The Awful Keeps Coming

It’s not just disaster relief — the House Republican leadership continues to find a variety of appalling-in-themselves excuses to refuse to renew the Violence Against Women Act:

But House Republicans insisted the bill is too supportive of immigrants, the LGBT community, and Native Americans — and they’d rather let the law expire than approve a slightly expanded proposal. Vice President Biden, who helped write the original law, tried to persuade House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) to keep the law alive, but the efforts didn’t go anywhere.

And so, for the first time since 1994, the Violence Against Women Act is no more.

In a bad commerce clause/14th Amendment holding, a bare majority of Supreme Court conservatives struck down one provision of the VAWA; the Court’s allies in Congress appear poised to finish the job.

90 comments on this post.
  1. charles pierce:

    Because, what the hell, the gender gap wasn’t big enough.

  2. JMP:

    But but Fox News told me teh War on Womens was just a Democrat Party myth@!

  3. Pestilence:

    I’m just waiting for the Compulsory Violence Against Women Act, it seems the logical extension of this.

  4. RepubAnon:

    So the Republican Party supports violence against women, and opposes helping the victims of Hurricane Sandy – and laud themselves as being “moral”.

  5. STH:

    I saw a reference the other day to a pre-election poll that found that 82% of the people polled thought Obama “cares about people like me.” 18% thought that of Romney.

    So when is that “new Republican party” that appeals to a broader demographic supposed to start? ‘Cause it sure doesn’t look like they’ve learned a damn thing from that election.

  6. STH:

    Makes sense to me. They’re always yammering about “freedom,” but it just seems to mean “freedom for everybody to be just like me.”

  7. rm:

    They promise to Repeal and Replace ™ with the Legitimate Violence Against Women Act. The House version will be the Violence Against White Women Act.

  8. hurt:

    but amazingly they still win married women and
    actually did 2 points better with women overall in 2012 even after a war on women and the legitimate rape crazies

  9. MAJeff:

    The GOP’s anthem: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ic7KH1PpbMY

  10. Leeds man:

    They are more protective towards guns than women. I am shocked.

  11. Chris Walsh:

    I don’t think this post is supportive of the whole truth. There has to be something substantial within it unsupportive of helping the country in it’s current stricken state. For example, the department of human services has just purchased a substantial amount of hollow point ammunition. Why? In case of a civil war with the legislative gun ban directly against our constitution and freedom. The names of things often become a disguise for something completely different than they were intended for. There is more money earned by women than men in this country now, violence against women is not at all tolerated, and for the first time ever in 2012, Caucasian births in this country was not in 1st place. We have a debt problem for many reasons, one being Obama allowing welfare for illegals (“minorities”). Sometimes, try reading between the lines, via some common sense (assuming you’re truly educated enough with current events to have any)

  12. xxy:

    Why do so many laws have expiration dates? Do people in Congress enjoy needlessly fighting the same battles over and over?

  13. MAJeff:

    Put down the crack pipe, dude.

  14. Chris Walsh:

    I just can’t imagine Eric Cantor being against it for purpose of it’s title.. who knows anymore. I don’t feel the people are being represented well. I like to have faith in the ones that seem to still work for the people.

  15. fd2:

    “I don’t think this post is supportive of the whole truth. There has to be something substantial within it unsupportive of helping the country in it’s current stricken state.”

    Cool. Name it.

  16. Sly:

    Alex Jones, Men’s Rights Activism, White Nationalism, Xenophobia, and Class Warfare all rolled into one paragraph of stupefying nonsense.

    Bravo.

  17. wjts:

    Solid effort, but needs gold-buggery, UN panic, and some kind of ludicrously specific bête noire (something about NOAA, maybe?) to round out the set.

    B/B-

  18. herr doktor bimler:

    Apparently India is now the goal to strive towards.

  19. L.M.:

    Somewhere in India, right-wing blog commenters are yammering that this is what a real, state-sanctioned war on women looks like.

  20. Ramon A. Clef:

    He’s not. He’s against it because it would be effective.

  21. LeeEsq:

    The sheer amount of stupidity compressed into this one paragraph is staggering. Its almost a thing of beauty of sort.

  22. LeeEsq:

    Women are just as capable of voting against their own interests as working-class white men.

  23. Malaclypse:

    for the first time ever in 2012, Caucasian births in this country was not in 1st place. We have a debt problem for many reasons, one being Obama allowing welfare for illegals (“minorities”).

    I’m just gonna quote this, and walk away, slowly shaking my head at how well stupid, uninformed, and racist all tend to correlate.

  24. anon:

    What is it about tribal jurisdiction that would cause republicans to go through a PR nightmare like this?

  25. Major Kong:

    Does this tinfoil hat make me look fat?

  26. RedSquareBear:

    You’re a racist shit.

    But I do respect that you’re willing to be a racist shit using (apparently) your real name.

  27. RedSquareBear:

    His name is Chris Walsh. His name is Chris Walsh. His name is Chris Walsh.

  28. rea:

    I’s just another word for nothing left to lose . . .

  29. witless chum:

    I think some EMP fear mongering would spice this just right.

  30. rea:

    the department of human services has just purchased a substantial amount of hollow point ammunition. Why? In case of a civil war

    It’s interesting to trace this down, since it’s been an object of some hysteria among the far right (and some far lefties, as well). Turns out thast HHS has 300 armed agents conducting welfare fraud invesigations–they arrest people, and execute search warrants, so they need to be armed. Hollow point bullets are standard law enforcement issue in this country. Most of these rounds get shot off at firing ranges. And of course, this is a standard purchase according to a practice going back decades . . .

  31. witless chum:

    Worried that the Lakota might try Bill Janklow’s corpse for rape?

    Makes as much sense as most things Republicans are worried about.

  32. Sy:

    Isn’t it to be called the “Can’t Live with Them, CAN Shoot Them” act?

  33. Bill Murray:

    You left out the debt idiocy

  34. Bill Murray:

    Janklow had every one taken care of that was involved in that case back in ’75 (Jacinta Eagle Deer) and ’76 (Delphine Eagle Deer). OK Big Bill probably did not have them killed. I hope this covers me against a Janklow family libel suit.

  35. JKTHs:

    But House Republicans insisted the bill is too supportive of immigrants, the LGBT community, and Native Americans

    I’m sure they’re also not too thrilled about its support for black women

  36. Malaclypse:

    From “ChiComs.”

  37. JKTHs:

    Ostensibly to “review” it to see if it’s effective. Of course, that never happened before and now it’s just about hostage taking.

  38. DrDick:

    Down South, we would have called that “teh good old days.”

  39. DrDick:

    Most particularly they support the right of white men to rape Native American women (who suffer the highest rates of rape of any group in the US). The sticking point was provisions to increase federal protections for Native women on reservations (where the federal government has exclusive felony jurisdiction).

  40. DrDick:

    Cantor opposed it because it expanded funding to fight rape on Indian reservations (where the federal government has exclusive felony jurisdiction). That is what he actually said he opposed. Native women have the highest rate of rape of any group and their rapists are overwhelmingly white. Any more questions, cracker?

  41. JL:

    I’d be curious what happens to the “married women” difference after you control for age, sexual orientation, and maybe race. Does anyone know of any analysis on this?

  42. DrDick:

    What is really important here is that the federal government has exclusive felony jurisdiction on Indian reservations under the 1885 Major Crimes Act. Also, tribes do not have any jurisdiction over non-Indians under Oliphant v. Suquamish Indian Tribe and tribal police cannot arrest them or tribal courts try them.

  43. JL:

    There have always been legitimate problems with VAWA, namely that it centers the needs of a subset of women while further marginalizing others. Of course, the version of VAWA that the House Republicans failed to pass would have addressed several of them. Apparently they saw the problems as a feature, not a bug.

    I hope the rape crisis counseling line that I counsel for doesn’t get bit in the ass by this.

  44. Bill Murray:

    and it’s hard to get much crime scene work done, when you have to go 200+ miles to report the crime

  45. basement cat:

    Chemtrails!

  46. njorl:

    Well, if you can’t decrease the gap, decrease the gender.

  47. DrDick:

    Depends on the reservation. There are two federal police agencies responsible for reservation law enforcement. One is the FBI, whose offices are often located far from the reservations. The other is the Bureau of Indian Affairs Police, who are often stationed on the reservations.

    Both agencies have their problems. The FBI often uses assignment to reservation areas (Aberdeen or Flagstaff for instance) as a punishment for troublemakers or as a dumping ground for fuckups. Reservation crime has a low priority and gets only cursory attention and few resources. The BIA Police are notoriously poorly trained, understaffed, and underfunded.

  48. DrDick:

    Must be a slow day over at Stormfront.

  49. Malaclypse:

    Robert Stacy McCain must be very proud of his readers.

  50. mds:

    I’m sure they’re also not too thrilled about its support for black women

    I would say, “Fixed that for you,” but this comment box is too small to contain it. I long for the day when someone coins a pithy shorthand for such a sentiment.

  51. Lee:

    It would be interesting and yes, I’d imagine that a majority of younger, same sex, and non-white married women vote Democatic. However, I also think its a bit non-relevant in that a majority of married women still believe that the GOP represents them better than the Democratic Party.

  52. Dr.KennethNoisewater:

    And we’re all now dumber for having read it.

  53. Dr.KennethNoisewater:

    Yes, and it clashes with your tie.

  54. Just Dropping By:

    Since Janklow is dead, you are probably immune from defamation suits concerning him in any event. (I’m not aware of any state that allows defamation claims based on post-mortem statements about the decedent.)

  55. ajay:

    I’d be curious what happens to the “married women” difference after you control for age, sexual orientation, and maybe race.

    And income!

  56. Woodrowfan:

    WTC7 was never hit by a 747!

  57. Cody:

    The real story here is the oppression of capitalism the US government is performing by purchasing in bulk.

    A real non-communist government would have purchased one bullet at a time, paying increased profit margins to the supplier, to revive the US economy!

  58. Bill Murray:

    Black women voted about 95% for Obama, Latinas ~75% for Obama, white women ~40% for Obama

    Overall, women voted about 10% more for Obama than men did

    http://www.cnn.com/election/2012/results/race/president

  59. Bill Murray:

    Thanks for the info. It might help that one of Janklow’s daughters was kind of sweet on me back in about 1984 or 85

  60. njorl:

    The rambling nature of the paragraph is reminiscent of a crack addict. I knew a guy who would go on like Mark Twain’s “The Story of the Old Ram”, but with even less continuity between thoughts.

  61. RedSquareBear:

    I could have gone for a dash of anti-vax, myself.

  62. Anonymous:

    Yeah, it’s not a real name…like yours.

  63. Speak Truth:

    Turns out thast HHS has 300 armed agents conducting welfare fraud invesigations–they arrest people, and execute search warrants, so they need to be armed.

    No..no..NO!

    As we have all learned here at LGM, guns are not effective protection against bad guys. They just cause more death. Everybody’s safer, including the authorities (think Brits) without guns…

  64. Speak Truth:

    THIS is what women in India are doing to protect themselves.

    Apparently, they didn’t get the word that guns are not effective protection and sometimes even pull their own triggers.

  65. Uncle Kvetch:

    Hey, speaking of breakfast treats, did you know they’ve come out with a bacon-flavored lube? Not for use on pancakes, needless to say.

  66. GeoX:

    Tell me, were you BORN that stupid, or did it just sorta sneak up on you?

  67. Speak Truth:

    it’s good to know that, on the average, my life expectancy is 20 years more than yours.

  68. Speak Truth:

    I went to your blog.

    I counted four (4) comments since November 12.

    Get back to us when you’ve become more interesting.

  69. The Lord God Jehovah:

    I know what you do in men’s rooms, my son. You can’t hide the truth from me. But I love you anyway.

  70. Ahistoricality:

    In the Republican Party, that’s “The Platform”

  71. Dr. Waffle:

    You’re right, Speak Truth: the only effective way to resist oppression, discrimination, and sexism is through widespread gun ownership and the implicit threat of violent reprisal.

    Nothing else has ever thwarted tyranny. Ever.

  72. GeoX:

    Golly gee, so if only I had more blog comments, you might deign to tell me whether or not you’ve ALWAYS been a dimwitted little creep? Can’t say that makes much sense to me, but it’s something to aspire to, I suppose. Or at least it WOULD, it malignancies like yourself were really worthy of that level of scrutiny.

  73. Sherm:

    it’s good to know that, on the average, my life expectancy is 20 years more than yours.

    Only 20 years more? I assumed that a douchebag had a much longer half life.

  74. Uncle Kvetch:

    He must be one of those new ecologically friendly, biodegradable ones. Al Gore would approve.

  75. Malaclypse:

    You should feel sad that Jennie doesn’t troll your site as well.

  76. MAJeff:

    Nah, he’s relying on the lies of Paul Cameron. Remember, dude is obsessed with gay folks. He thinks that the fraudulent research of Paul Cameron (and the fraudsters at the FRC) are telling the truth when saying that gay men die in their 40s…and he’s loving it. Truly a Reaganite, celebrating gay death. Vile monsters, the lot of them. Then again, that’s the conservative movement.

  77. Malaclypse:

    Nah, he’s relying on the lies of Paul Cameron.

    Nah, Jennie is self-hatred all the way down. He don’t need no fancy-pants fake research for that, just good, old-fashioned self-loathing, like his daddy beat into him.

  78. Pseudonym:

    So at least 29% of voters voted for a guy even they admitted didn’t care about them?

  79. LeeEsq:

    I felt that way after the previews were done when I watched the Hobbit.

  80. LeeEsq:

    And at least two or three movies previewed seemed to have the same plot.

  81. Sherm:

    Can we stipulate that he’s both a vile bigot and a douchebag?

  82. MAJeff:

    Can we stipulate that he’s both a vile bigot and a douchebag?

    Movement conservative. Seems to be a given.

  83. Bill Shields:

    Isn’t there anything that lawyers can do to combat this? Up in Surrey, we had some fail-safes put into place, but I don’t know if we can do that in this situation.

  84. MAJeff:

    So, as it has been historically, the problem with America is whiteness.

  85. Origami Isopod:

    Bagger, please.

  86. STH:

    Because he was better than the colored commie, as far as they were concerned. I don’t know that Republicans liked Romney any better than Dems did, they just really, really hate Obama. Voted against him rather than for Romney.

  87. STH:

    FEMA camps!

  88. STH:

    Now I’ve been totally sidetracked by this interesting legal question (ooh! shiny thing!) What about if the defamation diminishes the value of somebody’s estate? Say, if you came forward with convincing evidence that a famous dead person (whose estate is still raking it in for his or her heirs) was a pedophile and it meant that nobody wanted to buy the official branded memorabilia?

  89. ironic irony:

    They’ll never get this married woman. I have a daughter, and I want her to have a better world than I had. So fuck those assholes.

  90. ironic irony:

    There is more money earned by women than men in this country now

    Citation?

    violence against women is not at all tolerated

    Unless those women are Native American, then assholes like Eric Cantor simply don’t give a shit.

Leave a comment

You must be