There’s really nothing quite so wonderful as living in a community that’s become a regional hot spot for pertussis because hundreds and hundreds of assholes refuse to immunize their children. We’ve had 80 reported cases since July. Fantastic.
Juneau has endured similar fake controversies in recent years, and as expected, the objections to sound public health measures aren’t even remotely grounded in fact; the particular arguments against the pertussis vaccine have little to do with the typically bogus anxieties about thimerosol and autism, but instead focus on a pile of anecdotes from the 1970s and 1980s, when the “whole cell” pertussis vaccine was alleged to be responsible for seizures and brain damage. Despite the lack of empirical evidence supporting a link between the DTP vaccination and adverse, and despite the fact that newer “acellular” vaccines (DTaP) have replaced DTP (and have, in any case, proven equally safe and effective as the previous generation of drugs), anti-vaccination zealots continue to argue that pertussis vaccinations are unnecessary and pose dangers to children that physicians and pharmaceutical companies don’t want parents to know about for some reason. I’d post a list of conditions that these people believe are routinely caused by pertussis vaccines, but it would be easier just to type the word “everything” and run the risk of just slightly overstating the matter. (Believe it or not, there are people out there who actually believe “Shaken Baby Syndrome” is sometimes caused by vaccines.)
Barbara Loe Fisher, of the mis-named National Vaccine Information Center, is probably the most well-known American proponent of all this silliness. She’s got a blog these days, wherein she documents the vast conspiracy, warning about the grave threat to personal liberty that public health represents, and occasionally giving props along the way to investigative wizards like those at Pat Robertson’s CBN, who I suppose can be counted on to raise the oldest anti-vaccination arguments of all (e.g., God hates it).
Until recently, I’d have argued that the rhetoric of the anti-vaccination movement resembles that of the climate change deniers or those who sow doubt about the veracity of the moon landing. But the more I read about these folks, the more their work reminds me of some of the fraudulent arguments raised by anti-choicers who insist that abortions pose unique physical and psychological perils to women. Obviously the policy landscape is different, but the style of the argument — e.g., the reliance on personal anecdote, the disregard for data that hasn’t been contorted painfully, the demonization of medical practitioners, the insistence that all of this is being done to protect innocent life — seems oddly familiar.
…Jeebus, these folks even have an online memorial to the “victims of immunization”… The mind, to coin a phrase, boggles.
What Alterman said. The attempts to gin up pseudo-scandals involving Obama and SOHNEHO were bad enough, but attempts to tie Obama to the Blagojevich scandal seem to consist of guilt-by-association without even the association, unless “living in the same city” counts. And to this we can add the spectacle of pundits using arguments that could come straight from Obama birth certificate troofers — sure, there’s no evidence whatsoever of any wrongdoing, but somehow Obama is just never answering the right question in the right way.
It’s going to be a long 4 years for media watchers, and the even more frightening thing is that had Clinton won the media almost certainly would have been even worse.
…And in related news, the wanker of the week is certainly Ed Rendell.
Zimbabwe, it is fair to say, is a nation poorly served by its government:
The cholera outbreak in Zimbabwe which has left hundreds dead was caused by the UK, an ally of Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe has said. Information Minister Sikhanyiso Ndlovu described the outbreak as a “genocidal onslaught on the people of Zimbabwe by the British”.
On Thursday, Mr Mugabe said the spread of cholera had been halted. But aid workers warned that the situation was worsening and the outbreak could last for months.
In his comments to media in Harare, Mr Ndlovu likened the appearance of cholera in Zimbabwe to a “serious biological chemical weapon” used by the British. The Zimbabwean minister for information blames Britain for the cholera outbreak
He described it as “a calculated, racist, terrorist attack on Zimbabwe”.
Mr Mugabe has already accused Western powers of plotting to use cholera as an excuse to invade and overthrow him.
My heart cries out:
It is impossible to quantify how many affluent parents have trimmed allowances in recent months — or how many of their offspring, in turn, have sought either formal employment or odd jobs. But interviews with dozens of teenagers, parents, educators and employers suggest that many youngsters from well-to-do families seem to have found a new work ethic as the economic crisis that has pummeled their family stock portfolios and jeopardized their parents’ jobs has also led to less spending money for Saturday night movies or binges at Abercrombie & Fitch.
And this may be one of the least shattering insights ever provided to the readers of the New York Times:
“Research shows that the bigger allowance you get from mom and dad,” explained Andrew M. Sum, director of Northeastern’s center, “the less likely you are to work.”
Indeed; I’d like to see the hard data backing that up.
There are a bunch of ways to analyze this. One is to compare the most similar players to Sabathia at the same age. The most similar is Dave McNally, who at the same point in his career had 70 wins left in his arm. So that would be about $2.4 million per win. But that’s actually one of the most optimistic comparisons for Sabathia’s hypothetical future. The most similar pitcher to Sabathia overall, without regard to age, is Freddy Garcia. The first eight years of Garcia’s career look uncannily like the first eight years of Sabathia’s. Garcia has won two games in the last two years and it’s unclear whether his career will continue. So that would be $85 million per win.
Another very similar pitcher is John Tudor: he had 22 wins left when he had thrown a similar number of innings. So that’s $8 million per win. Then there’s Alex Fernandez: he had 11 wins left in his arm. The list goes on: Denny McClain, Teddy Higuera, Jack McDowell . . . it’s a pretty grim set of stat lines for sinking $170 million into one player (the one really similar pitcher who would have been “worth” this kind of contract in current dollars is/was Greg Maddux).
Sabathia’s future is also clouded by the closely related “pitching 1000 MLB innings before you’re 25 rule” (the rule is that this is generally a very negative indicator for what a pitcher will end up doing once he starts approaching 30).
But hey it’s only money . . .
Perhaps Scott will have something to say about this deal from the other side. I’ve got some mixed feelings about it, but I think it’s a small net positive for my Mariners. First and foremost, I’m just thrilled that the our new GM actually understands the team he’s running. Gutierrez is, by all accounts, a pretty spectactular defensive outfielder with a pretty questionable bat, which makes for a so-so player. But Zduriencik is aware that he’s got overpriced mediocre pitch to contact flyballers in the rotation that he probably can’t unload. The read coup here would be if the ridiculously good defensive outfield allowed Silva or Washburn to luck into a good ERA and he manages to unload them to someone in a pitching panic. But a high-end CF with little offense is of unusual value to this team. Heilman and Green seem like a pretty even swap of slightly better than average replaceable bullpen arms, with Vargas being a notch below but useable. Endy Chavez? We could have used him the last few years when the team needed a defensive 4th OF. This year he seems largely unnecessary.
Trading Putz is a great idea, and I’m now optimistic enough about our new GM to think he probably won’t foolishly return Morrow to the bullpen because we “need” a “closer”. Use the Beane model, create closers and trade ‘em. Watching him on the mound last year, my hunch is that he’s lost something beyond being hampered by a temporary injury. I’m skeptical 2007 is ever coming back.
What makes my feelings a bit mixed is Valbuena. I admit to a bit of irrationality here, but I just don’t like Lopez at 2B going forward. He’s got talent, but he seems unusually susceptible to lengthy funks at the plate and in the field. Betencourt’s defensive collapse is a bigger problem, but if we remain stuck with him 2B defense is even more important. I’d allowed myself to become optimistic about Valbuena and I’m sad to see him go. Hopefully we get more out of this deal then the last time we sent a talented infield prospect to Cleveland.
The Mariners also get three more minor leaguers, at least one of whom (Carp) is an OK prospect. If they get anything from the minor leaguers, or Gutierrez hits like 2007, it’s a pretty good trade for the M’s. But even if they don’t it’s not a disaster.
From the Mets angle, after the K-Rod signing, it’s hard to see precisely what the Mets are up to. A lot of work and money seems to be going into modest Bullpen improvements, but for a high price and with a potential loss of depth, as they loose Vargas, Smith (to Cleveland) and Heilman and get back only Putz and Green. They didn’t give up that much, but it’s still hard to see the point. Looks pretty good from Cleveland’s end, but I’m high on Valbuena.
I had only been to MSG once before, so it was very nice last weekend to see the Flames
somehow eke out a victory despite barely leaving their own zone in the second period thoroughly dominate the hopelessly overmatched Rangers. After such an abect humilation you go to the box and you feel shame. I think Berube forgetting his jersey was entirely responsible for the outcome, although it must be conceded that he was vastly superior in the post-game ad hoc darts contest.
On the other hand, I was disappointed to see that Canada’s bad Iggy, a charter Wanker Caucus member, has effectively handed the Liberal leadership. I’m not looking forward to this, and this doesn’t really seem like a good strategic move, but who knows, maybe he’s learned something. I guess this is low-risk-low-reward for the Liberals; Ignatieff seems more likely to stop a Conservative majority than Rae, but also seems less likely to stop Liberal bleeding to the NDP and Greens. Which I guess could be a decent outcome.
The War on (Some Classes of People Who Use Some) Drugs continues its roaring success:
Killings linked to Mexico’s drug war have more than doubled this year compared with 2007 and are likely to grow even further before they begin to fall, Attorney General Eduardo Medina-Mora said Monday.
The prosecutor tied the sharp increase in deaths to a battle for control among cartels and a power vacuum created by a series of high-profile arrests and seizures.
The number of gangland killings reached 5,376 from the beginning of the year until Dec. 2, a 117 percent increase over the 2,477 killings in the same period in 2007, Mr. Medina-Mora said in a luncheon meeting with foreign correspondents.
The bulk of the killings have occurred in the border states of Chihuahua and Baja California, where traffickers have sought to wipe out rivals on the streets of Juárez and Tijuana, and in Sinaloa, where one of the country’s most powerful cartels has its base.
“These criminal organizations don’t have limits,” said Mr. Medina-Mora, who previously served as Mexico’s public safety director and spy chief. “They certainly have an enormous power of intimidation.”
Mission accomplished! In fairness, it must be said that this violence is trivial compared to the turf wars between Busch and Coors…
Leaving aside his wanktastic politics, one thing that was never clear to me was exactly what credentials Bob Kerrey had to run a university. I know fundraising is very important to a modern university president, but…
More at the COHE.
The Most Inane Punditry of 2008.
I’m glad to say I’d never even heard of some of these items. For example:
“Well, here’s the other thing that we saw on the tape, Chris, is that, when Obama went in, he was offered coffee, and he said, ‘I’ll have orange juice.’ ” Matthews replied, “No,” to which Shuster responded: “He did.” Shuster continued: “And it’s just one of those sort of weird things. You know, when the owner of the diner says, ‘Here, have some coffee,’ you say, ‘Yes, thank you,’ and, ‘Oh, can I also please have some orange juice, in addition to this?’ You don’t just say, ‘No, I’ll take orange juice,’ and then turn away and start shaking hands.”
Duly noted! You know, without wealthy television pundits to instruct us, we’d probably spend most of our time slitting each others’ throats over the finer breaches of Regular Guy Etiquette.