Most of the rest of the top 10 make sense -- it it figures to be razor-thin -- but I'm pretty sure that I wouldn't have gotten the current NL leader win shares with 50 guesses. And I don't think careful analysis would leave him...
sabermetric wankery
Yglesias proclaims all-time HR leader Barry Bonds "the greatest offensive player in the history of baseball." I don't actually think that this is true. Ruth and Williams, as you can.