Subscribe via RSS Feed

This Day in Labor History: November 19, 1915

[ 27 ] November 19, 2012 |

On November 19, 1915, the state of Utah executed I.W.W. organizer Joe Hill for a murder he almost certainly did not commit. But he was an Wobbly and dispensable to society, especially in Utah, a starkly conservative western state outraged by the sheer existence of these radicals.

In 1914, a grocer named John Morrison was shot and killed in a Salt Lake robbery. The same night, Joe Hill went to the hospital with a gunshot wound. He refused to explain anything about why he was shot. Figuring they could easily dispose of both cases, the police pinned Morrison’s death on Hill and charged him with murder. It now seems that Hill was shot by a rival for a woman named Hilda Erickson who was a member of the family who rented Hill a room. Erickson confirmed her relationship with both men in a recently discovered letter. Out of honor, he refused to reveal anything about his injuries, even at the point of death.

Joe Hill was born Joel Hagglund in Sweden, immigrating to the United States in 1902 at the age of 23. This was a common fate for many young Scandinavian men during these years. Hill went to the West Coast. Like most committed Wobblies in the West, Hill drifted from job to job. We first know he was a member of the IWW when he wrote a letter to the Industrial Worker in 1910, identifying himself as working in Portland. By 1912, Hill was in San Diego where he participated in that city’s free speech fight. He flirted with the idea of going to Mexico to fight in the Mexican Revolution, but never did. He bemoaned the introduction of voting machines in California as a hopelessly bourgeoisie reform that would never change anything. In 1913, he moved to Utah, where he worked in copper mining and construction, agitating for revolution among his fellow workers and probably participating in two IWW strikes in Salt Lake that year. During these years, he composed many of the songs that became part of the IWW songbooks used to build solidarity among members and against the horrible conditions they faced in their lives.

By the time Hill was arrested in 1914, the Western forces of order saw the IWW as Enemy Number 1. The West was the Wobbly bread and butter. They had organized heavily in the region’s mining, timber, and agricultural camps and had engaged in free speech fights in cities across the West. Because they organized the region’s most despised workers with no apologies and no compromise, the forces of order–police, courts, politicians, newspapers, and business operators–saw them as scum to be eradicated. The sheer fact that Joe Hill was a Wobbly was enough to charge him with murder.

The Wobblies were excellent propagandists. Because they organized desperate workers with a flair for public attention and because those stories appealed to people interested in labor to the present, we remember certain highlights–Lawrence, Paterson, Joe Hill. But in my research in IWW newspapers, what I’ve seen is very little coverage of many of those events at the time. Lawrence was a small-fry thing in Wobbly news organs until the cops started beating women. Similarly, although we remember Joe Hill as the ultimate Wobbly today, it took awhile for the story of his arrest and trial to get the organization’s attention. There was little interest in his plight during the trial. The local press trumped up the charges, the trial was a farce in which Hill lacked legal counsel, police never found a gun. None of this mattered. Hill was convicted on June 26, 1914 and given the death sentence on July 8.

It was only at this point that Hill’s case came to the attention of the IWW. But when the Wobbly propagandists got their teeth into something, they did not let go. Very quickly the case became a national and international phenomenon. Not only did he become the latest class martyr for the IWW, but progressives and reformers saw his trial as a farce of justice. The Swedish Ambassador got involved in the case and asked President Woodrow Wilson to intercede. Wilson appealed to Utah Governor William Spry for clemency. Spry was not as rock-ribbed conservative as one might assume. Although a Mormon, he was a strong opponent of prohibition. But he would do nothing for Hill.

Hill was a true revolutionary though. He thought most “reform” efforts ridiculous distractions from the real task at hand. Hill saw himself of more value to the revolution as a dead martyr than a living organizer. Like John Brown before him, Hill played this role until the end. He wrote, with some false modesty, to Elizabeth Gurley Flynn bemoaning the amount of resources spent on someone as insignificant as himself. And there’s there’s his famous last telegram, send to Big Bill Haywood reading, “Good-bye Bill. I will die like a true blue rebel. Don’t waste any time in mourning. Organize.”

He even wrote his last will to be sung:

My will is easy to decide,
For there is nothing to divide.
My kin don’t need to fuss and moan,
“Moss does not cling to a rolling stone.”

My body? Oh, if I could choose
I would to ashes it reduce,
And let the merry breezes blow,
My dust to where some flowers grow.

Perhaps some fading flower then
Would come to life and bloom again.
This is my Last and final Will.
Good Luck to All of you,
Joe Hill

In some ways, Hill was right. He was more valuable as a martyr. Hill became the embodiment of IWW martyrdom; hardly the only person to give up his life to state violence and Wobbly repression, Hill’s self-image of martyrdom made him the person other Wobblies looked to for a model of strength and virtue, even as some pointed out his trial did not result from any workplace action. He also became the most famous Wobbly in public memory, perhaps even more than Big Bill Haywood. Had he lived, no one would know who he was. He was just another miner, another working-class person of the early 20th century American West who saw no hope in capitalism and longed for a more just system.

This is the 44th post in this series. The others are digested here.

FacebookTwitterGoogle+Share
  • Sherm

    Figuring they could easily dispose of both cases, they pinned Morrison’s death on Hill and charged him with murder.

    Is that all there is to it? I thought he was set up because he was a Wobbly. Suggested link:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f_yC4ffyGiw

  • Toyboat

    I enjoy reading your labor articles Erik, but is there a malfunction in your word processor? These articles seem to have words missing in quite a few sentences, and the meaning gets mangled. I appreciate your blog, but something is chewing your text up.

  • rea

    I wonder if he could have been convicted, even in Utah in 1914, if he had been willing to testify and/or call witnesses to explain how he came to be shot. While his conviction was unjust, he seems to have been a willing martyr.

  • Simple mInd

    Saw the Joe Hill film in Paris in the 1970’s. Sure removed the blinders.

    • Richard

      Not the greatest movie, though. But I was an extra in it – the director, Bo Wideberg, hired a bunch of hippies from Berkeley to play the miners who get put in the box cars and thrown out in the middle of the desert. I knew a friend of the casting director so me and a few of my friends were cast as nameless workers (on the condition we cut our long hair). We were bused out to the desert and then went through take after take of being pushed out of box cars down a hill. Finally, we said enough and struck for better wages – and got fired. But the footage made it to the final cut.

      • Being fired for striking for better wages on a film about Joe Hill is basically the greatest labor story in history.

        • Richard

          Yes, even back then we considered it supremely ironic

    • I actually have never seen this film.

      • Richard

        I only went to see it to see if I made the final cut and haven’t seen it since then but I recall it as being politically correct but very boring.

        • My willingness to watch boring 70s movies about topics of interest is actually pretty high. I wonder if it is available on DVD.

          • Sherm

            http://www.ioffer.com/i/The-Ballad-of-Joe-Hill-rare-DVD-JOE-HILL-121593925

            I’m not sure if this is the right film, perhaps Richard can confirm.

            • Richard

              Yep, thats the right movie. Directed by Bo Wideberg, most well known for Elvira Madigan, and starring some unknown (at least in this country) Swede.

              • Richard

                So for $23 I can get my entire film career, all twenty seconds of it, on DVD. Hmmmm.

                • Sherm

                  Pull the trigger, Richard.

      • Simple mInd

        I do not recall any boredom. It was riveting.

        • Richard

          I remember it as lifeless but that was 40 years ago. It had a limited release in the US and did no business. I’ll have to see it again to see if my view then holds up

  • bobbyp

    Had he lived, no one would know who he was.

    Well, there were those great songs.

    • Richard

      Except the only song that anyone knows today is the song about his death

      • People know “The Preacher and the Slave,” aka “Pie in the Sky.” Or at least I do, and I’m no kind of expert on old-time labor songs.

        • Richard

          You’re right. I had forgotten he wrote that one. I know it from the Cisco Houston and Pete Seeger versions.

          Still, I Dreamed I Saw Joe Hill Last Night is the ‘Joe Hill” song most people know (and mainly from the Joan Baez performance at Woodstock)

  • atheist

    I love Hill’s will. The image of being transformed into ashes dancing freely in the wind, and being consumed by living things, is a sweet way to look at death.

  • Pingback: Joe Hill | Liblogs()

  • Pingback: What are the odds of violence from the Right in America? | Fabius Maximus()

  • Pingback: On this Labor Day, let’s remember what unions have done for America | Fabius Maximus()

  • [email protected]

    Erik, mention “in a recently discovered letter.” Does this mean the letter was recently discovered, or that Ericksen discovered it late in the “process”? Source for this letter?

    Good article.

  • Pingback: On Labor Day remember those who worked and bled to create the middle class | Fabius Maximus website()

  • Barry Freed

    For some strange reason this post isn’t showing up when I refresh the main LGM page (I only saw it on Twitter).

    And really great post, btw.