Subscribe via RSS Feed

Most Prominent Politicians (VII): Maryland

[ 76 ] June 29, 2011 |

Maryland has a surprisingly lame history of prominent politicians. Given its proximity to the nation’s capital and its relatively high population for a small state, one might expect more from Maryland. The top 10 list is pretty thin and includes some pretty unsavory characters. Supreme Court justices lead us off.

1. Roger Taney–Supreme Court justice notorious for writing the opinion in the Dred Scott case.

2. Thurgood Marshall–not really a politician, but as a Supreme Court justice and gamechanger in American racial history, obviously deserves a high place on this list.

3. Spiro Agnew–it’s always good times to think about Nixon’s hippie-punching and race baiting vice president.

4. Samuel Chase–Supreme Court justice from 1796 to 1811; most famous for being impeached by angry Jeffersonians in 1804.

5. Paul Sarbanes–Senator from 1977 to 2007, making him the longest serving senator in Maryland history. Not really all that prominent but is well-known for cosponsoring the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 which reformed securities law.

6. William Pinkney–Long-term Jeffersonian politician, Attorney General under James Madison

7. Millard Tydings–Senator from 1927-51. Most famous for cosponsoring the Tydings-McDuffie Act of 1934, which provided for the eventual independence of the Philippines and ensured that Filipinos could no longer migrate to the United States. I always loved this law–we gave up colonialism in order to prevent Asian immigration! Tydings was later redbaited by Joe McCarthy and lost the 1950 election because of it.

8. Charles Carroll of Carrollton–signer of Declaration of Independence. The only Catholic to sign and the last surviving signer.

9. Gabriel Duvall–Supreme Court justice from 1811-35. Follower of John Marshall and made little name for himself. Averaged less than one written decision a year (17 written decisions in 24 years).

10. James Pearce–Senator from 1843-62. A Whig who switched to the Democrats after the Whig Party’s decline. Not much of a player. Chairman of the Committee on the Library (!). Did serve as Chairman of the Committee on Finance for 2 months in 1861.

Was it as lame as you expected? Probably lamer.

Next: South Carolina. That ought to be interesting.

Comments (76)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. nitpix says:

    You mean ‘its’, ‘its’, ‘race-baiting’, and Charles Carroll, not John Carroll.

  2. CapnMidnight says:

    Tommy Carcetti! After presiding as mayor of Baltimore over the strange phenomenon of Hamsterdam and the redevelopment of the grain pier, he went on to even greater success on the Small Council of the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros, eventually rising to be Master of Coin to the first two Baratheon kings, and a succesful businessman besides. Now that’s prominence.

  3. Malaclypse says:

    Why was Marshall the only one of the four SC Justices listed to be “not really a politician”? Or did you start with him at #1? I’m just curious how this caveat belongs with just him.

  4. John says:

    Taney and Chase were certainly politicians as well as judges. Not really sure about Duvall.

    Possibly absences:

    Reverdy Johnson, Attorney General under Taylor and a senator, defended Mary Surratt, played by Tom Wilkinson in a recent movie.

    Thomas Hicks, governor in the early years of the Civil War, his prompt action helped keep Maryland in the Union.

    Luther Martin, one of the leading critics of the proposed Constitution at the constitutional convention; also a drunk

    But, yeah, a very weak crop.

  5. Parris Glendening, the governor who implemented the first significant Smart Growth policy in the U.S., and put the concept into the national agenda.

    And who had perhaps the most awesome name of any 20th century political figure.

    • You know, it’s almost as if nobody actually gives a damn about Smart Growth.

      Almost. But, of course, that’s crazy talk.

      Excuse me, sir, can I have a moment of your time to talk to you about zoning reform…hey, where are you going?

  6. Dirty Davey says:

    Are you looking only at national-level political participation?

    At a strictly intramural level there’s something to be said for Baltimore Mayor/ Governor/ Comptroller William Donald Schaefer.

    Also Agnew’s successor in Annapolis, Marvin Mandel–House speaker, chosen by the legislature to replace Agnew (as there was not then a Lt Gov), and then spent time in federal prison before getting the convictions overturned in the 1980s.

    And going back slightly farther, four-term Governor Albert Ritchie (1920-1934), who was somewhat seriously considered for the Democratic presidential nomination in 1924 and was at least somewhat in the running in 1932.

    • Sharon says:

      Marvin and Barbara also got popped trying to spirit antiques from the Governor’s mansion when the Mandels moved out of the Governor’s Mansion after Marvin’s conviction.

      Good times.

      • Dirty Davey says:

        Not Barbara–Jeannie. Barbara was the first wife who stayed in the mansion until the divorce came through. Jeannie Dorsey was who Mandel was having an affair with, who he married the day after the divorce, and who helped “move out” of the mansion.

  7. Malaclypse says:

    Kurt Schmoke, who I think was the first elected politician (meaning Hunter Thompson doesn’t count) to call for an end to the war on drugs.

  8. partisan says:

    Doesn’t Barbara Mikulski deserve something? All female senators before had (a) been widows of male politicins (Carraway, Smith), (b) been the daughter of prominent male politicians (Kassebaum), or (c) defeated after one term (Hawkins).

  9. efgoldman says:

    I understand that you’rr going on Time magazine’s old “Man of the Year” theory – prominent for good or ill (that’s why they named both Hitler and Stalin over the years).
    But Spiro Agnew? Really?
    The man was nothing but a small-time grifter.
    I think of him as the Sarah Palin of the 1960s.

    • Malaclypse says:

      The man was nothing but a small-time grifter.

      I think if you reach the vice-presidency, you qualify as a big-time grifter.

    • Tom Paxton’s “Ballad of Spiro Agnew”:

      “I’ll sing of Spiro Agnew
      And all the things he’s done.”

      That’s it. No second verse. Sometimes he sang it as “And all the good he’s done” which struck me as more accurate. He did a version of it for Reagan as well, with the “all the good things he’s done” line.

      • Definitely believe that which you said. Your favorite justification appeared to be on the net the easiest thing to be
        aware of. I say to you, I definitely get annoyed while people
        consider worries that they just don’t know about.
        You managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal.
        Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

        Feel free to visit my homepage – Check This Out

      • I usually do not leave many remarks, however i did some searching and
        wound up here Most Prominent Politicians (VII): Maryland – Lawyers,
        Guns & Money : Lawyers, Guns & Money. And I do have some questions for you if it’s allright.
        Could it be simply me or does it look as if like some of the comments look like they are coming from brain dead visitors?
        :-P And, if you are posting on other sites, I’d like to keep up with everything new you have to post.
        Would you list of the complete urls of all your communal pages like your linkedin profile,
        Facebook page or twitter feed?

        Feel free to visit my page: check over here

  10. Jay B. says:

    No Barbara Mikulski?

    She’s the longest serving woman senator in history, which is a more notable achievement than anything Pearce did.

    And Thomas D’Alesandro not only had a decent New Dealer record and fought FDR’s conservative Jewish emigration policy during WWII, he also was mayor of B’more and, of course, the former Speaker’s dad.

  11. LuckyJimJD says:

    “Millard Tydings–Senator from 1927-51. Most famous for cosponsoring the Tydings-McDuffie Act of 1934″

    He might be better known these days as the namesake of an otherwise nondescript bridge along I-95 north of Baltimore.

  12. efgoldman says:

    Sarbanes first came to wide attention as a member of the House Judiciary committee for the Watergate hearings. He was one of several members who used the TV time eventually to win higher office.

  13. Humanities Grad says:

    Nice to see Tydings getting a bit of attention.

    It should be noted, though, that the role of racism in the U.S. anti-imperialist movement goes back a lot farther than Tydings-McDuffie. It played a significant role in the debate over whether the U.S. should acquire the Philippines after the Spanish-American War.

    There were two very distinct groups within the anti-imperialist camp. The first group were what I’d call “principled anti-imperialists,” led by Senator George Frisbee Hoar of Massachusetts. Their argument was that the holding of colonies by the United States was in conflict with the values upon which the nation had been founded.

    But there was also a lot of American “antis” who based their opposition to the acquisition of the Philippines explicitly on racial grounds. They were afraid that intercourse (literally) with the Filipinos would pollute the white race. They were also terrified by the possibility that the Philippines might someday be incorporated into the U.S. as a state or as several states, because prior to 1898 almost every bit of land that the U.S. had bought/fought for/stolen had eventually become part of the nation itself. Adding a few million Filipinos to U.S. voter rolls was NOT an idea that appealed to them.

    As far as Tydings-McDuffie goes, I’m sure that the immigration issue played a role in securing its passage, but most narratives on the Act suggest that economic issues were more important. The U.S. was still struggling with the Great Depression, and granting the Philippines their independence would have the effect of pushing the islands outside the U.S. tariff wall. That way, its agricultural products wouldn’t be competing on an equal footing with those of producers in the U.S.

  14. rea says:

    Montgomery Blair, Lincoln’s postmaster general, Dred Scott’s attorney, and prominent Lincoln supporter. His dad, Francis Preston Sr., was also a major political figure, but might be allocated to Kentucky rather than Maryland, despite founding the town of Silver Springs. The third Blair, Francis Preston Jr., gets assigned to Missouri.

    Montgomery Blair was also Montgomery Cliff’s great grandfather.

    • hamletta says:

      It’s “Silver Spring.” Major pet peeve of mine.

      And I concur with the nomination for Barbara Mikulski.

    • Brett Turner says:

      Meh. The Blairs were the worst racists in the 1860s Republican party, almost as bad as the Democrats.

      Montgomery was cast out of Lincoln’s cabinet at the bequest of the Radicals as the 1864 campaign started to get under way, probably as part of a deal to withdraw a potential Radical Republican third-party candidacy. They had limited influence after that.

      Mikulski would be on my list.

    • Erik Loomis says:

      I always think of the Blairs as from Missouri, so that’s a good one that deserves a spot, and probably fairly high given the general lameness.

  15. snarkout says:

    Reverdy Johnson was my suggestion in an earlier comments thread; the first two Secretaries of the Navy, Benjamin Stoddert and Robert Smith, are also possibilities.

  16. Incontinentia Buttocks says:

    How about Mac Mathias? One of the (nationally) leading liberal Republicans in the Senate as liberal Republicanism was dying in the ’70s and ’80s.

    Nor hugely significant, I’ll grant, but perhaps more significant than James Pearce.

  17. Burt Likko says:

    I’d have put Thurgood Marshall ahead of Roger Taney. Yeah, I know Taney was the Chief, and I know that Dred Scott led directly to the Civil War. But Taney isn’t known for much more than that one case these days, and Marshall did more than his part to heal the wounds Taney helped inflict, both as an advocate and as a jurist. Just on a question of wanting to recognize good instead of evil, Marshall should have got the nod for #1.

    • Scott Lemieux says:

      Dred Scott led directly to the Civil War

      Dred Scott was profoundly immoral, but it had essentially nothing to do with the Civil War happening. The result of deciding the case correctly would have been that the war would have happened sooner (cf. the 1860 election), and had the Court not done anything the Democratic coalition would have collapsed over Lecompton and other issues in any case (which is why Buchanan and the Democratic leadership in Congress wanted the Court to intervene.)

  18. cpinva says:

    fortunately for south carolina, prominent doesn’t mean a positive influence. if it did, you might well have to skip the state entirely.

  19. Jestak says:

    Reverdy Johnson was one alternative possibility I came up with. Another was John Eager Howard, Revolutionary War general, Governor and Senator during the early national period and Vice-Presidential nominee for the Federalists in 1816.

  20. Vance Maverick says:

    Is there a tag or rubric link for this excellent series? If not, there should be….

  21. Jim Lynch says:

    As a native San Franciscan, I shudder to consider some-if-not-most of the worthies from California that will be included in your listing of Golden State politicians.

  22. ScottC says:

    Pinkney, Duval, and Pearce over Reverdy Johnson, Montgomery Blair, and Luther Martin? I disagree. But I certainly agree with the assessment that Maryland has produced a peculiarly short list of prominent politicos, and that Taney & T. Marshall should top this list.

  23. jafd says:

    Surprised that no one’s mentioned Rep. George H. Fallon of Baltimore, chairman of the Subcommittee on Roads in the House Committee on Public Works in 1955-56, and leading shaper of the compromise that became The Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956.

    It’s probable that the Interstates would have gotten built sooner or later, and the question of whether they were paid for from long-term bond issues, or ‘as-you-go’ from gas and tire taxes is historical trivia today. Certainly Senators Prescott Bush and Al Gore, Sr, the leading spokesmen for their parties’ positions on this question, might be surprised at the place this holds in their historical memory. (Speculation on what Al Jr. might say to his father, given a time machine, is left to my fellow LGM denizens.)

  24. anonymous says:

    Chris Van Hollen is pretty darn good, and he’s young enough that eventually he might be considered sufficiently “historical” for this sort of list. (Note,though, he wasn’t born or raised in Maryland.)

  25. Subnumine says:

    William Wirt, Monroe’s Attorney-General, prosecutor of Burr, lawyer for the Cherokees, third party candidate for president.

    Surely more important than the SOB Chase, whose malice exceeded his competence. He didn’t do much to the Democrats, except in not being removed after his impeachment.

  26. Yesterday, while I was at work, my sister stole my apple ipad
    and tested to see if it can survive a twenty five foot drop, just so she can
    be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83 views.
    I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with
    someone!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • Switch to our mobile site