way through the video. I knew where it was going when he made his sense of entitlement so blatant, and I’m glad I stopped watching.

  • Anonymous

    All you popular kids. You’ve never accepted me, and now you’ll all pay for it.

    If someone put this in a script for his father, he’d have sent it back for a re-write.

  • Ronnie Pudding
    • Anonymous

      “Highly functional Aspergers” in this instance, where money can fob off a difficult child onto “professionals” = spoiled nerd who thinks he’s special

      • EH

        I don’t know if “nerd” really qualifies…

        • GFW

          “Not all nerds …” wait, wrong thread.

      • ThrottleJockey

        You do realize that Asperger’s is a serious mental illness don’t you and by “highly functioning” they mean in relation to full blown Autism? They can be EXTREMELY difficult people but its not just a case of a spoiled, entitled nerd.

        • Lee Rudolph

          That particular “Anonymous” is, I am sure, one of the usual trolls, to whom any such realization would be irrelevant.

        • KmCO

          Throttle Jockey, you don’t have a clue what you’re talking about. A “serious mental illness” is bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. Aspergers Syndrome is not even an illness, and the more you claim that it is, the more you confirm that you’re a clueless jackass.

          • ThrottleJockey

            Whether you call it a neurodevelopmental disorder or call it a mental illness/condition like I did, its still a serious social and personal handicap. Pull your head out of your ass.

      • herr doktor bimler

        There is a lot of it around. As a sign of the times, here is a real peer-reviewed academicological article claiming that spree killers tend to be autistic / aspergers. To achieve the desired conclusion, the authors performed a lot of retrospective diagnoses, drawing on such authoritative sources as — I am not making this up! — Daily Mail articles.

        It is the other side of the coin from those long lists published by neurodiversity aspergers-esteem enthusiasts, of famous scientists and artists who were in any way quirky or eccentric and are therefore recruited for the AS tribe.

        It is all very depressing and sends me off to my quiet place to recite digits of pi until I feel happy again.

        • Anonymous

          Asperger’s not likely to make people violent, experts emphasize

          Another means by which we’re excusing male violence because: neuro-atypical

          • ThrottleJockey

            I’m not claiming that the Asperger’s made him do it, but that doesn’t mean that Asperger’s isn’t a serious mental condition and we should empathize with people who face it. Its hard to imagine this guy didn’t suffer a variety of psychological issues…in addition to the MRA-rage/misogyny.

            • Anonymous

              Asperger’s isn’t a mental condition, and yes, it’s quite easy to imagine someone angry enough to commit violence without being “ill” or requiring our sympathy.

            • calling all toasters

              Well, I’ve now seen his video… if he has Asperger’s, then I’m Martha Raye. Seems a lot like your basic angry sadist, not at all like someone who doesn’t get social cues. Not ruling out a nasty mental illness like schizoaffective, which a short video wouldn’t help diagnose, but no way was he on the autism spectrum.

              • Anna in PDX

                It seems to me like he is axis 2 – narcissist, sociopath, etc… If he has any DSM type of thing at all. But generally I am among those who think that the thing to focus on is the toxic sexism and not to use “well he was mentally ill somehow” as a “look over there!” method of distraction from the sexism.

                • calling all toasters

                  The difference having one of those personality disorders and being an evil shit is entirely unclear to me. My guess is that this fucker could have been Hitler if resentment of the Jews was the big thing in the hateosphere, rather than resentment of women.

              • ThrottleJockey

                So you’re saying that the doctors who diagnosed him with Asperger’s are wrong, but from your watching a 5 minute video you’re right? Think I’m going to go with the doctors who, you know, actually treated him instead. Forgive me.

                • calling all toasters

                  Well, I can’t really argue with your point, and we’ll never know now.

                  But I still don’t buy it. He’s at the prime age for a psychotic break, he’s paranoid, and a lot kids present as autism spectrum — if they’re schizotypal.

                  I know a bunch of child shrinks, and they just do not want to diagnose that. Or don’t believe it has signs in the elementary school years. Or whatever. Autism (and even more so, Asperger’s) is an easy and defensible out. Schizophrenia is like a death sentence to parents.

                  Ted Kaczynski had been described as having autistic symptoms when younger. Cho Seung-hui was, too. It’s almost certain that they were schizophrenic (TK) and schizoaffective (CS-h).

              • ChrisTS

                If you can stand to read it, his ‘manifesto’ reveals a person almost completely unaware of other people as subjects of their own experience.

                He was angry with his mother for not marrying a wealthy man, as that would have been his ticket to sex (rich guys get sex). He actually pestered her and scolded her about it.

                • calling all toasters

                  That seems more like selfishness than a lack of Theory of Mind, although the two are far from mutually exclusive.

                • ChrisTS

                  Hah!

            • colleen

              I am content with the diagnosis of sociopathy and bemused that so many have sympathy for him. LOTS of people don’t have fulfilling sex lives. Hell, this is America and so most of the women in this country don’t have fulfilling sex lives. That does not mean we think it would be fun to kill blondes in response.

              • ThrottleJockey

                I said we should empathize with people who have Autism/Asperger’s as a general kind of thing. I never said I sympathize with what he did. There’s a world of difference between the two.

    • Jeremy

      It would violate our sacred Second Amendment freedoms to prevent murderous psychos from buying guns.

      • Brad Nailer

        Somebody’s going to say that and mean it.

        • I’m surprised Wayne LaPierre hasn’t said it yet.

          • dk

            He will, Oscar, he will.

          • Mr Rogers

            “If those sorority girls had all been wearing battle armor and been armed with assault rifles this would have turned out different is all I’m saying.”

            Probably on an NRA website somewhere already.

            • delurking

              The MRA websites, OTOH, are saying if the bitches just knew their place, none of this would have happened.

              Actual quote: “I blame blondes for this one, not guns.”

    • DivGuy

      I’m not saying mental health isn’t an issue here.

      But someone said on twitter, whenever a white guy kills a bunch of people, it’s always about mental issues and guns, never about ideology. I think ideology is a really big part of this.

      • McAllen

        This

        Mental issues may have played a role here, but dismissing this as a case of a mentally ill man (in a way would would have never done if he were a PoC) ignores the effect sexism and male entitlement have on society.

        • rea

          Sometimes the ideology IS the mental illness.

          • Richard

            I think we need a lot more information before coming to any conclusions. The info so far is that this guy had serious mental problems from a very early age, way before he joined women-hating groups. Also, the first three victims of his rampage were young men who he stabbed to death at his residence.

            • McAllen

              He literally posted a video saying he was going to kill women because no woman would sleep with him. I hardly think it’s a leap to point to sexism as a significant cause.

              • KmCO

                “Who’re you gonna believe? Me or your own eyes?”

                He may have killed men along with women, but we have what basically amounts to an a priori admission that his intent was to kill women.

                • Random

                  As he points out, his entire reason for killing other males is because they were having sex with females.

                • Manny Kant

                  I believe he said he would kill his housemates first in order to be able to turn his apartment into a murder den.

              • Richard

                Sexism is a cause. What encouragement/support he got from women hating groups may or may not be a cause. He was very disturbed from an early age according to spokespeople for his family.

          • mojrim

            No, it’s always the other way around. The deranged, the angry, the disaffected latch onto whatever ideology is most convenient to select the targets of their ire. They’re going to kill someone, all that ideology provides is targeting data.

            • Unsympathetic

              Mental health is always the issue.

              But hey, Saint Ronnie defunded the public availability of mental health in the USA, and as a result people like this can’t get the treatment they need in a timely fashion.

              Because freedom.

              Yes, treating mental health disorders costs money – and the results aren’t sexy. The results would be a decrease in incidents like this which wouldn’t have happened if there was a system with adequate capacity to identify and genuinely treat people like this.

              • herr doktor bimler

                “Being a vile human being” is not in itself a medical condition and there is no medical treatment for it (other than Debirthing Therapy, which my profession does not encourage).

              • JL

                While I would LOVE more mental health funding and strongly believe in it, violence, even severe violence, is not always about mental health. And the reason to fund mental health is primarily to increase people’s well-being, not to prevent shooting sprees.

              • Anonymous

                Ronnie defunded the public availability of mental health in the USA,

                The president does not hold the purse strings.

                Please try to be more honest

                • Guggenheim Swirly

                  Right, Ronnie was just an innocent bystander.

                  Please try to be more honest.

              • Manny Kant

                This kid was rich as fuck. In this case, the problem was absolutely not a lack of availability of mental health resources.

            • Origami Isopod

              Funny, isn’t it, how if a white guy shoots a bunch of black people, most of us (excluding the blatant racists) have no problem declaring racism the problem. But if a guy shoots a bunch of women, even ~~liberal men dance around the likelihood that ideology was the problem.

              • colleen

                Yes. I have noticed the same thing.

              • Anonymous

                And if two black guys shoot white people from the trunk of their car through a hole in it….it ain’t racism at all!

                That was easy!

                • Origami Isopod

                  What if two black chefs throw pancakes at white patrons from the counter of the kitchen, JenBlob?

              • I have noticed that.

              • mojrim

                As a brown man I have made the same argument in both cases. Not all murderers are mentally defective (legally) but mass shooters are. Whatever issues and problems make them need to kill in order to regulate themselves are separate from the ideology that drives target selection. In another time and place he would have killed immigrants or heretics or whatever.

                • herr doktor bimler

                  Not all murderers are mentally defective (legally) but mass shooters are.

                  Forgive me if I have missed something, but you seem to be defining “shooting lots of people” as a symptom of mental illness — or as a new syndrome of its own — and concluding that anyone who shoots lots of people is therefore mentally ill. Because no sane person would shoots of lots of people.
                  This seems a bit McArdle-esque.

                • Because no sane person would shoots of lots of people.

                  If you don’t want to fly missions, that means you’re sane and you have to fly missions.

                • ChrisTS

                  @N_B: Best. Book. Ever.

        • ThrottleJockey

          I tend to believe that psychology is more important a determinant in these crimes than sociology but you raise an intriguing question. On the one hand, 95% of MRA types don’t commit mass murder (so ideology would be a relatively weak predictor), but on the other hand psychology can’t possibly be the sole factor if these mass murderers are (near) exclusively male.

          This article had a good discussion of the interplay between the psychological and sociological factors:

          What is the connection between gender and outbreaks of massive violence? A helpful way to approach the question is to look at the three main categories of mass murderers. There are “family annihilators,” who, as the name suggests, turn on their families. There are “set-and-run” or “hit-and-run” killers, who usually hide and try to avoid capture. Then there are “pseudocommandos,” a category that would seem to include James Holmes, the suspected shooter in the July movie theater massacre in Aurora, Colo., and Seung-Hui Cho, who in 2007 killed 32 people during a rampage at Virginia Tech…

          How does the psychology of a pseudocommando relate to maleness? One theory is that the social construct of male identity — what it means to be a man — is more vulnerable to slights and challenges than the female’s. Men are taught from a young age that successful males “exert social dominance, achieve a high social status, command respect, and demonstrate authority,” say Christopher A.D. Charles and Deniese Kennedy-Kollar at The Southwest Journal of Criminal Justice. Men are also taught to value economic independence and sexual success. Holmes, Cho, and Lanza seem to have failed in some or all of these respects, possibly opening the door to injuries, perceived or real, that gnawed at their troubled minds.

          • Tyro

            One theory is that the social construct of male identity — what it means to be a man — is more vulnerable to slights and challenges than the female’s.

            I am beginning to think that obsessing over “what does it mean to be a man” is a personality disorder in and of itself.

            • guthrie

              Some TV presenter called Bear Ghrylls who likes to go on about being a man and so on has a new tv series wehre he follows the adventures of some modern men dumped on a desert island. Natuirally he thinks men should be able to hunt and eat things and survive there etc, but the real issue is that he’s not man enough to grow up and accept that you can defind manliness how you want.

            • Aunt Snow

              One theory is that the social construct of male identity — what it means to be a man — is more vulnerable to slights and challenges than the female’s.

              Seriously? No, the difference is that women who are insecure about their femininity tend to harm themselves rather than strangers.

              • ChrisTS

                I actually think he’s right about male fragility. There is a very old theory (at least back to Hegel)that the dominant class or group is likely to have a far more rigid construction of its identity than the less privileged one[s].

            • Lee Rudolph

              I am beginning to think that obsessing over “what does it mean to be a man” is a personality disorder in and of itself.

              You appear to have missed (perhaps because you were not yet born, or for some other excellent reason) about a couple of decades in which other males of more or less my age, and with whom I was thrown together for otherwise good purposes (or so they seemed at the time), wielded that obsession—in rather different ideological clothes—in my presence often enough that I … no, I won’t go there. (But think “Robert Bly”.)

              I mean, I. Just. Never. Got. It. I couldn’t, and can’t, even understand what it would mean to ASK myself “what does it mean to be a man”, much less what form the answer would take or what I would do if I knew it, and much, much, MUCH less why … no, I won’t go there, either. But, gaaah.

              • Tyro

                I mean, I. Just. Never. Got. It. I couldn’t, and can’t, even understand what it would mean to ASK myself “what does it mean to be a man”, much less what form the answer would take or what I would do if I knew it, and much, much, MUCH less why

                Thank you. That is exactly how I feel– I just don’t “get it”, so when these topics come up about how it is such a crucially important issue for men, I feel like they’re talking some kind of alien language.

      • herr doktor bimler

        A mango, I bring you one:

        Just STOP with the nonsense. Normal males don’t go around killing people!
        This guy had Asperger/Autism, and yes, we’re starting to see a pattern of violence with these people.

        • DocAmazing

          No group kills as many people as “normal males”.

          • herr doktor bimler

            Were I a US voter, I would vote for removing guns from the victims of testosterone poisoning.

            • Expatchad

              We have nothing like this in The Philippines. Not even remotely.

              We do have SOME guns, a few, which are not objects of worship.

              On the other hand, we have NO Republicans. None. Nor NRA.

              • Larry

                You have a guerilla war ongoing, right? Not too shabby.

                • Expatchad

                  You speak as one with authority, perhaps?

                • The guerrillas in the Philippines, aside from the restive island of Mindanao, are usually the New People’s Army, or, as my noble Ilocana spouse calls them, “No Permanent Address”.

                  She was once asked by a stranger on a bus if she was a Sparrow.(Short answer, no, just very careful about her surroundings. She’s like the protagonist of Burn Notice, except she’s also a good cook.

                • Barry Freed

                  Don’t forget, the MILFs have guns too.

            • Anonymous

              Were I a US voter…

              If you’re not…then STFU..

              • Malaclypse

                Agreed. People have no right to be foreigners.

                Unless, that is, we posit that you may, in fact, be a profoundly stupid little man in search of a balcony you will never, in fact, find.

          • Normal male

            Hoo ah! Semper fi!

          • EH

            Or Republicans.

          • Alex O’connor

            No group intentionally kills more people in the US than the possessors of guns.

        • Brandon

          Not all men

      • ThrottleJockey

        Ideology simply overlays the psychological isssues. Asperger’s is a serious mental illness. Adam Lanza was reportedly an ‘Aspie’ as well.

        • herr doktor bimler

          Key word there is “reportedly”. Mainly reported by the gun lobby, arguing — as they always do — that the latest multiple murderer was One Of Them and no reflection on Responsible Gun-owners. Actual evidence for a diagnosis?

          • ThrottleJockey

            The gun lobby may publicize the fact that he was reportedly an Aspie, but the gun lobby didn’t do the reporting. The behavior described in the press certainly fits classic Aspie behavior.

            • herr doktor bimler

              “Classic Aspie behavior”? You’re a feckin’ clinician now?

              • Classic as pie.

              • ThrottleJockey

                Spend 2 years working closely with an Aspie and being driven to read everything you can about them so that you’d empathize with them just enough not to throttle his fucking neck every damn day and you’ll become familiar with classic Aspie behavior too. If I hadn’t read up on it I seriously would’ve killed him. If you’re actually interested in it the New Yorker did a great article some years back.

                • Normal male

                  Personal anecdote, Shakezula! It’s all good.

                • Tom Servo

                  My god I think you’ve replaced J. Otto as everyone’s least favorite LGM commenter. Good job.

                • weirdnoise

                  I’m an Aspie. And, yeah, some of my brethren are obnoxiously socially ignorant and narcissistic. I’ve certainly felt like throttling a few myself. It’s definitely harder, though hardly impossible, to learn social graces when it’s not hardwired into ones brain.

                  However, even my stunted social intuition recognized bigotry when it sees it.

                • herr doktor bimler

                  If you’re actually interested in it

                  I am aware of all internet traditions the diagnostic issues (p. 24).

                • weirdnoise

                  I meant “recognizes” not “recognized.”

                  Aspergers people are at least as different from each other as they are from the norm, as herr doktor bimler points out. And as ThrottleJockey illustrates, it doesn’t take Aspergers to be an asshole.

                • cpinva

                  “It’s definitely harder, though hardly impossible, to learn social graces when it’s not hardwired into ones brain.”

                  they aren’t, any more than hunting & efficiently killing prey skills are “hard-wired” into a tiger kitten’s brain. both are taught/learned skills. the former by parents/teachers/classmates/society at large, the latter by the tiger kitten’s mom.

                • Pablo Picasso

                  Aspergers people are at least as different from each other as they are from the norm, as herr doktor bimler points out

                  There is a saying among my people that “If you know one person with Aspergers / Autism, then you know precisely one person“.

                • ThrottleJockey

                  Sorry Weirdnoise for offending you. It wasn’t my intent. I’ve not made any generalizations about those with Autism except to say that its a serious disorder.

              • wjts

                You’re a feckin’ clinician now?

                ThrottleJockey is an eminently qualified “General Contractor” of medicine. If he can misdiagnose himself with strep, I see no reason to doubt his ability to diagnose Adam Lanza from beyond the grave based on a few newspaper articles.

                • ThrottleJockey

                  I didn’t diagnose him. The newspaper reported that he had been diagnosed that way and then reported some of the accompanying symptoms. Forgive me for knowing how to read.

          • Alex O’connor

            There is not gun lobby. There is a pervasive a subtle terrorist organization, known as the NRA, and associated organizations, whose stated purpose is to spread mass murderous capability on a global scale.

        • DocAmazing

          Not all that serious. No longer in the Diagnositc and Statistical Manual–now considered part of the autism spectrum.

          In terms of violence, most of the literature I’ve read on the subject suggests that Aspergers patients are more likely to be victims than aggressors.

          • ThrottleJockey

            Sorry if I implied they were violent. The DSM-5 didn’t diminish Asperger’s it just formally included it as part of the Autism spectrum, since it was previously thought to be a distinct condition. Its true that they aren’t prone to violence, but they’re still seriously dysfunctional.

            • herr doktor bimler

              Various AS commenters will doubtless be grateful for your advice.

            • DrS

              Its true that they aren’t prone to violence, but they’re still seriously dysfunctional.

              So, of course it makes sense to trot this out popular speculation about aspergers dx for each and every mass shooter.

            • weirdnoise

              Dude, I’m quite successful, married with kids (and earlier, pretty successful with the opposite sex), a nice house in the ‘burbs filled with books and nick-nacks, a creative and fulfilling job, and enough savings to retire early.

              And have Aspergers.

              Now, shall we speculate what your “dysfunction” is?

              • ThrottleJockey

                I apologized up above and I’m apologizing here as well. Having Asperger’s doesn’t mean you can’t succeed anymore than polio kept FDR from being President. People with Asperger’s have done quite well. My friend’s father has it and he’s raised 2 lovely, accomplished daughters, has a number of patents, a house the size of a small state, and a successful wife. And he’s a perfectly likable guy if you take time to know him.

            • KmCO

              It’s abundantly clear that Throttle Jockey has no idea what Aspergers Syndrome is beyond a hazy, Hollywood-stereotype notion.

              • DocAmazing

                Aspergers Syndrome? Isn’t that when your pee smells funny after ingesting certain vegetables?

                • Anonymous

                  This is the ol’ “____________ is not what you think it is” schtick to try to shut down debate.

                  Seen this a bunch on LGM when they can’t come up with an answer….

                • herr doktor bimler

                  It’s where you feel an uncontrollable urge to sprinkle water on people.

                • DocAmazing

                  Okay, puns go over this guy’s head. I’ll try to think of something simpler…

                • Lee Rudolph

                  And, by a commodius vicus of recirculation, it happens that when the rite of baptism is practiced by sprinkling water over someone’s head, it’s called aspersion!

                • HCE

                  Anna Livia, is that you?

                • herr doktor bimler

                  Even I know that Commodius Vicus was a Roman Emperor. Maybe the one who died of a surfeit of alligators.

            • JL

              If they aren’t prone to violence, then why bring it up as a factor?

              Lots and lots of people have mental illnesses. These mental illnesses impair their function in some way or another – that’s usually a criterion for being diagnosed with a mental illness. But that doesn’t mean any sort of propensity for violence.

          • Alex O’connor

            I wonder has the DSM ever indicated that people not in possession of guns have ever shot anyone.

        • KmCO

          It is not a “mental illness.”

        • Origami Isopod

          It is not a “mental illness,” you ignorant fuck. It is a developmental disorder. They are not the same thing.

          • ThrottleJockey

            Is this all you care to share, or is there something more you care to illuminate?

            • Anonymous

              You’re just an ‘ignorant fuck’.

              This technique is used extensively in the Harvard debate club to win arguments.

            • Origami Isopod

              “All”? That’s a major difference with important ramifications. The fact that you consider it petty indicates that you shouldn’t be flapping your pig-ignorant yap about the subject. And the fact that JenBlob’s giving you moral support here should also make you think.

      • argolid

        He wasn’t white, he was biracial. His mother was ethnic Chinese. It sounds to me like race was a major issue for him. He dyed his hair blond in grade school and also made a point of mentioning the fact that he was half white when he was talking about blonde girls not liking him. It seems he thought that being part Asian was one of the reasons women didn’t respond to him.Our society’s emasculating stereotypes about Asian males likely played a part in his complex of intense resentments.

        And to the question of whether he was mentally ill, of course he was. This kid was absolutely bonkers. It doesn’t excuse his actions, but it does indict our system and its uselessness in proactively detaining and treating mentally ill people who are likely to become violent.

    • mojrim

      Everyone wants to keep crazy people from getting guns and killing people, the question is always “how?” The system that requires a court to revoke his right to a gun is the same that keeps you from being imprisoned without trial or charge. He was an adult with no criminal record that charmed the police. Maybe a better system is possible, but you really have to be specific.

      • Brad Nailer

        Well, we could start by getting the NRA out of the fucking way of our anybody anywhere doing research on the true status of Guns in America today. Just pick a research topic on the socioeconomics of guns; there’s probably one for every doctoral candidate in social psychology, criminology and public health who wants one, enough to give us–and the courts–all the information we need to start dealing with this problem effectively.

        But no, the NRA will not allow our (their) politicians to get the massive funding power of the federal government behind such an effort. And no real research means we are left with the anecdotal pseudoscience of people like Wayne LaPierre, who see–rightly–the end of the gravy train they’re riding on that would come about from real academic and governmental attention finally being paid to this horrible problem.

        “Unconscionable” is too good a word for it.

        • Anonymous

          Just pick a research topic on the socioeconomics of guns; there’s probably one for every doctoral candidate in social psychology, criminology and public health who wants one, enough to give us–and the courts–all the information we need to start dealing with this problem effectively.

          Already done. It’s just that you don’t like the answer that was arrived at.

          …the long run analysis showed no significant effect on overall crime with a positive effect on rape and a deterrent effect on robbery.

          Of course, there’s also the constitutionality issue that access to guns is an explicit individual right as recently reaffirmed by the Supreme Court.

          A right doesn’t have to be defended. That’s what makes it a right. It just is.

        • mojrim

          That’s a perfect non-answer. It’s easy to make out an enemies list, much harder to come up with working solutions.

    • Tristan

      Of course he did. He’s white.

      • Anonymous

        Um, no he isn’t white. His mother is Chinese. But nice illustration of a knee-jerk assumption there.

        • john not mccain

          He’s as white as you are, pervert.

        • ChrisTS

          Wait, Chinese are not white? Half Chinese/half Anglo kids are not white?

  • herr doktor bimler

    Somehow the idea has taken root in American culture* that if you are feeling miserable and rejected by your peers, the appropriate response is to go and shoot a lot of strangers, rather than write bad Emo poetry like we used to in my day. So you can’t just blame misogyny and MRAs.

    * Possibly involving the NRA arms industry lobbyists.

    • Anonymous

      He’s not American.

      • He is, in fact, American.

        • Anonymous

          He’s from CA

          • Malaclypse

            So, not the old Confederacy, for a change?

            • rea

              Southen CA, in fact, had to be forcibly restrained from joining the Confederacy

          • Gregor Sansa

            Central America? Canada? California?

        • Anonymous

          He’s not American and his family aren’t American.

          • N__B

            We all know it’s very important for you to keep saying this, but he’s been living in the U.S. since he was 5. Since the issue is the effect of culture on impressionable youth, it really doesn’t matter where he was born.

            • Anonymous

              It does, however matter what his loyalties are.

              Where are your loyalties?

              • delurking

                Is that you, Joseph?

                • ChrisTS

                  Honest to gods. Who is this idiot troll and why won’t it die?

          • LeeEsq

            Where he’s from is irrelevant when it comes to men persecuting woman things are universal.

            • ThrottleJockey

              China faces a pretty serious deficit of women to men. They forecast that by 2030 something like 25% of Chinese men will be single. Considering they are even more patriarchal than the US is, I wonder how much of this problem they’ll face?

              • Ahuitzotl

                well guns are a lot harder to get hold of. Knifing seems to be on a huge rise tho

              • That should put them on the fast track to legalizing same sex marriage.

            • Anonymous

              Agreed, so the gun issue is, to a certain extent, a red herring. Misogyny is the reason and the means.

              • delurking

                Yes, of course. He could have just as easily killed all those people by shouting MRA slogans at them, after all.

                Or with a baseball bat. Why, did you know that more homicides are committed every year with baseball bats than with guns!?1!!

                • Anonymous

                  Men tend to kill women with their hands, so, yes, if he didn’t have the ability to get guns (which he acquired, according to his manifesto, a year or more ago), he’d have done something else. He “lured” people to his apartment. Close quarters doesn’t require a gun, and he wasn’t a gun fetishist like Lanza.

                • Anonymous

                  Also, he stabbed the men in that apartment. Not shot.

                • delurking

                  Explain to me, Anonymous, how he could have strangled seven women in a crowd without someone stopping him.

                  I’ll be waiting over here.

                • Anonymous

                  What? Who said anything about strangling or in public? You’re aware the rates of violence against women? You’re aware the bulk of these crimes don’t occur in the midst of crowds?

                  Good. Stop bullshitting.

                • Anonymous

                  Additionally, he tried his best to slaughter his chosen victims — blonde women belonging to sororities — but they wouldn’t answer the door. He’d clearly planned to invade a women’s off-campus dormitory and murder as many as possible, and not in private. He chose to pot-shot random people and run over others.

              • LeeEsq

                The gun issue is not a red hearing because limiting access to guns prevents people inclined to do so from wrecking havoc. They can’t do much without their tools.

                • Anonymous

                  He stabbed three of the six victims, and he used his car on countless more survivors.

                  I’m fine with banning guns. I’d like “crazy” and “gun control” in this discussion to take a back seat to misogyny.

                • delurking

                  I’m fine with gun control taking a back seat to misogyny, so long as you also acknowledge it’s much harder to go on shooting sprees, like this one and the one done by Marc Lepine, not to mention the Aurora shooting, without access to guns.

                  Yes, you can kill people in other ways. No, you can’t kill large numbers of people easily and swiftly and without being stopped in other ways.

                • Anonymous

                  I don’t disagree with any of that. I’m tired of women’s systematic oppression being stifled because we need to talk about guns right now.

                  And, again, not for nothing, three of his victims were stabbed in private, in his apartment. Assholes will find a way.

                  I’d prefer guns not be available to anyone. Misogyny will still exist when (hopefully) that happens in this country.

                • Origami Isopod

                  Thank you, Anonymous.

                  The gun issue is certainly important. The misogyny issue needs to be addressed more.

          • calling all toasters

            He’s as American as pancakes.

          • Bruce Baugh

            Not like a real American like John McCain or Ted Cruz.

      • Alex O’connor

        Irrelevant. He had a gun. The only people who murder people by ripping through flesh with bullets are those who are in possession of guns. No one else is capable of that.

        Only possessors of guns murder people with guns.

  • Joseph Nobles

    There’s a report of 3 bodies being pulled from his apartment, but the reporter couldn’t confirm if these were already known by police.

    • Jesus.

      • Alex O’connor

        Yes. There were allegedly three bodies at Jesus’ crucifixion. At least one was a thief, at least one was a murderer, the other a con man.

        • Malaclypse

          They crucified Paul of Tarsus?

          • rea

            Paul, being a Roman citizen, unlike Jesus or Peter, got beheaded, not crucified.

            • Malaclypse

              Yes, I know. I was taking the piss.

    • C

      No sign of this any where in the coverage I read. Care to cite your source?

      • Joseph Nobles
      • Mike G
        • Richard

          Its now been confirmed. Three bodies were found at his residence, all men and stabbed to death according to the police

          • Alex O’connor

            Being stabbed to death is so much more gruesome than being dismembered by high velocity toxic projectiles ripping through your flesh and organs.

            And on top of that one who slashes people to death via knife, dagger, cutlass or bastard sword simply are not ardent enough defenders of the 2nd amendment right to bear arms.

            Behead someone is a single motion…pussy; pull a trigger a watch some one bleed from their liver; that make you a real man…..and likely a republican to boot

  • Keaaukane

    I don’t claim to be an expert in How to Pick up Chicks, but I suspect that the “Armed psycho” approach doesn’t work very well.

    • Gregor Sansa

      Even if you rename it “supreme gentleman”?

    • ChrisTS

      One of the creepiest aspects of his 140+ page life story is that he seems to have thought girls should come on to him. He would walk around, or sit around at parties, and fume that girls paid attention to guys who spoke to them.

      • delurking

        Well, you know, after all he was half-white.

        • ChrisTS

          :-)

  • Sly

    Someone on twitter said it was time to label MRA-type groups as hate groups. Yes. It’s past time.

    I don’t suppose its all that important to distinguish between the various subcultures of internet misogyny, but the murderer’s an “Incel” (involuntarily celibate); people who find themselves perpetually on the outs with their sexual fetish du jour and end up blaming the entire gender for it. Mostly males, though female Incels are not unheard of.

    Their sort of the obverse of Pick-Up Artists, and generally hate Pick-Up Artists for their self-proclaimed success in deceiving their way into a woman’s bed. The murderer was apparently a regular at PUAHate, one of the major Incel sites, which has been taken down in anticipation of the negative publicity.

    • I don’t suppose its all that important to distinguish between the various subcultures of internet misogyny

      I appreciate your fleshing out his bio a bit, but, no, in the end,all forms of misogyny are playing into this.

      • Anonymous

        Seriously. How are PUA-haters whose worldview is based around what women aren’t doing for them not an MRA group?

        • Sly

          There’s a pretty broad overlap between all of them, but they vary in terms of their core resentment of women and how it molds their particular styles of argumentation. Incels/PUAs hate women over perceived sexual rejection, MRAs/MGTOWs hate women over perceived political marginalization. Incels/PUAs couch their rhetoric in explicitly sexual terms, while MRAs/MGTOWs do so in political terms. All would agree with one another than women (particular “Western Women”) have too much sexual “power,” and that “hypergamy” is the root cause of male sexual disempowerment, but address it from different vantage points.

          Again, probably not all the important. Maybe its because the internet is dark and full of terrors, and I’m just overly resentful about knowing all this bullshit and wish to inflict that distress on others.

          • Murc

            Oh god, I hate myself preemptively for even asking…

            Hypergamy? The fuck is that?

            • wjts

              Technically, marrying above one’s social station. In MRA-style hatespeak, “dating or fucking a man who is wealthier, better looking, or less of a narcissistic jackass than I am”.

            • Nick

              ‘Hypergamy’ is an MRA ‘theory’ of women’s behaviour — that modern society has enabled women to have promiscuous sex with alpha males, so that 10% of the men sleep with as many women as they want, and the rest of the men get jack all. This is one reason that these philosophies attract so many conservative Catholics, because they have a theory of society that’s based on a critique of women’s sexuality.

              A second, even stupider adjunct to ‘hypergamy’, is that it causes women’s oxytocin receptors to burn out, so that when they get fat and marry a beta male for mercenary purposes, they feel no loyalty or honour towards him, don’t bond to him, and will use him for base purposes.

              Now everyone’s life is richer!

            • herr doktor bimler

              I’m going out on a limb here to speculate that the MRAs bring in Evo-Psych cargo-cult science when they talk about this. Mating choices are a marketplace, because evolution, therefore it is the wimmin’s fault when someone else outbids me.

              • Nick

                Your limb is thick and strong.

                • dk

                  That’s what she said!

              • Lee Rudolph

                Echidne, who reads Evo-Psych cargo-cult stuff so that you and I don’t have to, has posted plenty of confirmation of your speculation.

          • Anonymous

            I’m just overly resentful about knowing all this bullshit and wish to inflict that distress on others.

            None of what you’ve said is a secret. We all know this already. They hate women and believe the gubmint or “society” is oppressing them because women exist and don’t have to fuck or marry them because they say so.

        • Manju

          How are PUA-haters whose worldview is based around what women aren’t doing for them not an MRA group?

          I don’t know about this specific group, buy Pick Up Artists want to well, pick up women. They want to get laid.

          Their leaders write books about it and sell them to the “hot chicks with douchebags” crowd. These douchbags don’t want to hear about “Men’s Rights”, politics, abortion, custodial rights and such. They want to get laid.

      • DivGuy

        Yup. Based on Katie Baker’s Jezebel piece about Pua-Hate, this is clearly a misogynist hate group, just a misogynist hate group with a slightly different self-identity.

        • Aimai

          Yeah. Hating on PUA’s is just another way of hating on “Alpha Males” and the women who (supposedly) love them. Its just another splinter group within the MRA movement. Its not opposed to MRA/PUA attitudes towards women, which are universally horrific. It just is slightly more despairing and it fingers PUA’s as part of the problem because they are seen as successful males who market themeselves as master pickup artists to guys who have money to pay for tips which never, ever, pan out.

          • Nick

            Right, the MGTOW types view PUA’s as pussy-beggars; the MRA version of a millionaire socialist. At the same time, the MGTOWs look down on the people they term ‘incels’, because they don’t choose to go their own way, celibacy is forced on them.

            I used to read an MGTOW forum page for a while, not out of sympathy but because I came across the name elsewhere, thought it was strange, and then became very interested in the weird jargon and theories. Most of them are garden-variety misogynists, and from the amount of vocal hatred they have for women, I often thought that their contempt for the incels had a bit of too-vocal-by-half to it; but there are a few of them who did actually seem to be going their own way (i.e. hating women but ignoring them). For the rest, Manboobz summed it up pretty well once by asking “What do the MGTOW like to talk about? Women, mostly.”

            • Always been confused by MGTOW. If you want to go your own way shouldn’t you just shut the fuck up and go away? It seems like MGTOW won’t budge until we notice they’re going. Even then I have my doubts they’ll make good on their promise to GO.

              • Hogan

                I don’t think you’re confused at all.

              • Nick

                The problem with the MGTOW when they tried to interact with each other was that aside from hating women, they didn’t have too much in common. There was one particular type that tended to chase out all the others — conservative misogynist asshole, who also hated taxes, Obama, hippies, etc. — and so any MGTOWs who happened to be misogynistic hippies, liberals, black people, etc. tended to leave. Basically, they could talk about how they hated women, or they could fight about other issues. The overall common denominator was that they were all assholes, the kind of people who would brag about screaming “Wake up, dumbass!” at someone who was daydreaming while walking in public, stuff like that.

                The reason that they are all publicly going their own way, is that a very integral part of the MGTOW belief system is that when enough men GTOW, women will realize what is going on and regret it, but it will be too late and Men will laugh and laugh. They spend a lot of time talking about this sweet moment — the whole movement is basically about revenge.

                • DrS

                  Soon they’ll be asking each other “Who is Dick Galt?”

                • Julia Grey

                  What? They think that if most men stop all their creative and constant ways of begging us for attention, we’ll…regret it?

                  Uh…yeah.

                • Hogan

                  You never miss the arsenic-laced water till the well runs dry.

                • delurking

                  You’ll be sorry when they run away from home, Mommy slut!

              • Anna in PDX

                They (MGTOW and other dumb MRA subgroups) sound to me a lot like the antagonist characters in superhero movies. “One of these days you’re all going to be SORRY!” But then one of them actually goes out and kills a bunch of people – yikes.

          • Linnaeus

            The “fractal” nature of the various MRA groups is quite remarkable.

            • But, can they fracture into as many groupsicles as the Trotskyites or Maoists? That is the real challenge. 8-)

              • Malaclypse

                Trotskyist, comrade.

                • Trotskiïst.

                • calling all toasters

                  However you spell it, still better than being Trotnixonian.

                • Sly

                  Trotskiïst.

                  Bringing the revolution of the proletariat to the bunny slope since 1917.

                • Ahuitzotl

                  omg, 22 and never been trotskiist

            • herr doktor bimler

              I am reminded of 1980s ‘Guardian’ editorials, which were apparently under some kind of contractual obligation to use the word ‘fissiparous’ at least once in every discussion of UK leftwing politics.

        • PUA Hate poster

          Before we specifically blame PUA Hate, and as much as the readers collectively find it a loathsome board, is there any actual evidence that this homicidal individual was a member who posted there?

          Before blaming or partially blaming a particular group for murder committed by an individual there should at least be reliable evidence that they had contact with, and influenced him in a negative manner.

          The PUA Hate board started years ago, in response to the following observable facts.

          1) Many if not most of the Pick Up Artists leading courses on seduction could not actually seduce women themselves, oversold the usefulness of their material, or could not really teach their approach to others. Example, the Mystery Method was designed by a magician and took full advantage of his parlor tricks. “Do you believe in spells?” Cue intro. It is overtly complicated and has limited application for most males.

          2) Many of the individuals who so deeply desired to be PUAs had severely fucked up social skills and regardless of training could not be taught by anyone to be more successful with women.

          3) Though its been a hotly contested issue, a certain portion of any male’s success with women is independent of any “pick up techniques”. LMS stands for looks, money, status, a wealthy good looking male with a high status profession will always find it easier to meet and attract women then an under-employed, 5’5 balding guy who lives at home with his parents. (No surpise there)
          Obvious lesson: Get a better job, and move of of said basement.

          On PUA hate, the majority of posters appear to be under the age of 25, and spend a ridicious amount of time discussing whether they should somehow raise $30 K in order to get plastic surgery to somehow, improve their looks enough to be attractive to women.

          4) the PUA movement as a whole has a lot of women hating and rapey beliefs built in, it’s horrible, but not limited to PUA Hate.

          5) Some members of PUA Hate, talk about how much trying to be pick up artists have screwed up their social interactions with other people. That said, in this guy’s fairwell letter he only used one PUA term, “Alpha Male” and its not even a term exclusive to the PUA community.

          Many of the PUA Hate posters I’ve seen use more terms and acronyms then a critical lit conference. So I question how deeply our homicidal aspie was following the PUA or anti PUA boards. I’ll be interested to find out if he ever bought any books or paid for any “bootcamps”. Real Social Dynamics would have been an obvious choice for him since they do a lot of work in LA, but that’s pure speculation on my part.

          Flame away

          • wjts

            Blow it out your ass, you disgusting sack of shit.

            • ChrisTS

              Can we haz ‘like’ bootin, now?

          • wjts

            Before blaming or partially blaming a particular group for murder committed by an individual there should at least be reliable evidence that they had contact with, and influenced him in a negative manner.

            Here. It’s more than you deserve.

            The Spring of 2013 was also the time when I came across the website PUAHate.com. It is a forum full of men who are starved of sex, just like me. Many of them have their own theories of what women are attracted to, and many of them share my hatred of women, though unlike me they would be too cowardly to act on it. Reading the posts on that website only confirmed many of the theories I had about how wicked and degenerate women really are. Most of the people on that website have extremely stupid opinions that I found very frustrating, but I found a few to be quite insightful.

            The website PUAHate is very depressing. It shows just how bleak and cruel the world is due of the evilness of women. I tried to show it to my parents, to give them some sort dose of reality as to why I am so miserable. They never understood why I am so miserable. They have always had the delusion that everything is going well for me, especially my father. When I sent the link of PUAHate.com to my parents, none of them even bothered to look at the posts on there.

            • PUA Hate poster

              Hi Wjts:

              That establishes that he posted at PUA Hate and thought he learned something there. He learned the wrong lesson, one that had nothing to do with self improvement, and one he was probably pre-determined to learn.

              “The website PUAHate is very depressing. It shows just how bleak and cruel the world is due of the evilness of women”

              That’s a post by someone who obviously sees the wrong “why”. A social interaction doesn’t work so the person on the other side must be “evil”. Most people understand that social interactions frequently don’t work, and simply to try to improve how they deal with other people when it is possible. And that applies in both dating and non-dating situations.

              A person who labels themselves as “incel” normally has the self awareness to know that there is something they are doing which is causing their dating problems. This guy however had no such understanding and a sense of self entitlement which I do not believe represents the majority of posters, though it does represent in my judgment, about 10% of the people who post on PUAhate.

              I would bet that these posts were made in the Shitty Advice forum, which has served as the location of such venting, and has been viewed as the landfill of the site. Moderators generally don’t police that sub forum which is made up of troll thread after troll thread. (Up to 60 a day on a whole bunch of different complaints)

              • wjts

                That establishes that he posted at PUA Hate and thought he learned something there. He learned the wrong lesson, one that had nothing to do with self improvement, and one he was probably pre-determined to learn.

                Internet misogyny cesspools cannot fail; they can only be failed.

              • brad

                Indeed, why do all those homosexuals keep sucking your cock?

          • Sly

            1) Many if not most of the Pick Up Artists leading courses on seduction could not actually seduce women themselves, oversold the usefulness of their material, or could not really teach their approach to others. Example, the Mystery Method was designed by a magician and took full advantage of his parlor tricks. “Do you believe in spells?” Cue intro. It is overtly complicated and has limited application for most males.

            And this is the basic problem. Those who self-identify as Incels don’t frown upon PUAs because they are conning women, they frown upon PUAs for conning men. Not to mention blaming women for the entire situation.

            A healthy individual shouldn’t want what PUAs are advertising in the first place; not because what they’re selling “doesn’t work,” but because, even if it did, PUAs are fucking scummy.

            That a lot of Incels come across as failed PUAs with an oversized victim complex shouldn’t be surprising; a lot of them, frankly, are just that. But its not because, as an MGTOW would say, they “put the pussy on a pedestal” or, as a PUA would say, they “lack game” or “aren’t Alpha.” It’s because all of these groups have fundamentally warped views of sexuality that are going to make them all miserable until they cast them aside and become adults.

      • mojrim

        How do you seriously imagine this is about misogyny at it’s root? The reality is that humans will seize any justification loop for their anger – race, religion, sex, sexual preference. It all originates after the anger, it’s never the cause.

        The world is full of disaffected, socially awkward, emotionally disregulated people that watch the world move on without them. Depending on their circumstances some become religious terrorists, others mass shooters, and still others find some other damn thing. The point is that their feelings about the target group come after the anger; they will kill someone, the ideas just help them aim the gun.

        • dk

          How do you seriously imagine that people who spend all day talking about how they hate women aren’t misogynists?

          • mojrim

            No, I’m saying that misogyny is an effect rather than a cause of the underlying problem. Just as is religious fanaticism or any other thing people use to become crazy mass killers. The psychology of terrorism is instructive in these regards.

        • Origami Isopod

          So, so surprised to see Mojrim being clueless about gender issues.

        • ChrisTS

          So, poor white racists are not really racists because their racism – uh – anger directed at PoC is really just anger.

          Wait. Did I get that right?

          • mojrim

            No, not even close. You and Origami Isopod are too busy knee-jerking to even try.

            • delurking

              Hate speech and violence (up to and including murder) are only meaningless symptoms when directed against women, ChrisTS.

              Surely that’s clear to you.

              • ChrisTS

                Shit. Another fact I keep forgetting.

                I do keep lists, truly.

            • ChrisTS

              Ok. Let’s try again.

              How do you seriously imagine this is about misogyny at it’s root? The reality is that humans will seize any justification loop for their anger – race, religion, sex, sexual preference. It all originates after the anger, it’s never the cause.

              and

              The point is that their feelings about the target group come after the anger; they will kill someone, the ideas just help them aim the gun.

              So, according to you, what others mistakenly call ‘racism’ is not hatred of PoC; it is anger that found a target in PoC. Just like, what others mistakenly call ‘misogyny’ is not hatred of women; it is just anger that found a target in women.

              That is what you wrote, Dearie. Own it.

              • Lee Rudolph

                I think that’s not quite what he’s saying, because I think (1) he’s distinguishing “anger” from “hatred”, and more specifically saying that (2) “anger” can lead (directly) to acts (in particular, to killing its objects), whereas (3) “hatred” doesn’t lead (directly) either to acts or to “anger” (which has other sources, presumably), though it may channel “anger” to more hated rather than less hated objects.

                But to check whether that’s what he’s actually saying I’d have to scroll up the screen, and that’s more than I’m up to, at the moment.

              • mojrim

                Close, but Lee (below) did better.

        • Ronan

          There’s probably a very very nuanced and complicated arguement you could make here, (about the nature of violence and hatred etc ), and with access to enough info on him you could probably build a deep portrait which could semi support what you’re saying here, with *a lot* of caveats and complications.
          But in the absence of that you’re just spouting vage generalisations and cliches, and ignoring the huge amount of catalogued evidence (from his own biography, in his own words) which shows that he was driven by a hatred of women, that he wanted to kill because of his rejections by women, and that his entire life had become consumed in an all encompasing desire to punish the women who wouldnt sleep/date him.
          I have no idea why you feel the need to make the second argument (try and make the first, by all means)

          • mojrim

            Pretty simple:
            1. Bad analysis leads to bad solutions.
            2. Confessions are the only thing more worthless than witness statements.

            When a person is talking about themselves you can write off 50% of their words as self-justifying bullshit, presuming they actually know why they do things in the first place. As a professional matter, I have learned to never take anyone’s statements at face value, especially since most people are unaware of their own underlying motives.

    • sharculese

      Mostly males, though female Incels are not unheard of.

      This used to be the point where I’d link the long, vitriolic discussion on the wikipedia talk page for incel were a bunch of dudes insisted a woman can’t be incel, because any woman can have sex if she looks hard enough. Wikipedia seems to have since, and mercifully, deleted that article.

      • Gregor Sansa

        One of the lasting shames in my life, the ones I’ve never told anyone about, is that I once made a face when a female friend of mine suggested we have sex.

        Yes, I expect that pretty much any woman could get sex, if she were willing to be rejected several times, and then probably also treated like dirt by the person who finally takes her up on her offer. But since most people have some pride, there are definitely women who involuntarily go without.

        • Gregor Sansa

          That came out wrong. When I said “people”, I meant women.

        • What kind of face did you make? Like Harpo Marx?

          • Gregor Sansa

            I don’t want to say “disgusted” because that would be exaggerating. But it was in that neighborhood. It wasn’t intentional, but we weren’t friends after that.

            It can be hard out there for women, too, is my point. Especially if they’ve got a tin ear socially. (Not saying “aspbergers” because I’m a bad friend, not a doctor.)

            • Gregor Sansa

              We were a group of 4 nerdy outcasts at college (insofar as there are such… that is, far less outcast than it would have been at younger ages). She was the youngest and still the deepest in her nerdy cocoon.

          • Breadbaker

            The Harpo face to which you refer is called a Gookie.

      • cpinva

        this is probably true, to an extent:

        “because any woman can have sex if she looks hard enough.”

        and the same can be said about pretty much any guy, unless maybe you’re Quasimodo. that said, even the least attractive woman is going to have some sense of self respect, and would rather spend the night with “Mr. D Cell”, than with some douchebag (who even she would be embarrassed to be seen in public with), who’s going to treat her like shit. maybe I’m giving women too much credit, but I don’t think so.

        • Julia Grey

          Yes, and note that our shooter here deeply resented the fact that “hot” blonde sorority women were not interested in having sex with him.

          But seriously, how creepy would he have to be to not be able to get any action from, say, the pretty coffee shop waitress who knew what kind of car he drove and what kind of clothes he wore? Methinks he didn’t even try to use PUA techniques on “lesser” beings.

          He insisted that he deserved only the best.

          • cpinva

            well, if you throw in the fact that he was an extremely entitled, self-centered douchebag, it’s a shock that incredibly beautiful, smart women weren’t flocking to him. add in the mental illness aspect, and it’s surprising there wasn’t a line at his front door. I have no sympathy for him, only for his victims.

          • Linnaeus

            Yeah, there’s a real irony in that guys like these complain about how (certain) women won’t give them the time of day, yet they themselves overlook women who might be interested in them. Because they’re not worthy or some such bullshit.

      • Manny Kant

        It apparently has been hidden as the article “Denise Donnelly,” who is apparently a psychologist who’s done research on the subject, but you can still find all the old history of the article and talk page. What a horror show that was.

      • Article on incel wasn’t deleted for scientific reasons or notability reasons. It was delete due to a desire to harm incels.

        I know this because I know a man who was behind it.

    • NewishLawyer

      I know I shouldn’t be surprised by this but I am.

      Do people really invent whole taxonomies to describe not having great luck romantically and sexually?

      I’m kind of floored by that.

      • sharculese

        Whole taxonomies? Honestly, not so much. There are about three ‘labels’ dudes who’s primary frustration with women is a lack of romantic success will pick up. Of the ones who are comfortable admitting that that’s what the issue is, most will call themselves ‘incel’ and a few will call themselves ‘forever alone’ although it seems like that label is falling out of favor.

        The dudes who don’t want to be explicit in that label will call themselves MGTOW (men going their own way) as a way of not having to admit that women don’t want to be around them because of their toxic views.

        • sharculese

          And now you’re wishing you hadn’t asked.

          • Ian

            a few will call themselves ‘forever alone’ although it seems like that label is falling out of favor.

            That’s a shame. Unlike pretty much everything in that subculture there’s something charming about it, a bit of sad-sack laughing at oneself.

        • Jordan

          and a few will call themselves ‘forever alone’ although it seems like that label is falling out of favor.

          Wait, is that where the rage comic thing comes from??? Or did they see that and were like “sign me up!”?

      • LeeEsq

        Humans form tribes and tribes need names. The internet makes it easier for people to form tribes based on practically everything. Male My LittLe Pony fans call themselves Bronies of all things. Usually its all in good fun but sometimes it can get exasperating.

        I think that lots of people derive much psychological comfort from tribal identities and names. Its a sign that your not alone in your tastes or problems and that others like you are out there. Even if you don’t have much social contact with others like you, having a collective name can create some sense of belonging and community. That helps people struggling with feelings of alienation and loneliness.

        • herr doktor bimler

          Even if you don’t have much social contact with others like you, having a collective name can create some sense of belonging and community.

          Vonnegut had a word for it.

    • Manny Kant

      Oh, God, incels. Somehow, back when I used to be more involved in Wikipedia than I am now, I came upon the Wikipedia article on involuntary celibacy. It was an amazing document of self-pitying BS with no sources. When I went to the talk page to try to figure out what was going on, the whole thing just turned into a self-pity party with a bunch of wikipedia users complaining about how they were “Incels,” and how hard life was for them. Jesus Christ.

  • wjts

    The intersection of anxious masculinity, male supremacy, and firearms can be pretty fucking horrific.

    • Yup.

    • STH
      • wjts

        Not all men who stew in a toxic bath of self-loathing and echo-chamber misogyny are mass murders, of course, so it’s really not on to make these sorts of connections.

        • Which, of course, makes them part of the solution, right?

        • lolo

          No, to be fair, some just end up becoming rapists and wife beaters.

    • N__B

      A lot of these guys also believe in “human biodiversity” racism.

      • Linnaeus

        That’s like the superfecta of privilege ideologies.

      • Do I want to Google that or do I want to continue to enjoy my buzz?

        • Hogan

          Go with the buzz.

          • I take you as a credible source, so I’ll make a note for later. Besides, I’m sure the racist troll below will trot it out soon.

            • Malaclypse

              Vox Day believes in human biodiversity. Ask yourself, do you really want to know more?

        • JL

          Instead of Googling it later, you could read about it at Pharyngula, so that at least your first exposure to it would be someone mocking it and this might make you despair less.

    • ThrottleJockey

      I wonder how much of a problem China will have with this since they’re creating a society with about 25% more men than women, and they’re even more patriarchal than the US.

  • brad

    Yeah, what terrifies me more than anything is how common everything but his final outburst is in terms of the ease with which you can find people spewing it online.
    And I’m a privileged white male, I can’t begin to imagine what his acts do magnify the already far too legit concerns of those young women who live in overlapping worlds with these monsters.

    • Mungaf

      Privileged white male checking in. One of the striking things about teenagers and young adults who think like this is how lonely they are, and how in their loneliness and total self-focus they create totally whack explanations for why the world is passing them by.

      I think constant exposure to closed off internet communities with their own lingo and norms aggravates this, but so does ultra-competitiveness in school with little space for socialization and play, parents working extremely long hours and little involved, growing up in sprawling suburbs with little communal focus besides aiding the growth of private wealth, etc. I imagine this has all gotten worse.

      • I may be totally off base here. But, it seems that while there have always been marginalized and outcast individuals and groups, especially among adolescents that the reactions have become much more extreme in recent decades. Before the Columbine shootings it seems that while there were miserable people along these lines that they usually managed to eventually outgrow their feelings rather than commit any acts of mass violence. I suppose the internet is one explanation for this transformation. But, I think there is something else going on and I don’t know enough about the peculiar world these people dwell in to figure it out.

        • ThrottleJockey

          First point: We’re probably just more familiar with it in the information age. That Malay has a specific word for it is suggestive:

          Running amok, sometimes referred to as simply amok,[1] also spelled amuk, from the Malay,[2] is “an episode of sudden mass assault against people or objects usually by a single individual following a period of brooding that has traditionally been regarded as occurring especially in Indonesian culture but is now increasingly viewed as psychopathological behavior occurring worldwide in numerous countries and cultures”.[3] The syndrome of “Amok” is found in the DSM-IV TR.[4]

          Slate also discussed mass murders prior to the 1900s. Short version: They used fire.

          Second point: With 315M Americans, even if the incidence rate is a constant .01% that’s still 31.5K. More than enough to cover every day of the year.

          • Scott P.

            Such individuals tend to prefer the lirpa, or perhaps the ahn-woon, as their weapon of choice.

        • Mo

          I’d recommend reading “I, Pierre Rivière, Having Slaughtered My Mother, My Sister, and My Brother…” It’s about the 1835 case of a young man in rural France who out of hatred for his mother’s treatment of his father cut up his family with a pruning hook and wrote a memoir in prison. The book exploring the case is by Michel Foucault. I found wondering at the case through the lens of how it would be seen today more interesting than Foucault’s theorizing. It also goes to show that murderous misogyny is nothing new.

      • NewishLawyer

        I think you are right about the Internet creating communities that reinforce viewpoints and come up with entire taxonomies.

        This is not entirely bad. You probably do have a lot of people who were real outsiders or had very specific hobbies who can use the internet to form communities and friendships but it does lead to bubbles. A lot of problems and breakdowns in debate seem to be over miscommunications because of unshared language and one side assuming that someone knows their shorthand.

        The really dark side is when you have hate groups like the Vanguard News Network or MRA groups reach out. I think MRAs are a lot more powerful because of the internet.

        I am remembering last year when liberal art collectors were shocked to find out that Charles Kraftt was a real neo-Nazi.*

        *Charles Kraftt became famous for a series he called disasterware. Basically stuff like AK47s and grenades done in the style of delftware. Some of his work incorporated Nazi imagery. Liberals took it as a left-wing and ironic political stance about the astheticization of violence and war. The Stranger found out that Kraftt hung out on Neo-Nazi sites and chat boards and was a true believer in far-right politics.

        • LeeEsq

          This might be situation where you can’t through away the bathwater without throwing away the baby. The ability of the internet to allow the wrongfully excluded and ostracized from forming communities also allows the rightfully excluded and ostracized to form communities.

          • Linnaeus

            In another context, I used to tell my students that one of the greatest strengths of the internet was that virtually anyone can disseminate information on it. I then said that one of the greatest weaknesses of the internet is that virtually anyone can disseminate information on it.

            • ChrisTS

              I still tell my students that. The alert ones grin; the less alert plagiarize.

          • If people are ostracized and excluded in a proper and effective manner then the process should destroy their ability to form future communities. There is no worse failure from a social point of view than injuring somebody without totally neutralizing them. It leaves open the way for retaliation. I blame the imperfect ability of modern capitalism to completely atomize and marginalize individuals in this day and age. Maybe it will get better at this task in the future.

            • dk

              Say what you will about JOtto, every so often he hits one out of the park.

          • NewishLawyer

            I never meant to imply anything otherwise.

        • herr doktor bimler

          Charles Kraftt became famous for a series he called disasterware. Basically stuff like AK47s and grenades done in the style of delftware.

          Worse than a neo-Nazi, he’s a plagiarist.

      • LeftWingFox

        I think this goes to the core of all hate groups. All of us are the heroes of our own narratives. Most of us refuse to believe we might be the villain. At the low end, you see it in every community, when people take criticism of their actions as attacks on their character.

        This is made worse by entitlement and scapegoating. This guy believes that he should get girls. He can’t accept that the reason he can’t is because his personality is noxious (Certainly it’s not his looks or wealth.) Therefore, there’s a target to blame.

        Like any hate groups, the online misogynist groups blame someone else, in this case, women for this state of affairs, in the worst language possible. And I agree, the internet has served to make small hate groups viable.

        The guy isn’t insane, he’s been fed a philosophy where this is an acceptable course of action.

        • Julia Grey

          So well said.

        • Anonymous

          Dude literally wrote about a GoT fantasy in which most women are exterminated, but a chosen and select sexy few are kept in a harem he and only he can view from a tower where he is prince (meanwhile thinking to himself, if I can’t have them nobody can) while regular dudes who don’t know of the existence of women live, I don’t know, elsewhere?

          He wasn’t crazy. He was just a whiny asshole with no imagination. I can’t believe people are even debating this.

  • Brett

    The MRAs* we’re talking about have always been hate groups targeted at women. Even calling them “men’s rights associations” is like calling the KKK a “white people advancement society”.

    * That pisses me off, too, because there are legitimate issues for support groups for men – male single parents, men who have been the victim of sexual and other familial violence or violence in prisons, and so forth. But it ends up being tainted by these misogynistic fuckers.

    • Yes. This. So well said.

    • UserGoogol

      I’m fairly certain white supremacist groups have in fact described themselves as “white people advancement societies.” This seems to be a general trend not just among bigots but reactionaries in general. They take the language of progressive organizations and try to direct it towards defending their privileges.

      • Chris

        This seems to be a general trend not just among bigots but reactionaries in general. They take the language of progressive organizations and try to direct it towards defending their privileges.

        Hello, “National-Socialism.”

    • delurking

      Speaking of misogynist fuckers, Vox Day is blaming this shooting on, you guessed it, feminists.

      If only feminists didn’t slander proper alpha males, see, then this guy…

      Well, I don’t know. I don’t understand his argument from that point, especially since this guy = pretty much every guy who posts on VD’s noxious little hate blog.

      • Julia Grey

        No, no, not possible. THIS was a Nice Guy.

        • delurking

          This may be my problem with following VD’s argument, Julia. I can’t see much difference between Nice Guys and MRA asshats and the monsters at VD’s site.

          I think he’s claiming that his brand of monster should (by Natural Law) be dominate in the world, and have all the women; and then this guy (who’s not a real alpha male?) would…

          But here is where I lose him. Would what?

          Know his place? Be murdered by his alpha male betters? Be taught how to be a better alpha by his alpha betters?

          But WTF-ever. VD’s real point, as ever, is Bitches Had It Coming.

          • Julia Grey

            I was being ironic.

            • delurking

              I know! But for some reason the pathology of VD and his hate blog fascinates me. I just keep circling back, trying to find some way to make it make sense.

      • Ahuitzotl

        every guy, emphatically including Pox Day himself

        • delurking

          Yes.

    • MacK

      I have mentioned before the family law lawyers and judges I know who have the same reaction to the MRA types, and I’m paraphrasing:

      “Why is it so many of the MRA types reinforce every cliché that they claim the ‘man-haters’ have about men”

      “I’ve denied women custody for the exact same reasons I’d deny him…”

      “And if he was the mother, with issues like that, I’d deny her custody too”

      “This guy wants to blame his treatment on his being male, but the problem is it’s being who he is, not what he is”

  • McAllen

    His family apparently reported his videos to the police, who found him to be “polite and kind” and did nothing.

    • LeeEsq

      This isn’t really that surprising. Family members usually have difficulties understanding the potential of their loved ones to do great harm on the world. Its tragic but I can understand why parents, siblings, aunts, and uncles would be reluctant to say that their son, brother, or nephew might be a bastard.

      • Lee Rudolph

        You read carelessly. The family thought something was wrong. They called in the police. The police (according to the report) “found him to be ‘polite and kind'”.

        • LeeEsq

          Oh God. Thats bad in so many ways that I don’t even know where to begin.

        • somethingblue

          According to the family lawyer the police found him to be “perfectly polite, kind and a wonderful human.”

          This suggests to me that the family lawyer may perhaps not be quoting the police verbatim.

          • Lee Rudolph

            This suggests to me that the family lawyer may perhaps not be quoting the police verbatim.

            Quite possibly not. However, a commenter at PZ Meyer’s place has been posting what purports to be a transcript of a news conference given by the sheriff this afternoon (California time), and in the purported transcript the sheriff purportedly says that

            deputies contacted him following request to check on his welfare from a family member. Deputies found him to be polite and courteous,

            so, also quite possibly so.

            • ThrottleJockey

              If the police can’t stop this shit with advance warning who the fuck can?

              • LeeEsq

                How specific was the perpetrator in the video? Without a very specific plan like “I’m going to go on murder spree at this place at this time”, the police could have interpreted this as nothing more than a deranged rant.

                • Lord Jesus Perm

                  Trigger warning.

                  It’s an injustice, a crime, because I don’t know what you don’t see in me. I’m the perfect guy, and yet you throw yourselves at all these obnoxious men, instead of me, the supreme gentlemen.

                  I will punish all of you for it. (laughs)

                  On the day of retribution I am going to enter the hottest sorority house of UCSB… and I will slaughter every single spoiled, stuck-up, blonde slut I see inside there.

                  All those girls that I’ve desired so much, they would’ve all rejected me and looked down upon me as an inferior man if I ever made a sexual advance towards them while they throw themselves at these obnoxious brutes.

                  I will take great pleasure in slaughtering all of you.

                  You will finally see that I am in truth the superior one. The true alpha male. (laughs)

                  Yes, after I’ve annihilated every single girl in the sorority house, I’ll take to the streets of Isla Vista, and slay every single person I see there.

            • somethingblue

              Polite and courteous, sure. But kind and a wonderful human? Well, it is California, I guess. The local constabulary where I am are not quite so touchy-feely.

              • Hogan

                My predecessor, Mr. Flutie, may have gone in for all that touchy-feely relating nonsense – but he was eaten. You’re in my world now. And Sunnydale High has touched and felt for the last time.

                • Mr. Flutie’s death still amuses me.

                • Ahuitzotl

                  what, carnivore-to-carnivore admiration?

              • Mike G

                That was a quote from the family lawyer paraphrasing the police (supposedly), not the actual police report. The Sheriff said he didn’t meet the standard for an involuntary psych hold.

      • NewishLawyer

        I think he McAllen is saying that the family sent the videos to the police and the police did nothing.

        • wjts

          From his autobiography/manifesto, here is his account of the police visit:

          After only a week passed since I uploaded those videos on Youtube, I heard a knock on my apartment door. I opened it to see about seven police officers asking for me.

          As soon as I saw those cops, the biggest fear I had ever felt in my life overcame me.

          I had the striking and devastating fear that someone had somehow discovered what I was planning to do, and reported me for it.

          If that was the case, the police would have searched my room, found all of my guns and weapons, along with my writings about what I plan to do with them. I would have been thrown in jail, denied of the chance to exact revenge on my enemies. I can’t imagine a hell darker than that. Thankfully, that wasn’t the case, but it was so close.

          He describes the video in question thusly:

          I titled one of the videos I uploaded “Why do girls hate me so much?” in which I ask the entire population of women the question I’ve wanted to ask them for so many years. Why do they hate me so much? Why have they never fancied me? Why do they give their love and sex to other men, but not me, even though I deserve them more? In the video, I show that I am the perfect, magnificent gentleman, worthy of having a beautiful girlfriend, making the world see how unreasonable it is that I’ve had to struggle all my life to get a girlfriend. It is my attempt to reason with the female gender, to ask them why they have mistreated me. I was hoping I would get some sort of answer from girls. In fact, a small part of me was even hoping that a girl would see the video and contact me to give me a chance to go on a date. That alone would have prevented the Day of Retribution, if one girl had just given me one chance. But no… As expected, I got absolutely no response from any girls. The only responses I got were from other men who called me names and made fun of me. Women don’t care about me at all. They won’t even deign to tell my why they’ve mistreated me. This just shows how evil and sadistic they are. Oh well, they will realize the gravity of their crimes when I slaughter them all on the Day of Retribution. How dare they reject a magnificent gentleman like me!

          I don’t know if the police would have had probable cause to search his apartment. In hindsight, I obviously wish they had.

          • brad

            Jesus.
            He went on a fucking murder spree because women didn’t literally seek him out online to offer themselves to him.

            I already knew this, but to see it so starkly, I can’t even.

  • NewishLawyer

    I did not always have the best luck romantically. Most of my romantic life often consisted of going on 1-4 dates with women from OKCupid and being told I was “nice and sweet but they did not feel any chemistry.”

    Did I like this? No. It hurts to put yourself out there and be rejected and there were a lot of times when it seemed to go very well. There was one woman who said “When can we see each other next?” and then told me the next day that she changed her mind and she thought we would not be compatible but she wished me the best of luck in life and love.

    But you know what, all that rejection never made me want to go on rampage and kill people. I did not blame the entirety of the female gender for my relative lack of romantic success.

    I really don’t understand the MRA movement or this guy in particular. I really don’t.

    • wjts

      Honestly, my own romantic/sexual background is pretty similar to Rodger’s. I even had a brief flirtation with “NiceGuyism” in my early 20s. Based on my own experience, I strongly suspect that the appeal of the MRA/PUA/What-have-you outlook is that it serves as a means of self-defense and exoneration. Everyone is the hero of their own story, and this attitude lets the holder say, “Romantically and sexually, things aren’t working the way I want. There must be a problem somewhere, either with me or with the woman I’m interested in. There’s nothing wrong with me. I have many virtues. I’m nice. So the problem must be with them. And they can’t hate me because of my flaws, which are minor, so they must hate me because of my virtues. Which makes them the bad guys here, worthy of anything from contempt to hatred.”

      • LeeEsq

        Romance and sexual success as a strong element of luck in it. Its very possible to do everything right or at least do nothing wrong and get nowhere because the other side isn’t into for whatever reason. A lot of people can’t accept this.

      • Linnaeus

        I would say this is similar to my own experience.

        • cpinva

          “I would say this is similar to my own experience.”

          I would say that’s similar to pretty much everyone’s experience, unless your family has arranged a marriage for you. then you have to worry that the two of you can’t stand each other.

          • Nick

            I totally disagree — many people are happy sexually and emotionally, and many are not; and of those who aren’t, it’s often not for want of trying.

        • KmCO

          My own as well, and I come from the other side of it, being a woman. It IS frustrating as hell sometimes.

      • Julia Grey

        Headline:

        “NICE GUY” FINALLY GETS LAID….

        ON A SLAB AT THE MORGUE.

        Fucker.

    • Sly

      The question that tends to bother me is whether or not I would be among these assholes were it not for the fact that I watched an inordinate amount of Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood as a kid.

      • LeeEsq

        I have the same feelings with the only thing preventing me from going nuts is knowing that women and men like me platonically and that my tribal identity is elsewhere.

      • wjts

        I never liked Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood and I haven’t killed anybody.

        • Anonymous

          Not yet…

          It’s pretty common knowledge that down deep, everyone is a murderer down deep inside. Ya’ know, just as everyone is queer when you look deep enough.

          You cannot be trusted

    • Biscuits

      My son wants a girlfriend and has been on a bit of a dry spell in the romance department. I tell him these things often happen when you least expect it. To be open and approachable and polite. He goes out with friends to area bars and what not in the Seattle area but is a bit shy. He would never feel he was owed or entitled to companionship but could use a little confidence when it comes to women.
      My daughters, shy as well ( a family curse, I’m convinced) get the same advice, with caveats, women just have to be more “aware”. None of them blame their lack of romance on the opposite sex. Just haven’t had the right opportunity show itself.

      This recent carnage is just so sad and tragic.

      • Anna in PDX

        My son is currently getting over a breakup and after reading this thread I called him just to say “hi”. I hope he is aware that he is not the only lonely person out there. I am grateful for everyone on this comment thread who has discussed their own background with rejection and loneliness because it really helps others to cope with theirs.

        • cpinva

          “I hope he is aware that he is not the only lonely person out there.”

          being alone, and being lonely are not, by definition, mutually inclusive. being alone gives you time to (as the pop psych’s say) find yourself, explore new interests, clean out the garage, etc., maybe even join a group that shares your interest in whatever. great thing about that is, you already have something in common, should you meet a member who is also alone. you can be lonely with lots of friends.

        • Biscuits

          It’s so hard to see your kid suffer a broken heart. We as parents can only encourage and be there for them and let them know we love them. Life’s lessons I find are hardest when viewed through your child. We wish we could take the pain away and make everything sunny, good, and perfect. He will emerge stronger and smarter, especially with a mom who cares but still gives him his own space to figure it out. ;)

    • Jack the Second

      I’ve been reading this thread and trying to think of what advice I’d give to someone (eg, a son) to try to help them not be an angry murdering asshole.

      So far the best I’ve been able to come up with is “don’t let your sexual identity be your primary identity”. The accused in this crime, and the MRA/PUA community in general, seem to be defining themselves too much by their sex life, or lack thereof. They’re getting sex, so they’re a winner, or they’re not getting sex, so they’re a loser. People are so much more than that.

      I think there’s a corollary, “don’t treat other people’s sexual identities like their primary identity”, which a lot of assholes are also guilty of violating.

      • wjts

        So far the best I’ve been able to come up with is “don’t let your sexual identity be your primary identity”.

        Because I’m morbidly curious by temperament, I read his 140-page autobiography/manifesto and that’s one thing that he hammers home over and over again: women make him feel like a loser because they won’t date him or sleep with him. Men make him feel like a loser because they’re dating or sleeping with women while he’s not. Which is, I think, something that most people feel at some point or another for a day or a week or a couple of months. But here, this resentment grew inside of him and metastasized into a sense of all-consuming rage. He let himself become defined by his singleness, going so far as to view the experiences he has had (trips to London, attending film premieres) as worthless and depressing because there wasn’t an attractive woman on his arm when he had them.

        The other piece of advice that comes to mind after reading his manifesto is “do things”. He plays ungodly amounts of World of Warcraft and wonders why he never gets to go to parties (not that there’s anything wrong with playing World of Warcraft, but if you’re playing 14 hours a day and sleeping 8 hours a night that only leaves two hours a day in which you could conceivably go to parties). He writes about trying to meet women by sitting in front of Domino’s Pizza and hoping that a tall, beautiful blonde (the only type of woman he ever expresses any interest in) will simply walk up to him and throw herself at her feet. There are obviously a couple of reasons for why this strategy isn’t particularly effective, but the most obvious one is that hanging out in front of Domino’s Pizza for hours at a stretch is not behavior that is likely to attract a romantic partner as it not conducive to particularly sparkling conversation. (“The garlic knots smell weird today.” “Yeah. Oooh, look – they’re restocking the Diet Cokes.”) So instead, go out an do things. If you’re in high school or college, join a club. Or an intramural sports team. Or play cards. Or go bird-watching. Or whatever. If you’re an adult, volunteer at the library. Or go bird-watching. Or whatever. But choose something that you’ll enjoy doing regardless of whether or not it actually gets you laid and understand that this is not a sure-fire technique, because “doing things” is not a guaranteed ticket to Sexville. It is, however, a necessary prerequisite.

        For younger folks (teenaged guys in particular), Dan Savage gave some advice that I think is pretty good. If you’re 13, don’t worry about getting laid at 14. You’re a moron and anyone you want to sleep with is a moron, too. This is because you’re 13 and so are they. Instead, “worry” about getting laid at 18. Or 20. Or whatever. Start developing things about yourself that will make you an attractive partner when you and your cohort (hopefully) grow out of your moron instar. Learn to talk intelligently about things you’re interested in. Learn to talk intelligently about things other people are interested in. Learn to do things, learn how to meet people when you do things, and learn how to make friends with people you meet. Don’t just sit on your ass in front of Domino’s pizza and hope that this “plan” is going to somehow magically land you a Victoria’s Secret model.

        • LeeEsq

          American society does make people with not so great success in the love or sex departments feel like losers though. At best people with extended lack of success in those departments get treated as the but of a gentle joke like the 40 Year Old Virgin. At worse your made to feel like a complete loser. Lots of Americans like status-based bullying and mentally beating somebody up for having a sucky love life is one of the most primary forms of bullying possible.

        • Barry Freed

          Learn to talk intelligently about things other people are interested in.

          This, and what you wrote above and below it, is in general great advice, not just for attracting romantic partners but for life in general. But it’s quite apparent that it would have been useless in his case because he was incapable of seeing women as people at all.

  • Lee Rudolph

    Maybe not all, but all I’ve seen, of the stories on this have the following last graf:

    Isla Vista, a small community next to UC Santa Barbara’s campus, is home to 23,000 people. The area has a reputation for excessive partying.

    What. The. Fuck. Yes, yes it does have “a reputation for excessive partying”. But including that in this story? Really??

    • Anna in PDX

      I had the same reaction. How in the hell is it relevant? It comes off as a semi excuse for his anger if you ask me. Especially it’s placement as the final sentence. I saw it on the Guardian.

      • Anna in PDX

        Goddamn iPad putting apostrophes where they don’t belong.

        • herr doktor bimler

          Those apostrophes would be happier sticking with others of their own kind.

          • DocAmazing

            Imagine our outrage at mispunctuation.

        • Dr. Acula

          Apostrophes Going Their Own Way?

          • herr doktor bimler

            I keep telling each left parenthesis that Yes, there is a right-parenthesis out there that’s right for them, it just may be at the far end of a very, very long sentence.

            • Dr. Acula

              You know, you’d think that, but all over the internet you see colons (and even semi-colons!) running off with all the right parentheses! It’s like there’s nothing that a nice, respectful left parenthesis can do.

              • Hogan

                :(

                • Dr. Acula

                  That’s right Hogan. If you can’t beat ’em, join ’em!

    • Owlbear1

      I read that to imply the killer was driving around the area because he knew he could find a party to shoot up.

    • Mo

      That was in the earliest reports, which didn’t have much to go on, so the type of area where the shooting took place was important. There had been a full fledged riot back in March which with tear gas, rubber bullets and 50 people hospitalized. When it turned out the shooting had no connection to the riots, that was removed, but the sentence about it being a party neighborhood remained. Wire reports on breaking news can get really odd before they get pulled and completely rewritten.

      • Anna in PDX

        Thanks for this explanation. It is true that wire reports sometimes look really weird and disjointed depending on when in the editing process you happen to read them, probably that’s all that was going on in this case. But it sure was a weird sentence on which to end the article.

        • Mo

          Actually, spoke too soon. Here is a good link as to why Isla Vista itself is important, from a local paper. Isla Vista Shooting: Echoes of David Attias
          Similarities Abound Between I.V.’s Madmen, But What Could Have Been Done?

          It turns out that a mentally ill freshman at UCSB killed four and wounded others in 2001, driving his car into a crowd, later claiming it was out of sexual frustration. The article goes on to talk about how Isla Vista is an densely populated unincorporated community, with neighboring jurisdictions specifically excluding the area to avoid the possibility of the students becoming a majority population. This leads to no real municipal governance with neither the USCB or the community college Roger attended having any control over the students who live there. In addition to the riot (where the police ran out of tear gas) there was at least one other major incident and two violent gang rapes. Tuition increases and budget cuts in the UC system, as well as the fact that Santa Barbara City College has a swelling enrollment, due to the fact that students can transfer to the UC system after two years. However, community colleges offer no housing support and little in the way of support services.

          Ross Macdonald fans – this is Lew Archer’s stomping ground. Sounds like the miserable children of wealthy Californians haven’t changed much.

    • Manju

      What. The. Fuck. Yes, yes it does have “a reputation for excessive partying”. But including that in this story? Really??

      Well, aren’t PUAs partiers?

      • cpinva

        “well, aren’t PUAs partiers?”

        apparently not, if it requires them to break away from the video game they’re playing.

    • BoredJD

      The headline in one of the NYC tabloids today was something akin to “Revenge of the Virgin.” Sickening.

  • KmCO

    I will not get off the boat, but I will leave with this fact: mass-murderers are almost always, always, ALWAYS men (and in our society, yes, usually white men) who are pathologically bitter that they don’t get what they believe is owed them. Psychologically healthy people usually outgrow this trait by about age 4 or 5. It is a testament to the fact that hegemonic misogyny and male privilege are too often lethal that we are seeing these mass murders.

  • LeeEsq

    The problem with sex or romantic love in general is that its really difficult thing to handle on a societal basis. We obviously don’t want to go back to the old days where sex was seen as dirty and a sin or something that should be non for procreation only within the confines of marriage. The problems with the old system are too numerous to list. There are issues with treating sex or romantic love as something to be universally celebrated though, mainly that not everybody gets to experience them universally. People with horrible sex and love lives generally see a celebration that they are left out on. People with bad sex or love lives are seen as deficient.I know this from personal experience. My love life is non-existent. That doesn’t give me any right to lash out my frustration on the world but I understand how emotionally crushing loneliness or even horniness can be. I’ve done the rants and venting online and off line. Been there, done that.

    This is one of the areas of life where there really are no good answers. I don’t think its possible to have a society that both celebrates romantic love and sex in most of its forms but at the same time isn’t alienating for people with bad love and sex lives. The idea that romantic love and sex are good things but not a right isn’t something that many people are emotionally mature enough to accept because of the sheer emotional toll that frustration can bring.

    • Nick

      I think that this is a brave post on a subject that is not easily acknowledged. Sexual and emotional happiness are not evenly distributed, and we are resistant to accepting how fundamental they can be to life. Some people, by birth or temperament, find them unattainable. I was almost 30 before I did; and it was much later that I found by accident a condition labelled ‘love shyness’ that described a good deal of how I had lived my early life, and which I escaped mostly via luck. I have no idea if it is a real thing or not. The Internet has huge powers of connecting people, and it can relieve the isolation of many people; but it also can connect isolated people in ways that are negative, and the MRAs and MGTOW are an obvious example of this.

      • ThrottleJockey

        I second the brave post.

      • I think there’s something of a tendency to assume that people who are lonely and unhappy about being lonely are fucking losers, or creeps, or whatever. I’ve absolutely seen it.

        The big difference, though, is that decent people don’t decide to blame them [bitches] for not hopping on their [dicks]. There are so many different factors to a successful love life that it’s really pointless to name one or another as the particular culprit when you aren’t successful.

        And the other big tell is the claim that women don’t have the same problem. It might be true that most women could have sex by going down to a local bar and fucking the last guy there, but let’s be honest: fucking random desperate people isn’t what most people want, male or female.

      • Anonymous

        I think that this is a brave post on a subject that is not easily acknowledged. Sexual and emotional happiness are not evenly distributed

        Tha’s Soooo..unfair.

        I vote for EQUALITY!

    • ThrottleJockey

      I think this is getting back to bspencer’s point about the masculinity complex. While ‘one is the loneliest number’ the masculinity complex makes this much more hard on men than it does on women. I have a number of female friends who’ve been celibate and romantically unattached for most of the last 15 years now. Its not uncommon for educated/successful black women of a certain age. And yet they seem to tackle it much easier than do men.

      • Julia Grey

        Living with a man, even one you love, can often be a pain in the ass.

        As I’ve grown older, I’ve become more accepting of the idea that it might be better for women to live apart from men and “visit” frequently instead of trying to occupy the same house.

        Of course, my husband is now retired and underfoot 24/7, so I have to concede that one’s recent experiences can have a great deal to do with shaping a person’s opinions on a variety of subjects….

        • LeeEsq

          The real estate market might make your idea slightly impractical at the very least.

        • bluefoot

          I know a few older couples that have done this – they live next door to each other in a pair of condos, or a house and one has a condo near the office where they stay part of the time, or have rearranged their house so that each has their own area, with the kitchen and dining room being shared. It’s worked out well or the most part, thought they do get a lot of flack from others.

          • NewishLawyer

            Andrew Sullivan had a thread about this during the week.

            The other place I saw it was the dreaded NYT Styles Section.

            • LeeEsq

              It used to be a thing for married couples who could afford to maintain separate bedrooms but that was probably more about socio-economic bragging rights than anything else.

              • ChrisTS

                Oh, I don’t think so, Lee. My grandparents went to separate bedrooms as soon as their parents (who lived with them) died. They had not had sex for decades, and both thought it would just be easier to not have to see each other ‘at night.’

          • guthrie

            Not dissimilar to the older more middle class British way of doing things in retirement – the husband has his golf/ badminton/ gardening/ running some club or society, the wife has gardening/ Rural/ running some club or society, and between all these they end up meeting up at breakfast and dinner and not much else.
            Oh, and sheds and garages, the ‘man cave’ is a popular meme here rooted in a fair bit of fact.

            Or the man just spends all day at the pub leaving the woman at home.

            • ChrisTS

              I like the idea of loosely male/female sides of the pub. Not that one cannot go over to the other side, but that one could ditch one’s spouse if one so desired.

              “I’ll be on the ladies’ side, Bob. See you in the morning.”

    • KmCO

      This. Thank you for saying this–it’s needed to be said for a long time now.

      • LeeEsq

        Oh good, I was afraid of getting a verbal smack down for this. Many people don’t like this observation because it puts wholes in their pet theories. I’ve gotten shit from MRA and the sex positive community for this.

  • Anna in PDX

    I just read the Manboobz post about the guy after reading all your comments. The Men’s Rights guys have blood on their hands. The fact he used their terminology and posted on the PUAHate forum make it so clear, no one outside of these sick groups would use the term “incel” … So upset and sad over such a senseless tragedy and how a disaffected and lonely person channeled his feelings into doing this.

    • delurking

      Yes.

  • JMP

    Of course, the Raw Story articleon this creep, and it’s probably just one of many, has attracted a bunch of MRA trolls, telling everyone “how dare you feminists claim that he was part the MRM!” and even trying to claim that pick up artists and the men’s rights movement have nothing whatsoever to do with each other.

  • somethingblue

    I find my dominant reaction to this is not anything to do with the ideology or the internet or the Asperger’s or the guns, but just that this kid was in a really deep, dark place that he didn’t know how to get out of. I don’t aim to excuse anything he did, but I wish him peace and I hope he finds his way back to the light.

  • Reality Check

    Get real this kid was slaughtering blondes and he was mixed race. This was a racially motivated crime. You ideological lunatics will completely ignore this reality.

    • I’m getting real…pancakes. Mmmmmm

    • Lee Rudolph

      Without purity of batter, mongrel pancakes will take over!!!

      • “I first became aware of pancakes during the physical act of love.”

        • Jhoosier

          Well thanks, now my fetish is ruined.

        • Malaclypse

          Rule 34 is harsh but fair.

        • LeeEsq

          Most of us become aware of pancakes at IHOP.

      • Massapequa Burning

        “They want to throw white batter and colored batter into a mixing bowl, out of which come a conglomerated, mulatto, mongrel class of pancake!”

    • calling all toasters

      Dear Deep Thinker,

      You’re in luck! I’ve found something Rodger himself wrote that shows how prejudiced he was against whites:

      Today I drove through the area near my college and saw some things that were extremely rage-inducing.
      I passed by this restaurant and I saw this black guy chilling with 4 hot white girls. He didn’t even look good.
      Then later on in the day I was shopping at Trader Joe’s and saw an Indian guy with 2 above average White Girls!!!
      What rage-inducing sights did you guys see today? Don’t you just hate seeing these things when you go out? It just makes you want to quit life.

      Oh, sorry, wrong quote… in that one he sounds just like you.

      • delurking

        Heh.

      • wjts

        Here’s another mango:

        My father drove up to Santa Barbara to meet me a few days later. The two of us went to have lunch at a restaurant in the Camino Real Marketplace, an area that I often frequented. When we sat down at a our table, I saw a young couple sitting a few tables down the row. The sight of them engraged me to no end, especially because it was a dark-skinned Mexican guy dating a hot blonde white girl. I regarded it as a great insult to my dignity. How could an inferior Mexican guy be able to date a white blonde girl, while I was still suffering as a lonely virgin?

    • Ronan

      Your argument is he was British ?

      • The British are objectively one of the mud races. Even Hitler knew it–

        wait, what?

        Well, Hitler was a dirty Jew anyway.

    • DocAmazing

      If Rodgers had a racial motivation, it wasn’t because of any mixed race on his part:

      Rodgers posted comments in January, beginning with “Saw a black guy sitting with 4 white girls,” causing him to admit his frustration over white women socializing with minority men:

      Today I drove through the area near my college and saw some things that were extremely rage-inducing.

      I passed by this restaurant and I saw this black guy chilling with 4 hot white girls. He didn’t even look good.

      Then later on in the day I was shopping at Trader Joe’s and saw an Indian guy with 2 above average White Girls!!!

      What rage-inducing sights did you guys see today? Don’t you just hate seeing these things when you go out? It just makes you want to quit life.

      • DocAmazing

        As usual, calling all toasters is on scene first.

        • calling all toasters

          We are legion.

          • Ahuitzotl

            oh so thats what happened to the lost legion? Hadrianus will be pleased

            • calling all toasters

              All your English muffin are belong to us.

      • Manju

        If Rodgers had a racial motivation, it wasn’t because of any mixed race on his part:

        Well, he says:

        My father is of British descent, and my mother is of Asian descent, so that makes me a Eurasian.

        http://elliotrodger.blogspot.com/2014/04/lonely-in-santa-barbara.html

        And he wrote this:

        Full Asian men are disgustingly ugly and white girls would never go for you. You’re just butthurt that you were born as an asian piece of shit, so you lash out by linking these fake pictures. You even admit that you wish you were half white. You’ll never be half-white and you’ll never fulfill your dream of marrying a white woman. I suggest you jump off a bridge.

        http://www.mediaite.com/online/ucsb-shooter-elliot-rodger-posted-racist-messages-on-puahate-website/

        I think I may need to reread Frantz Fanon.

    • Nick

      Why is it that the mulattoes, half-castes, and lascars always seem to go for the blondes? Weird Tales was right!

      • Manju

        did flotus go all mary j blige when i wasn’t looking or something?

    • Anonymous

      Get real this kid was slaughtering blondes and he was mixed race. This was a racially motivated crime.

      That is a given. He stated it in his manifesto.

      • ChrisTS

        Holy Shitbag. He wanted sex with them because he found them beautiful. That is not ‘racially motivated’ crime.

  • LeeEsq

    Nick, I agree with your overall post but most psychologists see love shyness as being bulk.

    • Nick

      I think you mean bunk — and I certainly don’t mean that I accept it as a condition, or something that should be diagnosed, but just that when I read a description of the term, it jibed with my own experience. It’s interesting when you find something very personal described, I imagine that the Internet has potentiated that for a very large number of people.

      • LeeEsq

        I do mean bunk. When I went to a psychologist, he certainly had very little respect for the love shy theory. From what I read online, his opinion seems to be the common one.

  • Reality Check

    I’ve looked into his family history.

    He’s the scion of a mix race marriage. He’s the scion of Magnum Photography founded by George Rodger. He’s a card carrying member of the liberal establishment. His grandfather’s most famous work was photographing the horror at Bergen Belsen. I find it very hard to to see him as anything but the product if liberal. Orthodoxy. He also hated “blonde sluts”.

    Wake the Fugging hell up. He was a sexual predator with are fetish for blondes.

    • NewishLawyer

      Well this was inevitable if tragic.

    • somethingblue

      Keep smiling through,
      Just like you always do,
      Till the blue skies drive the dark clouds, far away.

    • calling all toasters

      “We’re moving at a faster pace,
      look out, here comes the Master Race!”

    • He’s a card carrying member of the liberal establishment.

      Conservatives, when pressed, will admit that it’s possible that some mass killer some where, might be conservative. But they just haven’t so far managed to find one. Strange how that works, isn’t it?

      • Anonymous

        Is ti true or not?

        • I’m sure that, as always, conservatives will declare him a liberal and then examine the evidence. I mean, examine the evidence and then declare him a liberal. Well, one of the two.

    • wjts

      I’ve looked into his family history…. He’s the scion of a mix race marriage.

      Which is certainly compelling, but I’d be reluctant to make any definitive statement until the medical examiner releases Rodger’s phrenology report, humoural balance, and blood-phlogiston level.

      • When the black bile and the green bile get mixed, the liberals win.

    • calling all toasters

      OMG, Reality Racist is trying to make him into Obama:

      Mongrelized race, check.
      Liberal establishment, check.
      Grandfather saw the death camps, check.

      Sicker and sicker! Almost Limbaughesque!

    • Hogan

      He’s a card carrying member of the liberal establishment. His grandfather’s most famous work was photographing the horror at Bergen Belsen.

      Oh well, if your grandfather documented the horror at Bergen-Belsen, then you’re obviously a hardcore leftist.

      • At least it’s clear now that our troll is pro-Nazi. Not that there was ever any real question on the matter.

      • Google

        I am wondering what the Liberal Establishment membership cards look like, and how I get to carry one.

        • Steve LaBonne

          I have a UU chalice pin- does that count?

          • ChrisTS

            Steve:

            I’m sorry I missed this earlier; I have one, too. Sadly, the answer to your question is “No.”

            However, it is a conversation starter:

            “Uh, what is that?”
            “It’s a UUA chalice pin.”
            “A what?”
            “Chalice pin; it means …”
            “No. No. What’s OOh OOH AY?”

            • wjts

              Once upon a time in kindergarten, three children were discussing religion.

              Carrie said, “My family’s Baptist, so we worship Jesus who is our risen Lord and savior.”

              Irem said, “My family’s Muslim, so we worship Allah who created the world and everything in it.”

              Julie said, “My family’s Unitarian, so we worship a martini glass that’s on fire.”

    • witless chum

      If I put blueberries and banana in the same pancake, would that be a mixed race hot cake scion of the griddle establishment?

    • Mike G

      His grandfather actually filmed concentration camps? That makes him more Reaganesque than Ronald Reagan, who told the Prime Minister of Israel that he filmed the camps when in actuality he never left Hollywood during WW2. So maybe he was conservative. (/conservative”logic”)

    • Alex O’connor

      Can I be a scion. Being a scion of Irish immigrants who was conceived in Europe but born here. Who grew up with several Bergen Belsen , Auschwitz and Treblinka survivors in the neighborhood I grew up in and still live in Chicago. Or is that too gang-land for your idiotic chauvinism?

      • DocAmazing

        You don’t want to be a Scion. Be a Toyota or a Mazda.

  • Reality Check

    Didn’t they drag three men out of this apartment?

    This is going to take a nasty turn. The kid might well have abused these bodies.

    I stand by my opinion on him. He’s half Brit/half Malaysian with a Moroccan step mom. That’s not a conservative profile.

    This story has to be about a generalized misogyny or it is no use to your political agenda.

    This kid hated white girls.

    • calling all toasters

      Please tell us about the racial purity test for conservatism.

      • The prophet Nostradumbass

        I’m just surprised the word “mongrel” didn’t appear.

      • Lee Rudolph

        No, no, tell us about the abuse you might well expect the bodies to have suffered! Please, tell us all about it.

    • Gomer Pyle

      Why, yer just soo full of your self.

    • That’s not a conservative profile.

      Has anyone told Bobby Jindal and Nicky Haley?

      • Alex O’connor

        Father….They know not what they do.

      • RobNYNY1957

        John Yoo, Dinesh D’Souza, Ramesh Ponnuru, Michelle Rhee.

    • herr doktor bimler

      I stand by my opinion on him.
      Pseudonymous troll has placed his/her credibility on the line! That’s commitment!

      • There’s no credibility like hermaphrodite credibility.

    • Anonymous

      This kid hated white girls.

      Well, fuck, Erik the Red hates all white people..

      • Black Power! Black Power! Black Power!

      • Well, maybe therein lies the difference. He’s not a whiney, self-deluded, entitled gun nut and raging misogynist, just a smart-ass college professor, so no white people will be killed anytime soon. You just get hurt fee-fees, is all, and you ought to be used to that by now. Not a bad deal, dude, I’d stop your bellyaching.

    • LeeEsq

      So your admitting that conservatives are racists with a racial purity fetish by this post?

      • jim, some guy in iowa

        he’s certainly bragging that he is

    • He’s half Brit/half Malaysian with a Moroccan step mom. That’s not a conservative profile.

      Because he’s not white enough? Because his father is a miscegenator? Is that really the hill you’re pleased to die on?

    • Hogan

      A Brit married to an Asian? QED.

      John Derbyshire, pillar of the liberal establishment.

    • ChrisTS

      He hated women he found attractive for not finding him attractive. The women he found attractive – exclusively according to him – were blonde white girls.

  • Reality Check

    Calling all toasters,

    You got a link on that quote? You do realize the shooter was a Eurasian?

    • calling all toasters

      I do, but you have to promise not to steal his lines when you go out hunting all those mixed-race kids.

      • Here’s a link:

        https://twitter.com/RaniaKhalek/status/470373774928670720/photo/1

        Read the highlighted part. I’m not exactly sure why anyone would want to make this a racist thing (though the guy was pretty damn racist) when we’re full up on “gun nut” and “whiney entitled manboy who spews hate because female loins fail to quiver at his fedora collection and husky manliness”, plus a good dollop of “this is why we should find a guillotine and an old lady to knit menacingly”. But, fish got to swim, birds got to fly, this guy’s got to be a pill.

        • Manju

          I’m not exactly sure why anyone would want to make this a racist thing

          I don’t grok u. Your very source is talking about how (the killer’s) sexism is intertwined with racism.

          That’s her central point.

          • Talking about the troll above who’s trying to make it all about hatred of white women ’cause he’s an asshole. Obviously, racial hatred intersects with rampant misogyny and gun violence in this case, but it’s not the key component nor is it an example of how the mongrel races are trying to stamp out the pure white race, that old conservative boiler plate. I wasn’t exact.

            Also, I once got bitched out for using “grok” correctly despite not being a huge Heinlein fan (apart from a few books, I think he’s a sexist old bore) by a huge Heinlein fan. I mean, like a five-minute tired on the subject that just got worse when I started laughing. Ended that date right quick, but I didn’t go out and shoot anybody.

            • Manju

              Also, I once got bitched out for using “grok” correctly despite not being a huge Heinlein fan

              damn. I thought it originated with Mork & Mindy. I hate Science Fiction.

              I mean, like a five-minute tired on the subject that just got worse when I started laughing. Ended that date right quick, but I didn’t go out and shoot anybody.

              Soooo…you negged her and it didn’t work!?

            • Manju

              Talking about the troll above who’s trying to make it all about hatred of white women ’cause he’s an asshole. Obviously, racial hatred intersects with rampant misogyny and gun violence in this case, but it’s not the key component nor is it an example of how the mongrel races are trying to stamp out the pure white race,

              Ah…I wasn’t paying attention to the troll.
              But yeah…its actually paradoxically about white supremacism + sexism…paradoxically b/c the killer isn’t fully white and his victims are. Certainly more convoluted than your garden variety anti-black white-power racism, but thats what it appears to boil down to.

    • Google

      If only there were some service which indexed Internet webpages and allowed searches for any given string of words.

  • Reality Check

    http://ajwnews.com/archives/4305#comments

    Here’s the Dad doing a walkabout asking “what is god?”

    He’s a card carrying member of the left.

    No point denying it.

    • KmCO

      Hi, K.

      • jim, some guy in iowa

        way too to the point to be “k”

        • KmCO

          I dunno…the mangled grammar and failure to grasp the “reply” function scream K to me.

          • Philip

            They all become more and more similar as they get more vile, but I seem to remember Jenny using this nym in the past.

            • Walt

              Yeah, this is Jenny. K always sounds high as fuck.

    • DocAmazing

      Yes, the part of the left that enjoys BMWs and misogyny and complains about miscegenation.

      But Dad did something vaguely Jewish, so…leftist?

      • Well, you know, all gun nuts are avowed leftists. Mao, “change must come”, something about the barrel of a gun, that whole thing. Also, it’s a little known fact that, to pump themselves up for a night of picking up groovy foxes, PUA’s sing Joe Hill songs. No point in denying it, he’s right.

        • delurking

          “…don’t mourn, STOCKPILE!!”

      • Alex O’connor

        Ladies who are vaguely Jewish are hot. Oh not that is too, too vaguely Jewsih

      • Spokane Moderate

        Clearly, his rejection of all the left stands for marks him as a liberal.

    • wjts

      Equally damning evidence of Rodger’s status as a hard-core leftist is this picture of a trout.

      • LOOK AT THAT RED STRIPE ON THE TROUT! COMMUNISM!!!

        • wjts

          AND I THINK WE ALL KNOW WHAT KIND OF PEOPLE ARE ASSOCIATED WITH RED STRIPE!

          • delurking

            +1

          • The prophet Nostradumbass

            Hooray, Beer!

        • herr doktor bimler

          It is a Rainbow trout, Erik, so GAYAGENDA.

      • DocAmazing

        Well, rainbow trout, I mean, Jesus, a gay hippie fish…

      • Alex O’connor

        I had trout for breakfast; it was smoked trout with capers…I suppose that makes me a …..

    • Julia Grey

      Okay, let’s pretend he was a flaming leftist.

      He was also, ahem, OVER-EXERCISING his 2nd Amendment rights and complaining about UPPITY FEMALES, publicly advocating for policies that would roll back feminism and women’s rights. Oh, yeah, and then there’s that in-your-face racism thing. And maybe even a little homophobia?

      Wow. All things considered, I think we shoulda told him to turn in his Leftist Card.

      • Hey, good point. This guy is no longer a leftist, and we’ll use the same logic that makes MLK Jr. a staunch conservative.

        • KmCO

          Funny how that works. It’s almost like the right-wing Zhdanovites don’t truly believe that MLK Jr. was a conservative, nor that Rodger is a “leftist.”

    • Adam

      Why would it matter if he was conservative or liberal in his personal politics in the slightest bit?

      • witless chum

        Because, something? I’m not sure, either, given that no one was particularly saying he was a political conservative. I guess the weirder, more racist troll was just around.

      • KmCO

        Too many right-wingers and their cultural brethren such as MRAs truly cannot (or more accurately, will not) process the fact that their ideology leads too often to deadly results.

        • Adam

          I guess so? That’s just what has me completely confused. I’ve been reading this blog a long time and never felt the urge to comment until now, but this just bothered me so much I felt the need to say something for the first time.

          Let’s grant for the sake of argument that he’s a leftist. Card-carrying, screaming leftist. Goes to Occupy rallies and shops at Whole Foods and whatever other fantasies describe a True Leftist in the fevered mind of the troll.

          Who cares? I mean, what would that possibly matter? Do you feel better knowing that he’s not one of Your Guys? Does it somehow make what he did any more monstrous and horrible because he was one of the Others?

          The shooter was awful no matter what party he was affiliated with or whether he was red or blue or whatever. Is it really worth trying to score some kind of nebulous political point on the backs of six dead innocent people?

          • KmCO

            I would say that the killer’s politics *are* relevant because they stem at least partly from an entrenched misogyny that, in this case, turned deadly. Misogyny is certainly endemic to both sides of the political aisle (although it would be a straight-up lie to claim that the right side of the aisle is not considerably more misogynistic than the left side), but this young man took it to extreme levels. The enabling of attitudes like his in our society are what in part led to this massacre. That is a pan-poltiical issue, of course, but it is inaccurate to say that his politics* don’t count *at all.* All human actors in a society are influenced by politics; no one is truly a “lone nut” acting alone.

            *I have no idea if he considered himself a Republican or a Democrat. Based on his online presence, however, he certainly does not strike me as liberal in orientation.

            • ChrisTS

              His ‘politics’ were pro-fascist.

          • delurking

            I think Reality Deprived’s point is something something only Leftists are evil.

            It’s a main point being pushed by the few remaining people who self-identify as Conservative in America today — that they are the virtuous True Americans, and everyone is eeeevil.

            My kid came home from school telling me that one of her classmates told her that HER father said all Democrats were “dirty inside.”

            Charming.

          • djw

            Who cares? I mean, what would that possibly matter? Do you feel better knowing that he’s not one of Your Guys? Does it somehow make what he did any more monstrous and horrible because he was one of the Others?

            I think that for Reality Check, the only point of giving any thought to an incident like this is to score cheap political points. He’s projecting; assuming we surely must be trying to do the same, and attempting to compete with us on those grounds. For him, there would be no other, independent reason to care about something like this.

            People who see themselves as Democrats or liberals or left-of-center or whatever make up nearly half the country. You can’t count that high without ending up with some truly awful characters on your side. Well all understand that; because Reality Check is so driven by a friend/enemy, us/them view of politics he can’t wrap his mind around the notion that we already get it.

        • MH

          I suspect even more accurately they just feel uncomfortable when people outside their group recognize that feature of their ideology, and, even more importantly, don’t approve.

          They aren’t bothered by the violence – that’s the way important social norms are enforced and privileges are protected. They’re bothered by the fact that other people think poorly of it. What they’re saying isn’t ‘those actions aren’t related to our ideological views and it’s unfair to link us to them’, they’re saying ‘it’s unfair to disapprove of us.’

    • Ronan

      Stop being a fucking idiot and develop a sensible argument, please. People arent here to walk you through beginners logic, just develop a hypothesis, a couple of supporting statements and leave it out there. This is a blog comments thread not MENSA.You dont have to be awesome, but just mke a logical fucking point people can work with. Please

      • Anna in PDX

        Ronan I adore you.

        • Ronan

          Many thinks for the kind words Anna : )

    • Alex O’connor

      What card. Show me your papers

  • mike in dc

    Mixing sexual frustration, the desire to be loved, perceptions of rejection, nascent adolescent/young adult hormones, and mental health issues with an entitlement mentality and the misogynist worldview of incel/PUA/MRA is a pretty toxic mix. Throw guns in the mix…BOOM.

    • calling all toasters

      Oh,crap– Reality Check has guns?

      • delurking

        I really doubt that Reality Check has a driver’s license.

        I mean, unless his Mommy paid for it.

    • herr doktor bimler

      Throw guns in the mix…
      I am worried that two pages are stuck together in your recipe book.

  • Alex O’connor

    Undoubtedly, there is intersection between MRA and NRA. That is all.

  • Alex O’connor

    The NRA advocates terrorism at a rule and relies on its influence for its survival

    U.S. Code › Title 18 › Part I › Chapter 113B › § 2332a
    18 U.S. Code § 2332a – Use of weapons of mass destruction

    Current through Pub. L. 113-103. (See Public Laws for the current Congress.)
    US Code
    Notes
    Updates
    PREV | NEXT
    (a) Offense Against a National of the United States or Within the United States.— A person who, without lawful authority, uses, threatens, or attempts or conspires to use, a weapon of mass destruction—
    (1) against a national of the United States while such national is outside of the United States;
    (2) against any person or property within the United States, and
    (A) the mail or any facility of interstate or foreign commerce is used in furtherance of the offense;
    (B) such property is used in interstate or foreign commerce or in an activity that affects interstate or foreign commerce;
    (C) any perpetrator travels in or causes another to travel in interstate or foreign commerce in furtherance of the offense; or
    (D) the offense, or the results of the offense, affect interstate or foreign commerce, or, in the case of a threat, attempt, or conspiracy, would have affected interstate or foreign commerce;
    (3) against any property that is owned, leased or used by the United States or by any department or agency of the United States, whether the property is within or outside of the United States; or
    (4) against any property within the United States that is owned, leased, or used by a foreign government,
    shall be imprisoned for any term of years or for life, and if death results, shall be punished by death or imprisoned for any term of years or for life.
    (b) Offense by National of the United States Outside of the United States.— Any national of the United States who, without lawful authority, uses, or threatens, attempts, or conspires to use, a weapon of mass destruction outside of the United States shall be imprisoned for any term of years or for life, and if death results, shall be punished by death, or by imprisonment for any term of years or for life.
    (c) Definitions.— For purposes of this section—
    (1) the term “national of the United States” has the meaning given in section 101(a)(22) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1101 (a)(22));
    (2) the term “weapon of mass destruction” means—
    (A) any destructive device as defined in section 921 of this title;
    (B) any weapon that is designed or intended to cause death or serious bodily injury through the release, dissemination, or impact of toxic or poisonous chemicals, or their precursors;
    (C) any weapon involving a biological agent, toxin, or vector (as those terms are defined in section 178 of this title); or
    (D) any weapon that is designed to release radiation or radioactivity at a level dangerous to human life; and
    (3) the term “property” includes all real and personal property.

  • Alex O’connor

    Should have been published prior to earlier comment

    18 U.S. Code § 2331 – Definitions

    Current through Pub. L. 113-103. (See Public Laws for the current Congress.)
    US Code
    Notes
    Updates
    prev | NEXT
    As used in this chapter—
    (1) the term “international terrorism” means activities that—
    (A) involve violent acts or acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or of any State, or that would be a criminal violation if committed within the jurisdiction of the United States or of any State;
    (B) appear to be intended—
    (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population;
    (ii) to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or
    (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination, or kidnapping; and
    (C) occur primarily outside the territorial jurisdiction of the United States, or transcend national boundaries in terms of the means by which they are accomplished, the persons they appear intended to intimidate or coerce, or the locale in which their perpetrators operate or seek asylum;
    (2) the term “national of the United States” has the meaning given such term in section 101(a)(22) of the Immigration and Nationality Act;
    (3) the term “person” means any individual or entity capable of holding a legal or beneficial interest in property;
    (4) the term “act of war” means any act occurring in the course of—
    (A) declared war;
    (B) armed conflict, whether or not war has been declared, between two or more nations; or
    (C) armed conflict between military forces of any origin; and
    (5) the term “domestic terrorism” means activities that—
    (A) involve acts dangerous to human life that are a violation of the criminal laws of the United States or of any State;
    (B) appear to be intended—
    (i) to intimidate or coerce a civilian population;
    (ii) to influence the policy of a government by intimidation or coercion; or
    (iii) to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction, assassination, or kidnapping; and
    (C) occur primarily within the territorial jurisdiction of the United States.

  • Alex O’connor

    Lead, a component of bullets which do their only work via impacting bodies, and do their only “useful” work by impacting and then tearing through flesh and organs is a toxic chemical:

    http://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/40/372.65

  • Alex O’connor

    The NRA is a domestic terrorist organization. The NRA advocates terrorism. Supporters of the NRA support terrorism. Supporters of the NRA do not support a stable or free society; supporters of the NRA do not support the 2ns amendment which is dependent on a stable and free society.

  • wjts

    So I went foraging through his 140-page autobiography/manifesto (facing dangers untold and hardships unnumbered) for mangoes and now I can’t sleep. (The last thing I read that left me feeling so appalled and upset was The Turner Diaries.) The entire manifesto is awful, but for those who share my morbid curiosity but don’t feel like wading through the whole thing, here are some excerpts and commentary. The first thing that jumped out at me was how ludicrously entitled he was.

    When father’s week came, I felt frustrated because I didn’t have enough cool clothes there, and it took a while for me to get father to find the time to buy some for me. Mother always got me what I wanted, right when I wanted it. At mother’s house, all of my needs were met with excellent precision, whereas at father’s house, there would always be a time delay because father and [my stepmother] had less time for me, and paid less attention to me.

    I had heated conflicts with [my stepmother] during every week that I was at father’s house. All I wanted to do was play [World of Warcraft], and [she] strictly limited my playtime. Because my new room was just across from hers, she knew what i was doing at every single second. She was breathing down my neck the whole time. She kept making me do chores around the house. I despised doing work around the house, especially since we had a nanny who was supposed to do it. If I made a scene about doing the work, she took away my laptop for a day or two. This was the most horrible thing she could do to me, to take away my only source of joy left in the world. She sometimes did it even when father was at home, and father didn’t life a finger to stop her.

    During the trip, we visited the town of Arles where we stayed in the hotel that [his] family owns. [He] told me about all of the sexual experiences he had. I never knew he had such an active sex life. The more he talked to me about it, the more envious I became. I questioned to myself why he got to experience such an amazing life, while I had to suffer so much loneliness and humiliation. I was introduced to some of the girls he ahd sex with in the past, and they were all pretty. On top of that, his family was extremely wealthy and they owned a sprawling mansion in the countryside. Where’s the justice? I thought. Why couldn’t I have been born into that life? I envied [him] so much. His life must have been heaven on earth. Despite my envy of [him], I couldn’t hate him, at least at that time. He was the only popular young person who ever reached out to me. He invited me to visit his home, and he treated me like a friend. For that, I will always have a grudging respect for [him].

    It was at this time that I was just beginning to realize, with a lot of clarity, how truly unfair my life is. I compared myself to other teenagers and became very angry that they were able to experience all of the things I’ve desired, while I was left out of it. I never had the experience of going to a party with other teenagers, I never had my first kiss, I never held hands with a girl, I never lost my virginity. In the past, I felt so inferior and weak from all of the bullying that I just accepted my lonely life and dealt with it by playing WoW, but at this point I started to question why I was condemned to suffer such misery.

    My mother carried on pressuring me to get a job, and she would never leave me alone about it. She was a bit frustrated that I wasn’t getting one. The two of us had a lot of arguments, and living with m mother became an extreme hassle…. The problem was that most of the jobs that were available to me at the time were jobs I considered to be beneath me. My mother wanted me to get a simple retail job, and the thought of myself doing that was mortifying. It would be completely against my character. I am an intellectual who is destined for greatness. I would never perform a low-class service job.

    It turns out that he’s the sort of intellectual who can’t bear to take college classes that “pretty girls” have enrolled in them, though, so he’s constantly dropping classes after discovering that there’s a couple in the course with him or a “hot blonde” with a boyfriend.

    • wjts

      His views on women are, unsurprisingly, straight out of the MRA/PUA alphabet soup of misogyny:

      [My stepmother] returned from Morocco, and she was very angry with me due to the way I acted while I was there. She effectively kicked me out of father’s house, and because I was eighteen, she was allowed to. Father didn’t do anything to stop her, being the weak man that he is. This is how it has always been. Father has always given [my stepmother] free reign to impose her rules on the household…. Father kept saying that the house is her house as much as his, and that she has the right to kick me out. No! I am the eldest son! The house should be MY house before hers! This caused any respect I still had for my father to fade away completely. It was such a betrayal, to put his second wife before his eldest son. What kind of father would do that? The bitch must be really good to him in bed, I figured. What a weak man.

      The move to Santa Barbara is the endgame, the ultimate climax of everything. I saw it as a new chance that was given to me to finally have the things I want in life: love, sex, friends, fun, acceptance, a sense of belonging. But I could never forgive the world for denying me such things in the past. I was already turning twenty soon. I had already lost many years of my life. I deserve better than that. I am an intelligent gentleman, and deserve the love of girls more than the other obnoxious boys of my age, and yet they get girls and I don’t. That is a crime that can never be forgotten, nor can it be forgiven. I always wanted to exact my revenge on humanity for forcing me to live such a life, but I’ve also always had the hope that if I can do things in my life to make up for all my suffering, then that in itself would be a form of peaceful revenge.
      In truth, the move Santa Barbara was actually a chance that I was giving to the world, not the other way around! I was giving the world one last chance to give me the life that I know I’m entitled to, the life that other boys are able to live with ease. If I still have to suffer the same rejection and injustice even after I move to Santa Barbara, then that will be the last straw. I will have my vengeance.

      Females truly have something mentally wrong with them. Their minds are flawed, and at this point in my life I was beginning to see it. The more I explored my college town of Isla Vista, the more ridiculousness I witnessed. All of the hot, beautiful girls walked around with obnoxious, tough jock-type men who partied all the time and acted crazy. They should be going for intelligent gentlemen such as myself. Women are sexually attracted to the wrong type of man. This is a major flaw in the very foundation of humanity. It is completely and utterly wrong, in every sense of the word.

      I concluded that women are flawed. There is something metnally wrong with the way their brains are wired, as if they haven’t evolved from animal-like thinking. They are incapable of reason or thinking rationally. They are like animals, completely controlled by their primal, depraved emotions and impulses. That is why they are attracted to barbaric, wild, beast-like men. They are beasts themselves. Beasts should not be able to have any rights in a civilized society. If their wickedness is not contained, the whole of humanity will be held back from advancement to a more civilized state. Women should not have the right to choose who to mate with. That choice should be made for them by civilized men of intelligence.

      Misogyny kills, plain and simple.

      • Anonymous

        There is something metnally wrong with the way their brains are wired, as if they haven’t evolved from animal-like thinking. They are incapable of reason or thinking rationally.

        heh

        Every married heterosexual (normal) man knows this.

        • Malaclypse

          The failure mode of clever remains asshole. Or, in your case, pathetic and stupid.

          • wjts

            The failure mode of most things is JenBob.

        • If you’re “normal”, God help the human race.

        • You haven’t actually spent a whole lot of time around actual women, have you. You’re getting all your information about relationships from bad ’80s stand-up comics, aren’t you.

          • N__B

            And what’s up with airplane food, anyway?

            • Hogan

              I just flew in from the coast, and boy, are my arms tired.

          • Origami Isopod

            bad ’80s stand-up comics

            Unfortunately that crap goes much, much further back than the ’80s, and comics who were considered good (Henny Youngman) indulged in it plenty.

        • brad

          Every married divorced and embittered man knows this. FTFY, normal is inapplicable to you or your cohort, and to say this without any homophobia, too many of your ilk are closet cases for heterosexual to be an appropriate descriptor.

    • wjts

      His attacks yesterday didn’t come out of nowhere. Assuming these stories are true and not retrospective revenge fantasies, his murder spree was the culmination of a series of assaults:

      As I made my way back from school one day during the first week, I was stopped at a stoplight in Isla Vista when I saw two hot blonde girls waiting at the bus stop. I was dressed in one of my nice shirts, so I looked at them and smiled. They looked at me, but they didn’t even deign to smile back. They just looked away as if I was a fool. As I drove away I became very infuriated. It was such an insult. This was the way all girls treated me, and I was sick and tired of it. In a rage, I made a U-turn, pulled up to their bus stop and splashed my Starbucks latte all over them. I felt a spiteful satisfaction as I saw it stain their jeans…. They deserved the punishment I gave them. It was such a pity that my latte wasn’t hot enough to burn them. Those girls deserved to be dumped in boiling water for the crime of not giving me the attention and adoration I so rightfully deserve!

      On one of my very last days as a teenager, as I was sitting at my usual place at the food court outside Domino’s, I saw a sight that shattered my heart to pieces. A tall, blonde, jock-type guy walked into one of the restaurants, and at his side was one of the sexiest girls I had ever seen. She too was tall and blonde. They were both taller than me, and they kissed each other passionately. They made me feel so inferior and worthless and small. I glared at them with intense hatred as I sat by myself in my lonely misery. I could never have a girl like that. The sight was burned into my memory, and it caused a scar that will haunt me forever. When they walked away, I followed them in my car for a few minutes, and when they entered a less inhabited area I opened my window and splashed my iced tea all over them. It was all I could do at the time, but at least it was something. At least I made some effort to fight back against the injustice. I felt sick with hatred that night. The hatred boiled inside me with burning vitriol.

      On one of the days in July, when I was roaming around Girsh Park, a group of popular college kids arrived to play kickball in the fields. They all looked like typical fraternity jocks, tall and muscular. The kind of guys I’ve hated and envied all my life. With them came a flock of beautiful blonde girls, and they looked like they were having so much fun playing together. One of the girls did a handstand in the grass, and her sexy bare stomach showed as her shirt hung down. All of the girls were scantily clad. Rage boiled inside me as I watched those people who thought they were better than me enjoying their pleasurable little lives together. The rage was so intense that I couldn’t take it. I was insulted too much. I couldn’t leave them without getting some form of revenge, so I drove to the nearby K-mart, bought a super-soaker, filled it up with orange juice that I bought at the same store, and drove back to the park. They were still there, having the time of their lives, and I wanted to ruin it for them. I wanted to ruin their fun just like they ruined mine, as they would never accept me among them. I screamed at them with rage as I sprayed them with my super soaker. When the boys started to yell and chase after me, I quickly got into my car and drove away. I was giddy with ecstatic, hate-fueled excitement. I wished I could spray boiling oil at the foul beasts. They deserved to die horrible, painful deaths just for the crime of enjoying a better life than me.

      At a house party:

      I stood awkwardly in the front yard for a bit, realizing how pathetic I looked all by myself when everyone was partying around me. To calm down, I climbed up onto a wooden ledge that bordered the street and plunged down on one of the chairs there. Isla Vista was at its wildest state at that time, and I saw lots of guys walking around with hot blonde girls on their arm. It fueled me with rage, as it always had. I should be one of those guys, but no blonde girls gave me that chance. I looked down at all of them, and in my drunken carelessness, extended my arm out and pretended to shoot them all, laughing giddily as I did it. Eventually, some partiers climbed up onto the ledge. They were all obnoxious, rowdy boys whom I’ve always despised. A couple of pretty girls came up and talked to them, but not to me. They all started socializing right next to me, and none of the girls paid any attention to me. I rose from my chair and tried to act arrogant and cocky toward them, throwing insults at everyone. They only laughed at me and started insulting me back. That was the last straw, I had taken enough insults that night. A dark, hate-fueled rage overcame my entire being, and I tried to push as many of them as I could from the 10-foot ledge. My main target was the girls. I wanted to punish them for talking to the obnoxious boys instead of me. It was one of the most foolish and rash things I ever did, and I almost risked everything in doing it, but I was so drunk with rage that I didn’t care. I failed to push any of them from the ledge, and the boys started to push me, which resulted in me being the one to fall onto the street. When I landed, I felt a snap in my ankle, followed by a stinging pain. I slowly got up and found that I couldn’t even walk. I had to stumble, and stumble I did. I tried to get away from there as fast as I could.

      His murders were in keeping with a long-standing pattern of violent behavior towards women.

      • wjts

        And this one:

        Another incident happened on the following day, near the same location. I went to the Starbucks at the Camino Real Marketplace by myself, like I usually did every morning. I ordered up my coffee and sat down on one of their chairs to relax. A few moments later, when I looked up from my drink, I saw a young couple standing in line. The two of them were kissing passionately. The boy looked lke an obnoxious punk; he was tall and wore baggy pants. The girl was a pretty blonde! They looked like they were in the throes of passionate sexual attraction to each other, rubbing their bodies together and tongue kissing in front of everyone. I was absolutely livid with envious hatred. When they left the store I followed them to their car and splashed my coffee all over them. The boy yelled at me and I quickly ran away in fear. I was panicking as I got into my car and drove off, shaking with rage-fueled excitement. I drove all the way to the Vons at the Fairview Plaza and spent three hours in my car trying to contain my tumultuous emotions. I had never struck back at my enemies before, and I felt a small sense of spiteful gratification for doing so. I ahted them so much. Even though I splashed them with my coffee, he was still the winner. He was going home to have passionate heavenly sex with his beautiful girlfriend, and I was going home to my lonely room to sleep alone in my lonely bed. I had never felt so miserable and mistreated in my life. I cursed the world for condemning me to such suffering.
        I wanted to do horrible things to that couple. I wanted to inflict pain on all young couples. It was around this point in my life that I realized I was capable of doing such things. I would happily do such things. I was capable of killing them, and I wanted to. I wanted to kill them slowly, to strip the skins off their flesh. They deserve it. The males deserve it for taking the females away from me, and the females deserve it for choosing those males instead of me.

        • Barry Freed

          Wow. That’s frightening. Thanks for reading through that so I don’t have to. The white-hot raging misogyny combined with the overweening sense of entitlement, he must have given off a really frightening vibe.

          • Mo

            And that was in his apartment when the police went to check him out and gave him a clear bill of health.

            Every police unit with a SWAT team needs a mental health unit as well.

            • DocAmazing

              Absolutely true, but there’s much more surplus military hardware for the feds to give local cops than surplus behavioral health workers to assign to law enforcement. Priorities!

        • ChrisTS

          One of the things that surprised me about the police giving him a pass after his mother called them was that they knew about the incident at the party, which occurred earlier.

    • wjts

      I don’t have anything to say about this last quote:

      My first act of preparation was the purchase of my first handgun. I did this quickly and hastily, at a local gun shop called Goleta Gun and Supply. I had already done some research on handguns, and I decided to purchase the Glock 34 semiautomatic pistol, an efficient and highly accurate weapon. I signed all of the papers and was told that my pickup day was in mid-December. That fell in nicely, because that was when I was planning on staying in Santa Barbara till. After I picked up the handgun, I brought it back to my room and felt a new sense of power. I was now armed. Who’s the alpha male now, bitches? I thought to myself, regarding all of the girls who’ve looked down on me in the past.

      Actually, I guess I do. This is what happens when men are encouraged to think of women as things rather than people. This is the acme of anxious masculinity. This is what happens when misogynist fantasies escape their festering internet echo chambers. And this is what happens when anyone with a couple of hundred dollars can buy a murder machine over the counter.

      • Brad Nailer

        Okay, so a nice-looking white kid goes into his local Handgun Emporiumm and buys his Glock. Even if the did a background check–what was “pickup day in mid-December”?–what are they going to find? No criminal record, no negative psych eval; I may have those details wrong, but let’s figure I don’t. What’s to keep the store from selling? And this guy apparently had three guns when he was found. And a shitload of ammo.

        There are, I think, 300 million guns floating around Freedom’s Land, as Mr. Vidal called it. Short of removing them all from circulation and shutting down weapons production and importation, how do you keep a Glock out of the hands of a murdering fantasist whose killings up to now have only been in his mind and who the police apparently think is a nice person?

        • wjts

          By criminalizing the possession and distribution of firearms.

          • DocAmazing

            It’s a thought, but a) hasn’t worked with other forms of contraband, notably drugs, and b) hard to sell to the voting public. Even those who are not rifle-fondling NRAistas think that Uncle Ted’s duck-hunting gun shouldn’t be threatened.

            • wjts

              No, it’s not one of the more realistic ideas I’ve ever had. But I do support a national ban on all handguns and clip or magazine-fed rifles. And a pony.

        • ChrisTS

          If they had done a background check, they would have indeed found a history of psychological troubles. They would have found out he was a serial college failure.

          • DocAmazing

            I must have missed something. I thought he was a UC Santa Barbara student. They’re a pretty selective institution–you absolutely cannot fail your way into UCSB.

            • The prophet Nostradumbass

              Santa Barbara City College, actually, local community college.

              • ChrisTS

                Yes. And he had flopped out of at least two others.

    • MacK

      There are a lot of incidents that are very similar – his splashing those he perceives to have offended him with a beverage – often from his car. I suspect that these splashings never actually took place, or are elaborate fantasies based on an accidental spillage on some occasion that he escalated in his mind to a deliberate protest act. I’m not sure, but they seem to be a fantasy

      • wjts

        I honestly don’t know.

      • AGM

        The trying to push the girls off the wall thing seems to have been real. Gawker reported he had 3 previous encounters with the police. One where he tried to press charges against a group of men assaulted him, and the police didn’t take it any further when they decided that he started it.

        • MacK

          On the other hand these could be fantasy events that he could not in reality implement until he was able to buy a gun.

      • Linnaeus

        I was thinking the same thing. We don’t really know if these were real, but the way he describes these episodes strikes me as really formulaic, stilted, and overwrought. Which doesn’t diminish this guy’s narcissism and misogyny. But my first inclination is that these were fantasies that escalated to the point where he decided to carry them out.

        • ChrisTS

          The incident with the ledge was real.

      • BoredJD

        I thought the same thing, but they show him to be so pathetic and helpless that they can’t be fantasies, unless he is trying to convince himself how powerless he is. A fantasy would probably end up with him beating up all the mean people and getting the girl at the end of all it.

        • delurking

          Yeah, but what you’re missing here is, no matter what he’s saying, he doesn’t actually want to be with a woman.

          He wants to hurt women. That’s what his fantasies are all about.

    • BoredJD

      Rodgers reminds me so much of an old roommate it’s scary. Right down to buying flashy designer clothing and sports cars to try and impress college age women, blaming his sexual failures on a culture that promoted interracial relationships, and engaging in random stupidly violent behavior in order to show how tough he was. A lot of the words in the manifesto could have come straight out of his mouth and it would not have seemed out of character.

      Despite a social IQ in the single digits, he had a few friends, wasn’t a virgin, to build a relatively successful professional career, although it was very difficult for him to operate in the real world. I shudder to think about all the people who are slightly more debilitated and don’t even have that.

  • Anonymous

    This is the age of equality and entitlement.

    Young people are told not to go out and make their life happen. Instead, they’re told that if they don’t get the money they think they deserve, live in the neighborhood they want, go to the school they want, it’s because someone else is trying to hold them down.
    They’ve been told they’re special and deserving from a very young age with trophies just for showing up to a game.
    They’ve been taught that they are smart, even when they aren’t to protect their self-esteem.

    So, this is no surprise when some unhinged young person believes he’s entitled and deserving of sex and then blames others for coming up short. Sad, but anyone could see this coming.

    • Malaclypse

      They’ve been taught that they are smart, even when they aren’t to protect their self-esteem.

      Thank you for meeting my minimum RDA for irony so early in the day, you profoundly stupid little man.

      • Anonymous

        Sounds like you might have the same anger issues, yourself…

        • Malaclypse

          No, sweetie, I just like making fun of you. You make it so easy.

    • weirdnoise

      Yes, people have been sold on the need for more and better stuff, and told they deserve to have it in return for whatever meagre pittance they can earn. Capitalism is a bitch, isn’t it?

      • Anonymous

        Pittance?

        This guy lived in Hollywood, his father was an assistant movie director. He drove a Beemer, for God’s sake. What do you think his resources actually were…$10 hour?

        And, he’s not alone. Those who don’t go to Harvard feel slighted and those who don’t start out at six figures right out of school are seriously disappointed. Just ask Paul Campos.

        • Loud Liberal

          People is plural. He/she was referring to the culture of greed and entitlement promoted by the plutopublican party. Try to read more carefully. Further, you don’t have to be poor to be sold on it. You just have to have internalized fucked up shitpublican values.

          • Loud Liberal

            See e.g. Charles and David H. Koch.

    • Lord Jesus Perm

      Of course, no wingnut bullshit rant is complete without a “BUH GAWD! PARTICIPATION TROPHIES!” mention.

    • DocAmazing

      Instead, they’re told that if they don’t get the money they think they deserve, live in the neighborhood they want, go to the school they want, it’s because someone else is trying to hold them down.

      Yes, by giving their job/home/school admission to one of the Those People. “You needed that job…”

      Loss of privilege is rough, nicht wahr?

      • calling all toasters

        +1

    • Tyro

      they’re told that if they don’t get the money they think they deserve, live in the neighborhood they want, go to the school they want, it’s because someone else is trying to hold them down.

      I grew up hearing a bunch of middle aged upper middle class white people complain about this all the time. It’s nothing new.

    • Lee Rudolph

      This is the Age of Entitlement, Age of Entitlement, Entitlement!

  • Karen

    I read about this in the hospital where my 16 year old son is having surgery for appendicitis. I thought of the kids I know, my sons’ friends, and wondered if any of them have this kind of rage buried inside. It’s bad enough sitting in the ER knowing my son is sick from purely physical illness. My mind just stops there; it won’t let me picture anything else. My heart goes out to everyone injured by the poison that this boy drank.

    • Karen, my thoughts are with you. Please update us.

      • Karen

        Thanks! He’s in surgery now. We got it in the very early stages so the surgeon said it looked simple. Of course, minor surgery is what other people have; your own is never minor.

      • Karen

        The surgeon just told us everything went well. Thanks for the good thoughts!

        • Malaclypse

          Yay!

        • N__B

          I sincerely hope your son will be going home with an appendix in a jar. Think of all the dates he’ll get!

          • Karen

            LOL!

          • Barry Freed

            Think of all the dates he’ll get!

            Medjool, deglet noor, halawi, barhi…

            Don’t put them in the same jar as the appendix though. That’s gross.

        • Barry Freed

          Good news!

        • Great to read this afternoon. :)

          • Karen

            We get to go home as soon as they bring us the papers. (That might happen before the onset of the next Ice Age, but I’m not sure.)

        • ThrottleJockey

          Glad everything worked out well, Karen. All the best.

      • Karen

        Thank you all so much for the good thoughts. You have no idea how much it helped!

        • I had to take a sister-in-law to the local hospital for an emergency appendectomy a few years ago, it is definitely not a fun trip, no matter who you’re taking.

          Hope your son heals well and recovers quickly.

    • Anonymous

      My heart goes out to everyone injured by the poison that this boy drank.

      Agreed

    • BoredJD

      I’ve known too many young men like this.

      • BoredJD

        And I don’t mean to freak you out, I was just observing that this is not a problem that can be blamed on bad parenting, or mental illness, or Grand Theft Auto. It runs much deeper.

  • Malaclypse

    Holy fuck.

    What happened is punishment for evil and violence of feminists and liberals. Any of you supporting atrocities like women’s suffrage, immodest clothing, child support/alimony, no ban on adultery, ban on prostitution and a lack of female premarital chastity, all the things that drove this young man to be unable to find a girlfriend, are disgusting , horrible people and you created a culture where this is possible. Renounce these horrors now. It is a decent thing to do. It will make you healthy and sane again. It will make the world healthy and sane again.

    • Hogan

      If I start to get out of the boar, someone shoot me.

      • Hogan

        Or the boat, even.

      • Malaclypse

        It got far worse from there.

        • DocAmazing

          I snuck over and peeked. That’s some high-octane wimmin-hatin’ there. Didn’t look at the comments section; learned my lesson after seeing the “racial realists” over at The Nation yesterday.

    • Anonymous

      Funny how he hates liberals yet thinks exactly like a liberal, or Leftist, blaming all his problems in life on some class that’s oppressing him rather than getting his shit together and building his OWN life as an independent, self-sufficient individual.

      You’re not getting laid because of women, moron, you’re getting laid because rather than pull yourself up by your bootstraps and improve your lot you’d rather whine about how unfair women are on the internet. The world owes you nothing, and that includes sex.

      • Anonymous

        *not getting laid

      • Tyro

        That’s interesting because conservatives universally blame black people and liberals for the fact that they are only in the top 5%-10% of income rather than the .1%-1%.

        Next I have got ever single suburban cubicle drone complaining that the wealthy city where I live– which generates the tax revenue for the rest of the state– is to blame for sucking down their meager tax dollars which barely pay for their own expensive suburban and rural lives.

      • Hello. Is this post directed at my article/blog?

      • “I am not getting laid” because of “people” who use such phrases at all and think incel is just about sex. Just “people” are the most successful in terms of reproduction because what is valued in a modern society are immorality and stupidity. This occurred after women got suffrage.

    • Ronan

      Wow. It certainly has been eye opening following links to MRA type sites the past day. I had no idea how vile and deranged these people actually are.

    • I do like how he calls other people modern monsters. I mean, this guy:

      All of this becomes even more obvious when you look at how I was treated. I am 3 years older than Elliot and was also a virgin at his age, yet I didn’t do what he did.

      So far, ok. Didn’t kill people…a win!

      But I had to things necessary for my survival

      I’m hoping things like eating, drinking, sleeping…

      – I had post a picture of an unstable woman who offered and retracted her offers of sex out of sheer sadism. I had to try to blackmail a slut who humiliated me on our date and slept with 50 men at the age 18.

      Oh no, John Ringo! Whoops, wrong guy.

      You blew it. These things weren’t necessary for your survival. These things were done because you are an awful person.

      • Bijan, you do understanding that you’re only proving me right?

        It’s entirely expected for incel men to snap and kill people. Incel is a living death, a denial of some of the most basic needs like romantic love and sex.

        As for what I did, let’s sum up your post. Sadistic sluts doing horrible things – good. A guy trying to at least get something out of them, while being fully aware that they can’t ever have a relationship with anybody nor would they want to (they’re that vapid) – bad.

        Yes, I needed to do that to survive. To alleviate my pain even a bit. I am not your goddamn robot and a worker bee who will shut the fuck up and act like I’m an eunuch.

        I’d do much, much more to get a relationship or sex, like lying about my achievements, blackmailing women, hell, even trying with underage girls if I get the chance.

        I have no choice.

        I must do what I must do to get at least something.

        You just confirm that liberals are hate machines who only have empathy for those their dogmas tell them deserve it. Men were never a group that belonged among these. Never at all.

    • Manny Kant

      Jesus Christ. Whatever you do, do not get out of the boat.

      • wjts

        Those mangoes are indeed pretty fucking disgusting.

  • Anonymous

    “MRAs” are, at the end of the day, just the mirror image of feminists, parroting much of the same, whiny Marxist claptrap about how a certain group of people is to blame for their lack of success in life (for the old school Marxist it was the bourgeoisie, for feminists “patriarchy”, for MRAs “hypergamy”).

    Feminism created MRA, and they both have a Marxist world-view at their heart, whether they know it or not.

    Marxism kills.

    • jim, some guy in iowa

      yeah, riiiight. people have been blaming other people for their own shortcomings since way before Marx came along

    • The prophet Nostradumbass

      LMFAO! That’s some serious weapons-grade stupidity right there.

  • Anonymous

    Leftists have created a culture of dependency wherein young people think they’re entitled to housing, entitled to food, entitled to a job, to a car, to everything under the sun, and if they aren’t getting it its someone else’s fault (“the one percent”, or what have you). So is it any surprise that young men now think they’re entitled to pussy as well? Its all the same ball of wax. Leftism created this problem.

    • Tyro

      You’re saying that people aren’t entitled to food and housing? Unless you’re going to give them a free plot of land to grow their own food and build their own shelter on, then, yeah, I am kind of thinking that they shouldn’t be homeless and starving for the mere crime of existence.

      In any case, his is a dilemma faced by most upper middle class white people: they thought their mere existence entitled them to all sorts of wealth and accolades, so they got resentful when they got a lot of it but other people got some as well, which they perceived as coming at their expense.

    • MAJeff

      derp on, cracker, derp on.

  • ChrisTS

    I don’t know if anyone is still around – which might be a good thing as I reveal my fascination with things awful.

    I spent a lot of time looking at Rodger’s various YouTube videos. As soon as I go to the first not-the-final one, I thought “I know this kid!” He had exactly the same mannerisms as a student I had in the fall. Strange pursing of lips, sideways glances meant to be – what? humorous? Odd speech rhythms. Arrogance. The whole nine yards.

    My student was not, as far as I know, a misogynist, but he was insanely full of himself and constantly demanded special privileges and accommodations. He was diagnosed as AS and came from a very well-off, very indulgent family.

    It creeped me out.

    • There’s better horror, there’s better porn, there’s hitting yourself in the head with a hammer. There are enough real assholes, like the one in your class, without searching them out on the net.

      I say this as a friend: rent the collected works of Keanu Reeves, but don’t keep researching this guy.

      • wjts

        There’s better horror…

        So I just finished Laird Barron’s The Croning, which I will recommend to any other horror aficionados as much better but considerably less horrifying than recent news reports.

        • HCE

          I’ll make a note for later, but right now let’s all have a drink, put on some good music, and let this shit go for the moment.

          Tears are round, the sea is deep,
          Roll them overboard, and sleep.

          • Hogan

            That were I. Here comes everybody.

          • wjts

            OK. Here’s the best song in the whole wide world.

            PS. Hogan, I think you’ve said you’re a fan of Caitlin R. Kiernan. If so, I’ll redouble my recommendation of Laird Barron as one of the best current crop of Lovecraftian writers.

            • Hogan

              I am, and thanks. I’ve just loaded The Imago Sequence to my Kindle.

          • ChrisTS

            You are absolutely right. And, yet, this particular horror strikes at mu heart.

      • ChrisTS

        I know, Hon. And, yet, I have this compulsion to understand, which leads to a compulsion to investigate.

      • ChrisTS

        Also: :-)

  • The prophet Nostradumbass

    This picture, of the father of one of the people murdered by this Rodger guy, breaks my heart every time I see it.

  • Mr Misogyny

    I kinda feel for that kid. In part.

    To be honest, I retain -even at 46- some serious resentment for the womenfolk. To be clear, my feelings can’t defined as hatred; more like a combination of mistrust and fear. My inability to navigate thru the complexities of 1970s or 80s dating arenas left me…somewhat confused. And complicated. Which is not to say that I didn’t date or lock lips with a few hot babes in the meantime.

    Bear with me: I haven’t thought any of this thru as I write

    My mother, after divorcing my father (among other reasons, because he was fucking his grad students) went thru a series of lovers, the last of which she wound up marrying. Her choice of guy sexually abused my sister (then a teenager)).

    My sister married my best friend from high school. So, that too. Also.

    First girl I slept with (did she fuck me or did I fuck her?) wasn’t my first romance, but WTF did I know about that shit?

    I’ve had nightmares about raping former girlfriends, and by “nightmares” I mean they were deeply unpleasant dreams that haunt me today.

    And then a few months ago some 18 yr fuckwit wannabe porn star said this

    “How does it make you feel personally to, like, watch degrading sex or see women being degraded and treated like s—t or just objectified?” a male interviewer asks Weeks.

    “Hot as hell,” Weeks replied.

    • Walt

      I would say that the key thing is to remember is that “women” is a big diverse group, made up of all kinds of people — crazy people, Sunday school teachers, brain surgeons, weekend cosplayers, crazy Sunday school teachers. They’re not all the same. If you were wronged by specific women, then you were wrong by them. You weren’t wronged by Women, as a group.

      Does an 18-year porn actress strike you as a plausible representative of the average American woman? Why?

    • Ronan

      You werent wronged by women *fullstop*. Reading your short bio the people in your life who wronged you(or your family) were men. Your father, your mothers boyfriends..
      Why does it matter that your sister married your best friend?

      I could understand better if your mother and sister resented men, but where’s the justification for your resentment of women?

  • Disgusted At White Privilege

    I agree with my fellow progressives above. How dare this guy slaughter innocent women with violence for no reason besides white privilege and expecting women to fall all over him!

    What if instead of waiting on psychos like this inspired by men’s rights hate sights, we put a stop to it abdad of time? Now some may say this is a bit reactionary, but I prefer to think of it as pro-active – just like the day Obama got Osama. Since there is established precedent for Obama executing American terrorist citizens via drone, why not just take suspected people like this and solve the problem ahead of time? He sure dealt with certain future terrorist and 16 year old US citizen, making sure that guy never harmed America.

    Why not create some sort of list with the NSA’s help? All of this stuff was out there on youtube anead of time, including his plan of attack! i agree about banning hate sites like the PUA sites, but they will still find ways to communicate. And for those worried this will be like Bush or something he would do, I completely trust Obama and how he has used his power – it is completely different and in line with respecting our civil liberties, unlike what bush did.

    • Walt

      Is this supposed to fool anyone? ‘Cause it’s not going to.

  • Disgusted At White Privilege

    What are you talking about? In my experience, progressives aren’t easily fooled at all, especially on issues related to Obama.

    Do you support my suggestion to have Obama stop these types of things ahead of time, or do you want to be at the mercy of nutjobs and the NRA? It is not as we don’t have the technology in the governement to actually stop this stuff. Or are you just trying to troll me bc you are Obama hating Republican?

    • Walt

      You need to replace the part of your central processing unit that simulates human speech patterns. It’s giving you away.

      • N__B

        That is un-fort-un-ate, Mis-ter And-er-son.

      • jim, some guy in iowa

        there at least was some humor involved when he represented Nigerian royalty-in-exile that just needed a helping hand and a routing number to recover their lost riches

  • Pingback: Feeling for the Kid - Lawyers, Guns & Money : Lawyers, Guns & Money()

It is main inner container footer text