BSG Finale
By I have deeply ambivalent feelings about Television Without Pity. I think that too much of their criticism comes off as too-clever-by-half fanboy posturing (Worst. Episode. Ever). Nevertheless, I rather enjoy some of their summaries, and I think that Jacob did a very good job with the second season finale of BSG.
Also check out this analysis by piny. I can’t say that I agree with piny, but it’s interesting nonetheless.